Yeah, that's not how it works
Would remaking TOS episodes make you upset?
- Thread starter eschaton
- Start date
Correct, thats exactly how it works.
Nope. It's fiction.
Nope. Same universe after multiple alterations by way of the Temporal Cold War. That's the canon. Anything else is wishful thinking.
Nope. Same universe after multiple alterations by way of the Temporal Cold War? Canon shows that it ~ends up~ in a same/similar place, not that the events between them are static. In my opinion, the Temporal Cold War was lots of little course corrections until things were restored to a place that could be recognized by the end of the events of First Contact.
That answer/excuse literally works the same way in support of what I say, as well. lol.
Exactly. It's fiction. So what ever the folks in charge say it is, is what it is. Because they write the stuff.
If someone wants to make a "Murder Board" to figure it all out, more power to them.
No. With all the time travel that happened, SNW should actually be in an Alt timeline or at least the prime timeline that actually was altered by all the time travel that happened. This would allow them to remake some stories a bit differerent. It shouldn't be overdone, but as an anniversary special or something.
That's the answer to all these interminable arguments. Anyone who doesn't get it can argue until they're green in the face, but they don't own it and can't dictate what is and what isn't.
Tomorrow, Tomorrow, Tomorrow absolutely sets in stone that we are watching an alt timeline.
Nope.
Still the Prime Timeline, though.
entire time periods changed, dates changed, interference that wasn't there before..... you can say nope, but the argument holds no water. It was extremely clear. The events referenced in TOS did not happen that way anymore. The entire timeline has been changed, thus explaining another thousand discrepancies.
maybe still the Prime Universe, but the timeline has been completely altered. Same canvas, different art.
Timeline has been changed multiple times by multiple series. Timeline still seems corrects itself. Strange New Worlds is just following what was previously established most recently. That World War 3/The Eugenics war was in the early 21st century, as established in TNG and further cemented in place by both First Contact and Enterprise.
Nah. It doesn't work that way. The "timeline" is an artificial construct for story telling. Any "alterations" are limited to what ever story being told.
Um yeah, they alternate timeline happened back in TNG.
They are in the I-Chaya dies timeline.
Last edited:
Similar threads
