• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Game The Most Disliked Fourth Season Episode, 2025 Edition

Saving "HOME".

Great followup to their Xindi arc, it does for ENT what "Family" did for TNG.


VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Waking Moments"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "The Aenar"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Divergence"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Kobayashi Maru"
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rubicon"
 
I'm going to save Enterprise's "Divergence", the epic explanation for why Klingons didn't have ridges for a bit. There are many reasons why I'd choose it above all those other stories, but the main one is the scene where Trip has to climb from Columbia to Enterprise during warp.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Waking Moments"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "The Aenar"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Kobayashi Maru"
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rubicon"
 
DIS: "Kobayashi Maru" The butterfly people try to liberate Booker's queen.


VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Waking Moments"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "The Aenar"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rubicon"
 
I'll finish up saving that story arc by choosing ENT: "The Aenar" Not the strongest episode, but it was nice to see Andoria on screen and introduce the Aenar.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Waking Moments"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rubicon"
 
"Waking Moments" is one of those guilty pleasure episodes I love. It's so stupid - an entire race that spend all of their lives asleep! - but in the right way.

And the unbelievable obviousness of the trap, that the crew just blunders idiotically right into. The Voyager crew was rarely stupider.

I'm also properly OBSESSED with "Night Terrors" on TNG, so I appreciate this as the (extremely) poor man's version.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rubicon"
 
If I needed more of a reason to save Rubicon other than gracing us with the return of the wonderful Nhan then it would probably be that sense of hopelessness when the second DMA just pops right back up. Really raised the stakes.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Affliction"
ENT: "Divergence"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
Saving "AFFLICTION".

Great two-parter for ENT. I love their explanation for the Klingons, even if it wasn't needed.


VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Borderland"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
"Borderland" has such a good prequel feel to it. Space feels really dangerous in this one. I love the thing with the new recruit freaked out to be immediately abducted by the Orions.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Augments"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
This list has pretty effectively reduced to my personal least favorites. There's only 5 remaining that I personally would hate to see as winners, the other 15 I all think are win-worthy.
 
I'm going to jump to the other side of the three-parter and save "The Augments", because it's always fun when the villains get frustrated that Archer and his weak primitive spaceship are somehow still coming after them.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
VOY: "Demon"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
Demon singular. I liked the silver blood as a concept and exploring as exotic planetary classification was fun. It also remembered that Voyager has to keep on top of its energy reserves. Granted we can assume that stocking up and mining happened regularly but it would be a largely boring episode but you could make a slice of life bottle episode out of it.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Cold Station 12"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
Saving "COLD STATION 12".

The other two parts were already saved, andvI loved all parts of this trilogy.


VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Random Thoughts"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
I honestly didn't expect Demon to get saved before Demons. I thought people liked the Terra Prime two-parter and wanted it to be the finale! :p
Simply a matter of time... it's ultimately why I haven't gotten to several others yet. (There are 3 episodes left I would pick as 'worst'. Most people here can probably guess what at least one of them is.)

I can defend "DEMON", because it is a suitably creepy episode and has a great vibe and atmosphere. As a horror fan, that goes far with me. And it gave Kim something.

Plus it sets up an excellent followup with "COURSE: OBLIVION".
 
Random Thoughts is next, what a fascinating idea for a race of telepaths that has a black market for dark memories.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "The Forge"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
I already saved the end of Enterprise's The Forge three-parter, so I suppose I should save "The Forge" as well. Even if it did blow Admiral Forrest up.

Enterprise's most prominent ongoing storyline, the relationship between Earth and Vulcan, had gotten stuck in a bit of a rut, but this started pushing it forward in a big way. Plus it was also a good story.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
DIS: "Rosetta"

Edit: I put Rosetta back on as it seemed to have just fallen off the list.
 
Oh well I have to save "Rosetta" then. I loved all that stuff on the planet graveyard in this one.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "Terra Prime"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
I honestly didn't expect Demon to get saved before Demons. I thought people liked the Terra Prime two-parter and wanted it to be the finale! :p
I've never been able to feel the love for Demons/Terra Prime. It reminds me of some shows I worked on that got cancelled, and then the writers and cast just phone in the episodes we still have to shoot to complete the order.

Something that always happens in those episodes: the series regulars we thought were bad, who no one ever wanted to write for, are suddenly getting screentime, because the writers don't care anymore and the leads don't want to work. That's what came to mind when I saw that Demons/Terra Prime suddenly had material for Mayweather, for the first time in years.

And the fact that it ends with Trip & T'Pol crying over their dead baby! That does not make a satisfying end to a series!

Honestly (controversial opinion incoming)... I think TATV makes a better finale than that. And I haaaaaaaate TATV.
 
Last edited:
Saving "TERRA PRIME".

I said it was only a matter of time a few posts ago, and I meant it. For me, THIS is the real finale... not that episode which followed.

A great speech by Archer when he addressed everyone at the end, too.


VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Awakening"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
Last edited:
I'm saving ENT: "Awakening", the final part of the Vulcan trilogy to go. I love that Trip and Soval work together to save the day, so to speak, and T'Pol coming to terms with her mother's choice to join the Syrranites.

VOY: "Revulsion"
VOY: "Hunters"
VOY: "Retrospect"
VOY: "Vis à Vis"
VOY: "Unforgettable"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part I"
ENT: "Storm Front, Part II"
ENT: "Daedalus"
ENT: "Bound"
ENT: "Demons"
ENT: "These Are The Voyages..."
DIS: "Anomaly"
DIS: "The Examples"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top