My only real problem is that Q's story with Picard and the Enterprise D hit such a perfect conclusion in All Good Things that a followup, no matter how entertaining, would feel a bit anti-climatic.
It was tricky for TNG because with that issue and the Borg being done in First Contact, there weren't many TNG antagonists that wouldn't feel a little small scale on the big screen. I would have loved to see Sela or Tomalak in film, but I'm realistic enough to conclude that the casual movie audience would not have been blown away by either.
A reconstructed Lore could have potentially worked, and as far as "evil version of the main character" movie villain, would at least have played a little better than Shinzon anyway.
It was tricky for TNG because with that issue and the Borg being done in First Contact, there weren't many TNG antagonists that wouldn't feel a little small scale on the big screen. I would have loved to see Sela or Tomalak in film, but I'm realistic enough to conclude that the casual movie audience would not have been blown away by either.
A reconstructed Lore could have potentially worked, and as far as "evil version of the main character" movie villain, would at least have played a little better than Shinzon anyway.
