• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The War Games -- colororized

Look, lets remember the omnibus is not meant to be the definitive take on this story. Its definitely not going to replace the original serial in any way, be it canonicity or whatever. Its meant to be an easy intro to newer fans who get into Who through DisneyWho, or start watching NuWho on streaming and want access to old stories as an apetizer.

Also, I don't think the season 6B theories were at all discounted by this edit. Indeed, that concept in itself is an edit, of the Second Doctor's fate after all. So, I would not lose my sleep over this. The splinter Second Doctor is still out there.

Great reminder!

It's still okay to recognize that it's a new take and not a replacement, which is great, while watching the new and alternate take and to point out what is liked or not about it as some changes were cool or cute or whatever to go along with what a viewer might also disagree with (for this and original story, both versions have triumphs and nitpickerying). Plus, it opens the door for future showrunners to re-edit older stories to make them more interesting to modern audiences. There's a whole universe of possible alterations and improvements.
 
My problem with modern Who dealing with old stuff is that they leave it ambiguous. They play around with answering big mysteries such as the Doctor's name,

Which was corny enough when "The Mysterious Planet" tried it, in a way that was also so far beneath and unworthy of scriptwriter Robert Holmes' talents... but it is some proof that old stuff was dealt and played with even "back then".

past lives,

Draaaaaaaama! And plot fodder too! The 70s set up a lot of hoops and hurdles for cheap dramatic points, and then came the 80s that dug into it even more. "Mawdryn Undead" and "The Five Doctors" utilizing the idea the most effectively, better than the 70s since I've retried watching key stories that set up regenerations and all and the 70s do suck eggs in that regard (more on that later), but the 80s are when the show looked too far inward for ideas, though even then sequels with established monsters is always more preferable to regurgitating the identical plot elements over and over (e.g. Silver Nemesis = Remembrance of the Daleks being an easy example of this, and Nemesis had JNT ordering retakes and putting his foot down on ideas as he deemed they would do the show a disservice...)

where he's from,

Raaaaaaaaaatings graaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaab! Amusingly, apparently, "The War Games" was supposed to be a bookend - in case the show was to be dropped. Star Trek took over Doctor Who's timeslot, but the show got renewed with hopes that an exile, tighter scripts, avoiding the production problems season 6 had, etc, would lead to greater success. Which it didn't but were given one more chance, hence season 8's format changes and the Master was exactly what the Doctor ordered (see what I did there, it's soooo clever like how it never was? :guffaw: )

human side

Draaaaaaaaaaaaaaama! (and, yup, this one was incredibly hokey too. The hokiest and laziest. Topped off with sappy 4th wall comedy by interchanging clips with Frankenstein (har har) with a MadTV actor to ensure the audience it's all played up as a joke, it all proved the 1996 movie has far more in common with the 21st century revival/reboot than the McCoy era ostensibly had.)

etc.
But they never give a definitive answer. By touching on the lore without answers they're just adding more confusion to it.

I think they want to try to answer one thing but make something new that remains vague, for the sake of keeping the character "mysterious". While "The War Games", likely due to budget constraint, kept some ambiguity about the Time Lords, the 1970s were increasingly quick to dive right in for plot opportunities. After changing regeneration from a TARDIS function to being biological, then imposing a limit to the number of times it can be done, and expanding the home planet's lore with "Celestial Intervention Agency" and other campy nonsense that actually makes most 80s camp (prior to 1987, certainly) nullified as a result, some of today's complainers would surely have to concede the 70s were also doing this demystifying deconstruction pretty badly too.

Problem is, after so much diving into the pool of demystifying, remystifying then has to occur. Assuming audiences still care since wallowing in continuity only works for a certain period before the return on exploring the origins falls flat. A reboot can arguably bypass all of this, though a rose by any other name smells the same - ditto for a skunk, even if your pet skunk is called "Perfumella" and never had its stink glands removed. Whatever that means I no longer know because the smell generally has to change with a reboot to make it feel 'original' again despite it being the same name, then add in decades' worth of produced material and things only begin to get a little bit exponentially complicated. It's why we got Babylon 5, Firefly, and Firescape as original tv shows instead of "the third time Blake's 7 got a reboot". That's all I'd know or guess.
 
Some clips...

The intro...
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

The War Chief sees The Doctor. Saxon Master theme included.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

The War Chief's death, with regeneration sound (and Saxon Master music) added.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

My least favorite alteration is the inclusion of modern Doctors, complete with their sonic screwdrivers, being shown as the faces the Doctor can choose from.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

And the new regeneration sequence...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Last edited:
I really don't think that the other Doctor cameos make much sense. If they had kept it to classic Doctors maybe, but Capaldi's face was specifically taken from someone The Doctor wouldn't meet until after the Time War, and its not random because those are all future Doctors.

So logically the Time Lords of the 2nd Doctors era must have very far advanced future knowledge, including of the Time War, because its not like Capaldi's face was something The Doctor would have turned into if he hadn't had a very specific set of adventures.
 
I really don't think that the other Doctor cameos make much sense. If they had kept it to classic Doctors maybe, but Capaldi's face was specifically taken from someone The Doctor wouldn't meet until after the Time War, and its not random because those are all future Doctors.

No sense at all, apart from arguably another attempt to tie in Classic with New and even then there've been better ways in Modern Who that had done it already. It's really just the Doctor being forced to change, here are some options, they're all his very distant future and nobody else, he spits out sarcastically "What an incredible bunch!" (read; Not in a good way, the Doctor hating his own future in the GOAT of all unintentional 4th wall gags ever put out). Also, the original and as-intended version got it right when going for, in part because "I'm well known on (Earth)!" means you don't whip out the play-doh and force him to look like someone who will become known as well.

I'd read a couple people posting "Why not have Pertwee in there before 'that won't do at all!' and the time lords force him to become Pertwee".

So logically the Time Lords of the 2nd Doctors era must have very far advanced future knowledge, including of the Time War, because its not like Capaldi's face was something The Doctor would have turned into if he hadn't had a very specific set of adventures.

Or advanced past knowledge as well, but I don't buy for one second it was this trial that caused the Doctor to have his past memories taken either - made more sense that, given what Hartnell said from the start, that whatever event caused that level of memory loss would have happened when he and Susan left Gallifrey.
 
True, but one change from the original video that I thought was a nice touch was including the arrival of the Nestene Consciousness asteroids from the beginning of Spearhead from Space.

For every silver lining there's a big murky teal-hued cloud. Or teal-orange... 🤪 Or one so inconsistently recolored that so many costumes and sets were left untouched (War Chief not wearing maroon? Great opportunity missed. Or the War Room's alternate backlit walls are also untouched, lighting and all, and if "surrealism" is a descriptor, it's probably not in the "60s surreal" way.)

Never mind the loud klaxon upon the War Lord's arrival was blotted out by new and tacky incidental muzak, dulling his introduction that much more.

Nitpickery aside, there were a lot of subtle details that got great attention -- the War Lord's glasses are done extremely well. I wouldn't quite say "red" unless it's "rose", since that's a 4th wall gag regarding the adage "wearing rose-tinted glasses", at least from the villain's perspective. That or it's jade-tinted glasses but the War Lord has enough elements of both, from his POV, that either works. But being the surreal sixties, one could have been tinted rose, the other jade, and show him off like wearing a poor pair of 3D glasses as yet another 4th waller as audiences love those, right?
 
I'd read a couple people posting "Why not have Pertwee in there before 'that won't do at all!' and the time lords force him to become Pertwee".
My favorite joke idea is just having different photos of David Tennant. Tenth Doctor, too young. Fourteenth Doctor, too old. Dobby Doctor, too thin, metacrisis Doctor, that won't do at all...

Or maybe do the Curse of Fatal Death Doctors, or the Morbius Doctors... There are better options that make more sense in-universe and are funnier in-jokes. Even the (other) fan-edit that had the same idea was better for filtering the photos so they looked more like the original hand-drawn sketches.
 
My favorite joke idea is just having different photos of David Tennant. Tenth Doctor, too young. Fourteenth Doctor, too old. Dobby Doctor, too thin, metacrisis Doctor, that won't do at all...

Or maybe do the Curse of Fatal Death Doctors, or the Morbius Doctors... There are better options that make more sense in-universe and are funnier in-jokes. Even the (other) fan-edit that had the same idea was better for filtering the photos so they looked more like the original hand-drawn sketches.
Both these ideas would've been better than what we got.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Okay, it looks like the lights were colourized, just not the partition panels, beyond the red scaffolding/edges.
 
The Time Lords being able to know what future incarnations look like has been alluded to with the "Eighth Man Bound" game from the novels, but then if they can do it with tech the game is a bit redundant.

Recent novels have also had "probability engines" that can view possible futures, but again the various prophets seen (like the one in The End Of Time) would be out of a job if they were up to snuff.
 
The inconsistent colouring did occasionally give Troughton some rather odd eyes. Like he was in some eyeshadow at a couple of points.
 
The Time Lords being able to know what future incarnations look like has been alluded to with the "Eighth Man Bound" game from the novels, but then if they can do it with tech the game is a bit redundant.

Recent novels have also had "probability engines" that can view possible futures, but again the various prophets seen (like the one in The End Of Time) would be out of a job if they were up to snuff.

The idea of regeneration possibility being almost coded into the genes is workable. Or at least was, until the modern era. Everything from Capaldi on is a new regeneration cycle, and the mistake of using promo shots make it seem like he now also knew his clothing in advance… ah well, maybe it explains why Jodie had such a terrible outfit.

It would have been far subtler if they had shown the actors in other roles or out-of-costume shots. But, this was not a subtle project.
 
Also doesn't tie with the "never know what I'm gonna get" lines we've had from 9 on, unless the Doctor means they know the faces but not the order? Which implies we might get two-head or no-head Doctor someday.
 
I've seen at least one headline claiming the changes in the colorized/trimmed version are additions to Doctor Who "canon," but I'd say it's just the opposite -- since it's an alternative edit of the canonical story, that makes it non-canonical. And it's not like DW has ever had a clearly defined canon anyway, or bothered much with internal continuity.
 
Wasn't there a joke or something a while back pointing out one of the potential future faces actually did resemble one of the future Doctors? I think it was Davison, but don't hold me to that. Anyway, if they had wanted to include actual future Doctors for that sequence, including Davison (or whichever one it was) in place of that face is what I would have done.
 
I've seen at least one headline claiming the changes in the colorized/trimmed version are additions to Doctor Who "canon," but I'd say it's just the opposite -- since it's an alternative edit of the canonical story, that makes it non-canonical. And it's not like DW has ever had a clearly defined canon anyway, or bothered much with internal continuity.
Doctor Who has no problem tossing canon whenever it's convenient.
 
“And the new regeneration sequence...”

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


Having the chronometer blink between 1970 and 1980 refers to how hard it is to nail down the UNIT-centric stories to come?

I wonder if you could retcon this as another type of “containment” for the Doctor…
 
I've seen at least one headline claiming the changes in the colorized/trimmed version are additions to Doctor Who "canon," but I'd say it's just the opposite -- since it's an alternative edit of the canonical story, that makes it non-canonical. And it's not like DW has ever had a clearly defined canon anyway, or bothered much with internal continuity.
Absolutely. The original story is the canonical story and this is just a fun aside. Something to have fun with the old fans and hopefully attract a few new fans to the classic show in the process. The whole bit with the Saxon Master music was absolutely a fun little wink and a nudge to the fans and their long time theories and conversations, but it didn't canonize any fan theories about the War Chief and the Master.
Having the chronometer blink between 1970 and 1980 refers to how hard it is to nail down the UNIT-centric stories to come?
Sure. It's just another fun little nudge nudge wink wink at the fans. They did something similar in Day of the Doctor when Kate mentions a file that would be found under either the '70s or the '80s, depending upon the dating protocol used.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top