• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers "Superman & Lois" Season 3

I didn't enjoy this much. I'm so tired of Doomsday. The character was a stupid, shallow idea to begin with in the '90s. A mindless brute is not a worthy adversary for Superman, who's defined by far more than just his physical strength. Besides, they already did a "Death of Superman" mini-arc last season, so what's the point of doing Doomsday now? (Although I am amused that the "fakeout" of early season 2, when we thought Bizarro was Doomsday, turned out to be foreshadowing instead. I wonder, did they plan it that way all along, or did they just decide after the fact that it would be cute?)

And why the heck didn't Jordan and the Steel duo come to Superman's rescue? They just stood there when they could've helped. It would've been nice if Lex's plan had failed because he hadn't anticipated Superboy coming to the rescue.

The worst part by far, though, was Superman making the ruthless decision to kill Doomsday by impaling him on that spire, and not seeming bothered by it afterward. That's not a line he should cross. (And how did that even work? Surely Doomsday's flesh was as impenetrable as Superman's. He should've crushed the spire, not been pierced by it.)

Then there's the characters' ridiculously good aim when wildly punching each other. Doomsday backhands Superman in the farm, and out of the entire 360 degrees around them, he goes in exactly the direction that lands him on Main Street. They battle in midair, and coincidentally land right in Metropolis instead of anywhere in the vast swaths of sparsely populated land that make up most of Kansas. Then they go fight in space, and out of all the infinite directions they could go, they end up on the Moon. Okay, granted, that time it looked like Superman might have aimed him that way intentionally -- although aiming directly for something is not the way to reach it in orbital mechanics, because it's a moving target.

Also, the Moon apparently has air in this universe, since you can hear Doomsday's roars and Superman's cape was flapping. Maybe there are some nearby astronauts that they can ask for directions to planet Houston.

This episode did nothing to make Lex Luthor a more interesting or dimensional character, continuing to have him just be a brutal, vengeful thug. And I'm deeply sick of TV depicting long scenes of torture.

The rest didn't do much for me either. It was mostly just tying off loose ends of the character arcs and felt like going through the motions. And TV has got to stop doing stories about unplanned pregnancies as if it were some kind of romantic thing. It's grossly irresponsible for men not to be careful about contraception, since a pregnancy can ruin a woman's life if she doesn't want it or isn't financially or emotionally ready for it. So it just makes male protagonists look bad when that happens (and yes, I'm glaring at you, Star Trek Picard season 3). By the same token, I'm also not a fan of surprise public marriage proposals, which feel like emotional blackmail to trap the woman into saying yes rather than disappoint the spectators. Okay, Chrissy didn't hesitate to say yes, but that was the writers' choice to make her react that way. Realistically, it could've gone the other way.

Even aside from all that, is it wise for Kyle to rush into marriage again? It didn't turn out that great the first time. Both marriage and parenting are things that both participants should discuss and consider with care rather than just leaping into them. Though I guess we don't know if we'll even see these characters again, at least not much.

It just really frustrates me that this season gave us the series's best, most complex villain, then cut off his arc early so they could do this extended prologue to season 4, when they didn't even know if they'd get a season 4. Honestly, given the politics of the people who own Warner Bros. now, I can't help wondering if there was a racial element to that decision -- or to the decision to remove every nonwhite actor from the regular cast next season.
 
I was thinking during the whole episode that it was a real left-turn in terms of quality. Halfway through, I was wondering the thing I mentioned about when the production learned they were having their budget slashed, because the vibe I was getting was less "Season 3 finale" and more "Season 4 prequel" with all the shake-ups.
 
I was thinking during the whole episode that it was a real left-turn in terms of quality.

Yeah, and there was so much they didn't even resolve. Jordan patched things up a bit with Sarah, but the whole thing of his reckless showing off and his anger at being grounded for it was left unresolved. And it's still uncertain where Jon stands with Kyle now, and we may never know.


Incidentally, since this was a Bizarro Doomsday, should we call it Yadsmood?
 
That finale basically cemented why this show needs to end, be cancelled, next season. It was super cheesy.

About 40 minutes of CW soap opera dialogue, and then 10 minutes of some really goofy sfx beyond the scope of what this show can pull off.

It's time to let Superman Legacy take the torch.


IMO the rumor of Lex nuking Smallville was a far more interesting concept than doing another Doomsday take. It would have been like the Arrow S1 finale when they blew up The Glades, or the Arrow S5 finale when they blew up the island. Something with real stakes that could potentially kill off some of the characters.
 
I liked the episode. I also think I know how next season is going to go. All our characters have left Smallvile and have gone into hidden due to the fact that Lex Luthor is going to want to kill everyone close to him. Superman is assumed dead. Jordan has become Superboy for real to replace the gap in the world of no Superman but still also has to be careful to avoid Lex. Henry Irons leads a mission to recover Supermans body on the Moon and the find he has come back to life and will be wearing the black outfit. He also knows he has to stop Lex Luthor so everyone can return home though for many even returning home will be different because Lana can't just stop being mayor and go back to that. Chrissy and Kyle might not have jobs waiting for them back in Smallville or Kyle might not be able to see his daughters in awhile inf they are with Lana. Throughout the season we would catch up to what they are doing while in hiding.
 
Some random thoughts regarding season 3:

I serve in a cancer center in a large metropolitan area. I'm a chaplain/counselor/therapist and I work with patients who have been diagnosed with various kinds of cancers and am with them from diagnosis, to radiation and/or chemo, to surgery and beyond. I lead support groups for patients, for caregivers, and for the bereaved, as well as serving the needs of individual patients. In many cases I have worked with women with the diagnosis given Lois this season.

Sometimes this season was difficult to watch because it was very, very realistic as far as Lois' story was concerned. Bitsie Tulloch's performance was absolutely pitch perfect, and in a different series she would be recognized during awards season. From her shock at the diagnosis, to her putting off treatment at first, to her withdrawing from family and then letting them back in, to her "chemo brain", to her anxiety regarding her mastectomy and her relationship with her body afterwards, to her steps toward reexploring intimacy with her spouse, the writing, directing and performance was incredibly real and moving. Kudos to Tyler Hoechlin as well for his sensitive performance.

I cannot commend this season enough for capturing a glimpse of what this journey can be. I am so glad they did not take an easy out and provide a Kryptonian cure. If the entirety of this season had just been Lois' story, this season would have been much stronger and better served without the coda involving Luthor and Doomsday---which would have been better suited to be the opening gambit for season 4.
 
Doomsday? Seriously? It didn't make sense in the comics and it didn't make sense here. Bizarro gets stronger every time he's killed? Oy vey.

Meanwhile, still damn impressed with Bitsie and her performance as Lois. Beautifully done.
 
I can't say I was all that happy to see Doomsday again, either. At least, for now anyways, I still like how they used him over how he was used on Smallville and Batman vs Superman at least. So their is at least that.
 
Superman and Lois
Season 3 finale - Episode 13 - "What Kills You Only Makes You Stronger"


The episode begins with a montage of Smallville life on the eve of summer, including Lois' cancer journey continuing, Jonathan gaining more experience as part of the firehouse crew, Irons and Lana appearing to grow closer, Sam is dating Gretchen...and then there's Jordan, just as bitter as ever, angrily crumpling a photo of himself with Sarah...

SM/Clark / Lois I: At the farm, Sam, Clark and Lois wonder what Luthor's next move will be; the criminal has not been seen in some time, which worries Lois--as you'd expect. Sam tries to ease Lois' nerves with an assumption that Luthor would need to go through him--and Superman--to get to her.

The twins have volunteered to help with Smallville's meteor shower celebration; the still-pissy Jordan complains about not being able to use his powers, which is flattened by Clark calmly reminding Jordan that he should have gone home (as he was ordered) and not taken selfies with citizens. Sam warns that Clark and Lois should not allow Jordan's anger fester for too long, using his past relationship to Lois as an example.

Kyle / Chrissy: Chrissy tells Kyle she's pregnant, lamenting the fact they're not married, or live together. Kyle is surprised, but happy about having another child (considering it the best that's happened since they first kissed), although his joy screeches to a halt when Chrissy wonders what Lana will think...

At Lana's, Kyle lets the family know about the pregnancy. Lana is a bit stunned, but says she's happy for Kyle, though she seems to take the announcement as much of a closed chapter on her old life as the divorce papers....

Irons / Lana / Natalie I: At Lana's Irons' diagnostic scan detects something...but he's not sure its anything too concerning (whoops). Lana mentions Irons not being around much (the Manheim situation), and thanks him for all he's done to help her throughout recent times, with the conversation moving toward Irons in a roundabout fashion--asking an enthusiastic Lana out.

Later, as Irons seeks clothing advice from Natalie, Sam visits with some big news: the D.O.D. is so impressed with Irons' weapons, that they want him to design more--which means relocating to Metropolis (SEE NOTES). Irons has to consider what it all means (and make a decision sooner than later), while Natalie wonders if she can attend the D.O.D. academy...with Matteo.

SM/Clark/Lois II: Lois calls for Clark, appearing concerned, but she has decided she's ready to be intimate with her husband again--right at that moment. Flying to what appears to be a picturesque villa in Italy, Lois--wearing a bathrobe--slowly approaches Clark, telling him how nervous she is. Clark reassures her she has no reason to be, as the sexual side of their relationship is rekindled (SEE NOTES).

Returning to the farm, Clark and Lois excitedly tell the boys about their plans for family vacation in Italy; the twins sense there's something behind their parents' giddy behavior, but have no problem accepting the offer.

Chrissy informs the Kents about her pregnancy, but they're called back to Metropolis when Clark learns judge Reagen has been murdered--her corpse left on the street. Lois is certain its a message from Luthor--that one by one, anyone responsible for his incarceration will die.

The Kent family: The twins and Natalie are introduced to Gretchen, Sam's new girlfriend (SEE NOTES). At the diner, the boys discuss Gretchen--and the Irons' possible move to Metropolis with their parents. Clark suggests they'd save money if the super-half of the family flies everyone to Italy. Jordan questions why he's allowed to use his powers for a vacation and not helping people, but Clark reminds him that selfies and attention are not why he should use his powers. His true north should be making the world a better place.

Sarah attempts to take the Kent's orders, but Jordan is so hateful to her, that she quickly walks off, leaving Clark and Lois rather stunned by Jordan's behavior. Clark gets Jordan to admit his feelings for Sarah are not as intense as they were before the break-up, and that he has no reason to be nasty to her. Clark prods the boy to make things right, which starts with Jordan apologizing to Sarah. While Sarah accepts the apology, she believes they should not try to be friends, but she hopes he straightens his life out.

Irons / Lana / Natalie II: Lana and Irons talk Chrissy, Kyle and Metropolis: Lana is happy for Kyle, feeling they are better as friends than they were as a couple (which was based on shared history more than anything else). Irons is somewhat conflicted and apologetic when telling Lana about the D.O.D. offer, but Lana seems okay with what that offers means. Instead of breaking things off, Lana says she's going to make Irons wish he was not moving, leading to the couple to have sex in the bar's restroom (SEE NOTES).


Luthor / Bizarro aka Doomsday / Otis / Warden Ellis I:
Sam and Gretchen take a slight detour from the town's meteor viewing set-up; using a ruse of wanting to have some alone time with Sam, he turns to see Otis (with his right ear bandaged - SEE NOTES), but is shocked into unconsciousness by Gretchen's stun gun. Sam is apprehended....

Flashback: 33 days earlier, Bizarro attacked Otis, biting off his ear (a cheat!), but was killed by one of Luthor's advanced weapons. Luthor, Otis, Gretchen and another henchman repeatedly kill Bizarro, who miraculously revives stronger than the previous life. Luthor uses the psychological tool of promising strength through pain (death), to make his "patient" compliant, all to reach a level where Bizarro will be unstoppable.

Eventually, the number of "rebirths" transforms Bizarro into a hulking, physically distorted beast with traces of the "S" shield now encrusted on his chest.

Luthor drives to the Kent farm and is met by Superman. Arguing that Lois brought this on herself by not accepting the deal (to stop writing), and with Sam kidnapped, she only has one person to protect her--and that person is going to die. Signaling Doomsday, SM acts fast and rams into the beast, taking it into the sky, but the creature knocks SM right to the middle of town. The Kents and Irons families all run toward SM, but he begs them to stay away, and resumes the battle, leaving Jordan feeling powerless.

SM is knocked into Metropolis harbor, followed by the creature, but SM acts fast, freezing the water around the creature, temporarily incapacitating it. SM hurls Doomsday on a building's spire, seemingly killing it, but in consideration of the episode's title's meaning...you know...Doomsday recovers, barreling into SM, through the street and into the subway tunnel, where Superman is beaten to a pulp. Doomsday grabs SM by the neck and flies off into space.

Back in Smallville, Jordan can no longer hear his father breathing, leaving Lois to gasp, "Clark". Whether or not SM heard Lois is up for debate, but his mind is flooded with memories of his family, which revives him, giving him the strength to break free, punch Doomsday to the moon's surface, where the creature removes spikes from its own body, and launches himself toward Superman, who in turn, rockets toward Doomsday--one would assume he's going in for the kill....

NOTES:
Season three ends with a cliffhanger--Superman presumed dead, but in a do-or-die struggle against Doomsday. It must be said that throughout the series' run, Superman and Lois had been quite liberal in borrowing ideas and scenes from the DCEU Superman plots, and with Doomsday's origin:

  • A Luthor using a Kryptonian (a Bizarro one in this case, instead of Zod's DNA, but a Kryptonian nonetheless) to engineer a creature of immeasurable power.
  • The creature has one purpose: kill Superman.
  • Superman appears to be killed, but is revived (by memories rather than the sun)
  • Superman impales Doomsday (only this time, he slammed him on top of a high-rise's spire, instead of a Kryptonite-tipped spear).

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice's Doomsday / Superman death plots were pretty much copy+pasted for the big battle. That, and one film earlier--Man of Steel--had Superman having no choice but to kill Zod, who could not be talked down (and was a second away from burning down a cowering family). Superman and Lois' Superman was left with the same lack of options when a world was threatened. There's no Super Friends-esque ending in a fantasy/adult drama.

Of course, I do not mind Superman and Lois' showrunners displaying such unabashed acknowledgement of two of the best DC/superhero genre films ever produced, but this season finale's fight lacked the inspiration's level of danger because we know Superman did not die, and there's a season 4, no matter what shape Superman is left in after the battle.

I hope the absence of SM does not lead to Jordan demanding to take up the mantle, and due to circumstances, he's allowed to do so. No matter what emotional issues Super-Angst goes through, his petulant nature does not need to be rewarded, and to be frank, if his father--a full Kryptonian with years of experience--could not handle the Big Bad (Doomsday or Luthor), junior certainly cannot.

With the cast gutted for S4, any of the hints and/or set-ups of lives going forward have lost the wind behind their sails, since this cliffhanger will undoubtedly be the springboard for supporting characters to "move on" with life if Superman is missing / injured / comatose for an extended period. In other words, most supporting character sub-plots might be a thing of the past.

Personally, I would like to see "..and the story continues" visits from Irons/Lana and Kyle/Chrissy in S4, since this season finale set up some promising plotlines.

The series has not lost its sensitive handling of Lois cancer / post-operative journey; her sense of self--identity as a woman, including her sexual perceptions about herself was presented in less than one minute of screen time, but it said so much--

Its clear the decision to gut the cast was already known some time back, since this season finale's plot is all about new directions--away from Smallville. Top of the list: Irons. Just as he's exploring a relationship with Lana, Sam drops the D.O.D. offer at his feet--and at a time when Lana feels she was on the road to starting her own new chapter with him. That's one of the true blows to the forthcoming final season. It hurts the supporting player plots the showrunners had been patient in developing over the past two seasons--one of the series' strengths. Sure, a suited-up Irons could fly back to Smallville in no time at all, but that's not exactly practical due to the nature of the job offer.

Sam introduced Natalie (to Gretchen) as his granddaughter--a sweet, continuity-aware touch.

Kyle proposed to Chrissy. Not unexpected, and its certainly a good thing for the two, but the expression on Lana's face during the announcement was interesting.

...and yes, the battle FX were largely early 2000s video-gamey (a constant problem in this series' history), but the emotional beats finally made the FX deficiencies somewhat tolerable.

GRADE: A.
 
Barely watched the first few minutes, and it never ceases to amaze me when two adults (one of whom has already had children) are completely astonished to find out she is pregnant after having unprotected sex.

When you have sex and neither of you are infertile, pregnancy is an expected event. Astonishment is completely out of place.
 
So it really was Doomsday after all that? It’s a double fake out. :)
It was pretty good. The fight scene did remind me of a Resident Evil cutscene. I expected it to start saying “Stars” at some point.
 
Barely watched the first few minutes, and it never ceases to amaze me when two adults (one of whom has already had children) are completely astonished to find out she is pregnant after having unprotected sex.

When you have sex and neither of you are infertile, pregnancy is an expected event. Astonishment is completely out of place.

Well, to be fair, contraception, like any other precaution, can occasionally fail. So it is possible that a couple could have protected sex and thus be justified in their surprise that a pregnancy happened anyway. But if that were the case with Kyle and Chrissy, they should've mentioned it.
 
Barely watched the first few minutes, and it never ceases to amaze me when two adults (one of whom has already had children) are completely astonished to find out she is pregnant after having unprotected sex.

That's writers projecting a reaction to surprise the audience.
 
Will the show's setting shift to Metropolis or away from Smallville in Season 4? Otherwise this butchering of the cast for the next season makes no sense to me.
 
Kyle proposed to Chrissy. Not unexpected, and its certainly a good thing for the two
I disagree. How long have they been dating? A few months? I agree with Lana when she was talking with John Henry - it's too soon. Kyle is a bit older and has been married and a dad before - this will be all new to Chrissy.

I saw Gretchen-working-for-Luthor coming a mile away, but Walsh's acting sold me on him being too besotted to notice any red flags.

Bizoomsday's beatdown of SM was brutal. However cheesy some of the effects were, the fight choreography was great.

Lois... wow. Bitsie's performance and the writers work on her this season has been nothing short of fabulous. It was also really nice to see adults in a sweet and sensitive "sex scene".

SuperAngst (love that) would be more annoying to me if I didn't know any teenagers. :lol:
 
That's writers projecting a reaction to surprise the audience.
In my case, I think the writers have completely failed. They seemed to me like two teenagers who had skipped too many natural science classes rather than two adults.

However Beverly is a worst offender. "Oh it's incredible, I'm pregnant after having sex! As a mother of a child and a trained doctor, this took me completely by surprise! If only there was something in 25th century medical science that would allow me to to plan a possible pregnancy as I wanted!"
 
Last edited:
They are madly in love. They may be grown adults but are feeling like a couple of school kids because they have completely surrendered to cupids arrow. The baby will change that and now will have to be a little more serious but I know if I ever fall in love I hope I don't become so serious that I forget to just let go and embrace the experience.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top