• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Han's dice

But how? Without Jabba, Han's arc is incomplete and there is no resolution.
Is arc is incomplete? His arc is going from anti-hero to hero. His arc is fairly well resolved at the end of ANH. Then they artificially revive it in ESB (Jabba apparently hasn't worried about being paid in 3 years until right when the film starts).

It works only if you don't look at it closely and the fact that we have grown up with "This is Han's backstory." But it doesn't have to be Jabba to resolve anything.
 
Is arc is incomplete? His arc is going from anti-hero to hero. His arc is fairly well resolved at the end of ANH. Then they artificially revive it in ESB (Jabba apparently hasn't worried about being paid in 3 years until right when the film starts).

It works only if you don't look at it closely and the fact that we have grown up with "This is Han's backstory." But it doesn't have to be Jabba to resolve anything.

Han ran into some bounty hunters on Ord Mantell, so Jabba didn't forget.
 
I thought it was only one bounty hunter.

The old SW comic strip turned this into a whole story with a bounty hunter named Skorr.

Kor
 
Thanks to various authors telling different versions of that encounter, I'm pretty sure the EU version of events had Han running into every bounty hunter in the galaxy on Ord Mantell at one time or another.

As I've already stated though, the decision to carry forward the Jabba plotline from ANH happened during the development of ESB's script. It's purpose wasn't to resolve Han's epic and highly relevant "financial dealing arc" (coz there ain't one!) it was to give Han a compelling reason to have to leave the rebellion and thus drive up the romantic tension between him and Leia. In the earlier drafts it was the Alliance asking him to go see his estranged step-father and ask for his support (he was some bigwig that controlled most of the major shipping lanes or something.)
That was a little dry and convoluted, so they parred it down to "he has to go get the price on his head removed".

It was not something Lucas deliberately left dangling to be resolved later when he wrote ANH. Indeed, Had Ford gotten his way and Han had been killed off in that, movie, they we would never have seen Jabba at all and he'd remain just a passing mention and not at all involved in RotJ.

This is what happens when stories build on each other. Inconsequential details in earlier instalments start taking on more weight and consequence in later instalments. In the initial conception of ANH, the Emperor wasn't the ultimate face of evil, he was just some figurehead/puppet ruler controlled by "greedy trader barons" and the real villain of the piece was a moustache twirling, corrupt majordomo type character that would later evolve into Tarkin. But then they killed him off so they needed a new boss for Vader, and the rest is history.
 
I think the interesting thing about Han, is he clearly didn't learn his lesson. Jabba is killed, Han is no longer a wanted man...sooo.. he falls right back into that lifestyle. I guess being hunted by bounty hunters, and being frozen in carbonite wasn't enough to steer him straight.
 
I think the interesting thing about Han, is he clearly didn't learn his lesson. Jabba is killed, Han is no longer a wanted man...sooo.. he falls right back into that lifestyle. I guess being hunted by bounty hunters, and being frozen in carbonite wasn't enough to steer him straight.

Sure, twenty-five years later, after his son turned evil and his wife's career was ruined by scandal and she started a militia movement. It's not like he started running Forest Moonshine the second Lando gave him back his keys on Endor.
 
Han's dice in the sequel trilogy were different from Han's dice in ANH.

Kor
 
I think most people should be able to grasp the notion that certain props do change between movies, especially when it starts off life as a little bit of set dressing thrown into the background on short notice.
Then later it has to be featured more prominently and hold up under close-ups, so the prop master has to 1) make it look more detailed and interesting, and 2) make a lot more of them since you can't have everything grinding to a halt if the one hero prop they have is lost or gets damaged. Plus there's some props that vary from shot to shot depending on whether it's the hero prop (the one mostly just meant to look pretty) a functional prop (sometimes meant for some kind of practical effect) or a stunt prop (typically made of rubber so the stunt performers don't get pointy bits of metal lodged in their brains while falling down a flight of stairs of whatever.)

The details on the Stormtrooper helmets changed in every single movie as the fabrication processes were refined and budgets went up. Same for Vader's helmet & costume, the Luke/Anakin/Rey lightsabre was a little different each time, Han's blaster was never exactly the same twice. There's probably been about two dozen R2-D2's at this point and I doubt Anthony Daniels has ever worn the same Threepio costume two movies running. Hell, the Falcon seemed to grow an extra pair of landing gear between ANH & ESB! (They rebuilt the whole thing from scratch for ESB and again for TFA.)

I still want an in-universe explanation for the difference between Tatooine cruisers and "big Corellian ships" Han talks about in ANH.
The "local bulk cruisers" are probably the likes of the Gozanti & Arquitens class cruisers which would be what you'd most expect to find on most outer rim patrol routes. The "big Corellian ships" would be the Imperial class star destroyers, which we saw being constructed on Corellia. One assumes that CEC was subcontracted by Kuat, or every major shipyard in Imperial space was at least partly nationalised after the Clone Wars.
 
Last edited:
The "local bulk cruisers" are probably the likes of the Gozanti & Arquitens class cruisers which would be what you'd most expect to find on most outer rim patrol routes. The "big Corellian ships" would be the Imperial class star destroyers, which we saw being constructed on Corellia. One assumes that CEC was subcontracted by Kuat, or every major shipyard in Imperial space was at least partly nationalised after the Clone Wars.
Yes, but that is confused when you see Star Destroyers pursuing them once they leave Tatooine.
 
Yes, but that is confused when you see Star Destroyers pursuing them once they leave Tatooine.
Those aren't always there, they were left there by Vader because they're still searching for the plans down on the surface. So they're not the local cruisers, they're from Tarkin's forces. Han certainly seems a little surprised to see them.
 
They even filmed an entire scene with him. Lucas wanted to replace him with an alien, but they really couldn't figure out how to do that back in the 70s so it was cut.
Rubbish. They never intended to replace the actor with an alien or they would never have let Ford cross in front of him.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top