• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Prodigy 1x09 - "A Moral Star, Part 1"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    67
I think Murf is probably one of a kind with no specific planet or race attached to him.

So instead of trying to identify him as a specific type of creature, we might want to try and find a specific character or an instance in which a similar being was created.

And it seems that it's most likely from the Trek Novel universe.

‪‪I had thought the novels might be the best place to look, but Aaron Waltke has mentioned on a couple different podcast interviews that Murf’s origins were mentioned specifically on one of the shows.
 
‪‪I had thought the novels might be the best place to look, but Aaron Waltke has mentioned on a couple different podcast interviews that Murf’s origins were mentioned specifically on one of the shows.
Oh, hadn't heard that yet.
Well then ... I guess folks will have to scour the several hundred episode scripts for the answer then.
 
Oh, hadn't heard that yet.
Well then ... I guess folks will have to scour the several hundred episode scripts for the answer then.

In a weird way it’s nice to have it narrowed down like that, but it’s also pretty freaking daunting, what with 803 episodes having aired before Murf’s debut.
 
The caretaker looked like a purple blob when he was dying and Murf could be a baby Nacene, Denevan neural parasites are slimy blobs and could perhaps combine to form a more gentle and complex lifeform, the coalescent or silver blood lifeforms could have relatives that aren't mimetic, or the Protostar could have had bio-neural gel packs that somehow merged and formed a lifeform :D
 
I noticed a small continuity snag/animation error. There's one shot of Zero at a console, after painting themselves in the uniform colours, where they're back in their regular colours.

I'm not complaining about it, just making an observation. Shit like this happens all the time.
 
The caretaker looked like a purple blob when he was dying and Murf could be a baby Nacene, Denevan neural parasites are slimy blobs and could perhaps combine to form a more gentle and complex lifeform, the coalescent or silver blood lifeforms could have relatives that aren't mimetic, or the Protostar could have had bio-neural gel packs that somehow merged and formed a lifeform :D
Apparently though, what Murf is, has never been SEEN on screen, only mentioned.

I searched for blob, goo, gelatin, gelatinous, slime, gel... any other keywords that come to mind?

I found this at Memory Beta ...

Gelloid
"The Gelloids were a species, composed largely of protoplasm.
They were known to the Federation by the 2370s.

A Gelloid was visiting Deep Space-9 in 2370, when the station became home to a disorientated group of Horta.
When the Horta found their way onto the space station's promenade the people of the station, including the Gelloid and an Avian trader, were rather startled and in the ensuing chaos the Avian's talons got stuck in the Gelloid's gooey protoplasm.
(DS-9 Novel "Devil in the Sky)"
https://memory-beta.fandom.com/wiki/Gelloid

Though I don't know if they were ever mentioned in any of the shows.
 
Last edited:
He seemed to be in trouble when he got stuck between stuff while the Protostar crashed on the evil vine planet. Somehow he couldn't get out and trilled like he's in distress, and then Gwyn saved him, IIRC.

It would be interesting to see if parts of Murf stay alive and can perhaps even form their own heads when split off. If that's the case, you'd have to wear a living creature as armor XD
But if you can 'harvest' armor goo from him that doesn't have its own mind, and if he can regenerate whatever he loses, you could cover entire ships with that stuff :D

What is your daytime job, evil schientist? ;)
 
Interestingly, if Murph has been mentioned onscreen then it's likely (unless it was a Voyager episode) that they're yet another member of an alpha quadrant race far from home.

The Federation of this era (Picard spoilers)
let Riker's son die when they could have just harvested B4 for a synth-generated cure. They let the son of the hero who saved the Fed from the Borg die over rigid adherence to a synth ban
I don't think they're suddenly going to be buying the "think of the children" issue on this alone.

That'd be years after this.

Starfleet only gave up because half of the member world's threatened to leave the Federation

Hardly half. I think 14? Presumably worlds close to the neutral zone with unpleasant history with the Romulans. Still a bleak, depressing place to take the Federation...

Oh, hadn't heard that yet.
Well then ... I guess folks will have to scour the several hundred episode scripts for the answer then.

I'll just keep periodically watching reruns. Work, work, work...
 
I wonder if all the rescued children will become the ship’s crew and recurring characters. They will need to do something with them unless they find some conveniently nearby planet with a galactic orphanage. I hope they keep the little Caitian girl and make her a main character. They also need a human.
 
here’s my question — half our crew are species that we know are from the Federation (Tellarite, Brikkar, Medusan), plus the Caitian. Is the only reason they are ignorant of the federation because they were enslaved so young? It strikes me that if a dozen years worth of child abduction cases from across the Fed turned out to be the responsibility of a single person then damn straight the Federation would send in Starfleet.
Jankem talks about being from a Tellarite Sleeper Ship, which I previously speculated could mean he was from a time when early in the Tellarite space age, before they had developed warp drive and therefore before the Federation existed. This could explain how he doesn't know about the Federation, and why the Federation didn't react to his apparent abduction.
 
In a weird way it’s nice to have it narrowed down like that, but it’s also pretty freaking daunting, what with 803 episodes having aired before Murf’s debut.

It would be literally like looking for a needle in a haystack.
Problem with it is that the only series which comes to mind that could have something like Murf would be TOS only because more 'exotic' (and less humanoid) species were mentioned in TOS.
Apart from that... I do not recall any other Trek series that could have referenced Murf's species.
There are some vague similarities in Murf's composition and the Founders gelatinous state... but its just that... 'vague' at best.
Murf has no ability to shapeshift and he's pretty much indestructible (at least when it comes to energy/explosions/radiation)... the Founders have no such ability and can easily be vaporized (but for all we know, Murfs exterior could be more vulnerable).
 
My prediction: Janeway’s upgrade.

This is a distinct possibility.

Gwyn was seen working on Janeway's holo matrix while the kids were preparing to integrate their plan before jumping back to Tars Lamora.
My guess is she anticipated her father and Drednok will try overwriting Janeway and installed subroutines to protect her (which Drednok obviously didn't see because Janeway is a low priority system and has access to low priority systems) and possibly also give her greater command access to the ship in the process.
So, right now, Va'uk/Nat Janeway is probably still real Janeway and playing possum (waiting until the time is right).
We'll see.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top