Holy wow... I'd downloaded all the NV episodes a few months ago but never watched them and then I decided that I was bored and NV was the way to go... so with a stream of WEaT open in the background, loading, I popped in my DVDs.
So totally cool - was my first reaction. Huge worlds of improvement from Come What May to In Harm's Way (great story using the Guardian)... but then came TSAMD... wow. It was a little on the low key side but effective.
However... WEaT blew my expectations out of the park. Phenomenal. This episode has sold me on NV and I'm now registered on the boards and ready to follow the production a heck of a lot closer than I had been. This was a Star Trek episode of callibur that I haven't seen in quite a while (not at all related to the fact that Trek's been off the air..

). You know, I wasn't a fan of TOS and I still am not really... but I'm content with NV. It's still a little rough on the edges but by WEaT, I'm comfortable with the new Kirk and Spock (and now I have to adjust to a new one just as I got on board with Quinn). Uhura was hard to come to grips with but by the wonderful pacing of the opening scene of WEaT, I was sold. I agree that McCoy is probably the weakest of the bunch, but there's nothing wrong with that among this production.
WEaT opened with a bang - it was sharp, crystal clear for the most part... the effects around the daughter were amazing and i could have just stared at those colors line thingys for hours. My favorite part was the bookending on the Excelsior - I kept watching the episode wondering who was in that shuttle from the beginning and needless to say my wild theories got a little out of hand but the resolution was wonderful - and the last scene on the bridge with a certain visitor watching from just outside the turbolift... most network TV can't get me to the emotional point that that did.
Huge kudos to you all... I don't know how you do it, but keep it up - you've got a new fan onboard here.