• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Lost in Space: original vs. the 2 remakes

Admiral Jean-Luc Picard

Commodore
Commodore
I love the 1998 movie and the Netflix series. I've tried watching the original series on Hulu. I gave it the 2 pilots, the first regular episode, and got halfway through the 4th episode. I can't. :eek: :lol: Does it get better? :shrug:
 
Lost in Space --the 1965-68 series--was typical of Irwin Allen's sci-fi TV series from that decade: generally strong-to-compelling pilot episodes, followed a by a handful of interesting 1st season stories (in The Time Tunnel's case, it only had one season). To your question, arguably the best from the 1st season are:

"The Hungry Sea"
"The Keeper" two-parter
"There Were Giants in the Earth" (hey, it inspired a popular model kit, so it cannot be that bad!)
"My Friend, Mister Nobody"
"War of the Robots"
"The Sky is Falling"
"The Magic Mirror"
"The Challenge"

YMMV, but if you're accepting the kind of sci-fi Irwin Allen and his various writers created, you might find the listed episodes enjoyable...but you will notice the Allen-ordered inflating of Dr. Smith's wild, screaming coward act along the way.
 
Lost in Space --the 1965-68 series--was typical of Irwin Allen's sci-fi TV series from that decade: generally strong-to-compelling pilot episodes, followed a by a handful of interesting 1st season stories (in The Time Tunnel's case, it only had one season). To your question, arguably the best from the 1st season are:

"The Hungry Sea"
"The Keeper"
two-parter
"There Were Giants in the Earth" (hey, it inspired a popular model kit, so it cannot be that bad!)
"My Friend, Mister Nobody"
"War of the Robots"
"The Sky is Falling"
"The Magic Mirror"
"The Challenge"


YMMV, but if you're accepting the kind of sci-fi Irwin Allen and his various writers created, you might find the listed episodes enjoyable...but you will notice the Allen-ordered inflating of Dr. Smith's wild, screaming coward act along the way.
The only Irin Allen production I've seen besides this show is "The Towering Inferno" film, but it's been so long, I forget how it goes. I do remember a burning building and the guy from the first Planet of the Apes movie.

Does S1 maintain quality across 29 episodes? I cannot stand the screaming, cowardly Dr. Smith thing. I'd rather put another framing nail through my foot. Please, tell me that's not frequent.
 
If you don't like the early episodes, I doubt you're going to like the rest of the series. As it goes on it gets more and more ridiculous, until they get to the point where they've got guys in medieval knight's armor flying around in rocketships, and giant talking vegetables.
 
If you don't like the early episodes, I doubt you're going to like the rest of the series. As it goes on it gets more and more ridiculous, until they get to the point where they've got guys in medieval knight's armor flying around in rocketships, and giant talking vegetables.
The first pilot was OK, the second pilot was a struggle. I actually bailed on the third episode, because the spacewalk was just getting tedious. I came back to finish the episode, but then I bailed on the 4th episode, because the dad is checking out the planet below in his spacesuit. WTF? YOU GUYS HAVE A SPACESHIP, USE IT!!!!

I don't mind silly, it's more zero danger, and people just make WTF nonsense decisions where I'd rather just put on Star Trek (TOS) instead. :eek:
 
You should seek out the other remake pilot directed by John Woo.

Or don't. My memory of it was that it wasn't all that good.
(And because it was never finished, it's full of temp music which took me out of it. Too many Terminator 3 cues in there.)
 
Lost in Space --the 1965-68 series--was typical of Irwin Allen's sci-fi TV series from that decade: generally strong-to-compelling pilot episodes, followed a by a handful of interesting 1st season stories (in The Time Tunnel's case, it only had one season). To your question, arguably the best from the 1st season are:

"The Hungry Sea"
"The Keeper"
two-parter
"There Were Giants in the Earth" (hey, it inspired a popular model kit, so it cannot be that bad!)
"My Friend, Mister Nobody"
"War of the Robots"
"The Sky is Falling"
"The Magic Mirror"
"The Challenge"
I would add "Return from Outer Space" to that list. The unofficial Christmas episode.
 
You should seek out the other remake pilot directed by John Woo.

Or don't. My memory of it was that it wasn't all that good.
(And because it was never finished, it's full of temp music which took me out of it. Too many Terminator 3 cues in there.)
The Robinsons 2004 pilot? I tried to watch 5 minutes of it, but I couldn't. I kept skipping ahead until I bailed. :lol:
 
I was a kid in the 60s, so I loved LiS for it's spaceship, silliness and bright colors. I can't watch it at all these days without cringing so much my face muscled lock. But, I still love Irwin Allen's tech. His vehicles were always cool as hell, and I have model kits of all of them.

The movie was just awful, IIRC correctly, and I barely recall it at all, except that I didn't like it. The one thing I did like about it was that Dr. Smith was played as a genuinely evil bastard. The ship and robot were awful, IMHO. Penny was so totally whiny-screechy-obnoxious that I can't even look at the actress after that. :lol: .

The Netflix series is pretty darn good. They changed quite a bit from the TV series. QUITE a bit. But I enjoyed it as its own thing. There were changes I disagreed with here and there, and changes I liked, and changes I didn't mind.
 
I was a kid in the 60s, so I loved LiS for it's spaceship, silliness and bright colors. I can't watch it at all these days without cringing so much my face muscled lock. But, I still love Irwin Allen's tech. His vehicles were always cool as hell, and I have model kits of all of them.

The movie was just awful, IIRC correctly, and I barely recall it at all, except that I didn't like it. The one thing I did like about it was that Dr. Smith was played as a genuinely evil bastard. The ship and robot were awful, IMHO. Penny was so totally whiny-screechy-obnoxious that I can't even look at the actress after that. :lol: .

The Netflix series is pretty darn good. They changed quite a bit from the TV series. QUITE a bit. But I enjoyed it as its own thing. There were changes I disagreed with here and there, and changes I liked, and changes I didn't mind.
#1 As a kid of the 90's, I grew up on 60's shows, loved them, but LIS was never shown in reruns with the others I watched. My exposure to Irwin Allen TV is 3 1/2 episodes of LIS. :lol:

#2 In all honestly, what was so bad about the movie? It's one of the best films to come out of 90's cinema! I loved the ship and robot. haha Yeah, Penny was obnoxious, but very accurate as a middle child regarding the 90's audience. I was 14 when this came out, I think I had to wait for the VHS cassette, so I probably saw it when I was 15. Anyway, great movie. Also, Gary Oldman (Dr. Smith) is great in every movie he's in, even if the movie is crap. :lol:

#3 Did the Netflix series not stay true to the original regarding the overall concepts? I like some of the changes from the movie to the Netflix series. Dr. Smith is completely reinvented, and I love it. Robot is now an alien which works for the Netflix narrative. I didn't mind Judy being from a previous marriage as this is common in modern America, or so it seems. I also liked how the show started with a failing marriage that slowly comes back together over 3 seasons. It gave the parents a wholesome character arc.
 
If you really want to explore every version of LiS, there's the failed 1973 pilot for an animated series, which aired as part of The ABC Saturday Superstar Movie series (generally used as a launching pad for a number of cartoons based on 1960s and 70s live-action TV series):

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

If you dare to watch, you will quickly notice the character focus, and typically crappy Hanna-Barbera animation from that period...
 
If you really want to explore every version of LiS, there's the failed 1973 pilot for an animated series, which aired as part of The ABC Saturday Superstar Movie series (generally used as a launching pad for a number of cartoons based on 1960s and 70s live-action TV series):

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

If you dare to watch, you will quickly notice the character focus....
Dr. Smith, Will, and Robot. :lol: I've seen part of this on YouTube. Why was this a thing? :eek:
 
I love the 1998 movie and the Netflix series. I've tried watching the original series on Hulu. I gave it the 2 pilots, the first regular episode, and got halfway through the 4th episode. I can't. :eek: :lol: Does it get better? :shrug:
Overall, the original show outdoes the movie. The 1998 version did outgross TITANIC.....for one solid week. The heavy-metal remix was arguably cute, but the hokey dialogue undercut the film's attempted seriousness. So if you do watch it, it's really only good on its opening day 27 years ago. Use a time machine?
Does S1 maintain quality across 29 episodes? I cannot stand the screaming, cowardly Dr. Smith thing. I'd rather put another framing nail through my foot. Please, tell me that's not frequent.
It is. Too much so. That's why I fast-forward over Harris' tedious scenes if the better actors are absent during them.
You should seek out the other remake pilot directed by John Woo.

Or don't.
I didn't. They made Penny an infant. It should have been Will.
If you really want to explore every version of LiS, there's the failed 1973 pilot for an animated series, which aired as part of The ABC Saturday Superstar Movie series (generally used as a launching pad for a number of cartoons based on 1960s and 70s live-action TV series):

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

If you dare to watch, you will quickly notice the character focus, and typically crappy Hanna-Barbera animation from that period...
But thankfully no concluding guitar numbers.
 
Overall, the original show outdoes the movie. The 1998 version did outgross TITANIC.....for one solid week. The heavy-metal remix was arguably cute, but the hokey dialogue undercut the film's attempted seriousness. So if you do watch it, it's really only good on its opening day 27 years ago. Use a time machine?

It is. Too much so. That's why I fast-forward over Harris' tedious scenes if the better actors are absent during them.
#1 It's one of my favorite 90's-era movies. Yeah, the dialogue is goofy, but the same goes for most 90's movies.

#2 Oh... the pain... the pain!
 
Dr. Smith, Will, and Robot. :lol: I've seen part of this on YouTube. Why was this a thing? :eek:

Animation studios found it quite profitable to adapt live action properties (usually cancelled) which were attractive to young viewers as much as the adult audience. Filmation was one of the first with 1968/69's Fantastic Voyage (inspired by the 1966 20th Century Fox movie). While TOS was still first run, Filmation's Lou Scheimer approached Roddenberry about adapting Star Trek as an animated series. Of course, that would not happen until 1973, but the interest in live-action adaptations was growing.

By the early 70s, certain 60s and 70s TV series--especially sitcoms (e.g., My Favorite Martian, Gilligan's Island, I Dream of Jeannie, The Munsters, Bewitched, The Addams Family, Nanny and the Professor, Gidget, Emergency!, et al.) were so successful in syndication (with a sizable child audience) that it was just good business to try to bring that kind of property to Saturday mornings.

Where Lost in Space was concerned, Fox--more than Irwin Allen--promoted the idea of a Lost in Space cartoon (by 1973, LiS had earned Fox a pretty penny in syndication), but the approach was doomed from the start, by replacing all original characters except Smith (voiced by Johnathan Harris), dumped the Jupiter II in favor of one of Hanna-Barbera's endlessly recycled rockets, and attempted to play up the Smith character, but the screenwriters were just plain inferior--even compared to many of the sub-par writers who cranked out scripts for the original series.

As part of The ABC Saturday Superstar Movie, Lost in Space was one of many pilots, but it--similar to the majority of specials--failed to be picked up, the exceptions being The Brady Kids & Lassie's Rescue Rangers. Hanna-Barbera's Lost in Space pilot was awful, and its no surprise that it failed to sell, with such terrible animation, nonsensical plot and sharing not a thing which made the original series popular (IOW, more than Dr, Smith and the Robot).

Its purely a train-wreck watch.
 
I think the only old cartoons I watched were the old WB type cartoons, Looney Tunes, the Flinstones, the Jetsons, and mostly just that. As a kid, my dad didn't believe in cable TV (long story), so I had to settle for whatever was shown on local TV. There were a lot of 60's shows in reruns, love 60's TV. haha
 
You should seek out the other remake pilot directed by John Woo.

Or don't. My memory of it was that it wasn't all that good.
(And because it was never finished, it's full of temp music which took me out of it. Too many Terminator 3 cues in there.)
Fun fact: The team from Battlestar Galactica bought the sets from the pilot, and they used them for the Pegasus.
 
Dr. Smith, Will, and Robot. :lol: I've seen part of this on YouTube. Why was this a thing? :eek:
Let's face facts: young kids are quite undiscriminating at the Saturday-morning cartoon age. During that same time, whenever I walked out of BUGSY MALONE, SMOKEY AND THE BANDIT or APPLE DUMPLING GANG, it was inevitably the best movie I'd ever seen in a movie theater ever.

But once I saw ALIEN, that was. And still is.
 
Last edited:
Let's face facts: young kids are quite undiscriminating at the Saturday-morning cartoon age. During that same time, whenever I walked out of BUGSY MALONE, SMOKEY AND THE BANDIT or APPLE DUMPLING GANG, it was inevitably the best movie I'd ever seen in a movie theater ever.

But once I saw ALIEN, that was. And still is.
I loved RoboCop (the series) when I was 10 or 11 when it was on local TV.
Tried to watch it as an adult, and I'm like: :eek: :crazy::cardie::ack::brickwall:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top