Your trek "supergroup".

[AresB]

Writing (plot): DSC
Writing (dialogue): DSC
Main characters: DSC
Secondary/recurring characters: DS9, esp. Gul Dukat. A delicious villain there.
Acting (regulars): TOS
Acting (guests): DS9
Worldbuilding: ENT
Visuals/production values: DSC
Fight choreography (ground): ENT
Fight choreography (space): ENT
Ship: ENT
Theme song: DSC
First episode: DSC
Last episode: DS9

Anti:
Writing (plot): Kelvinverse
Writing (dialogue): Kelvinverse
Main characters: Kelvinverse
Secondary/recurring characters: No particular unfavorite
Acting (regulars): No particular unfavorite
Acting (guests): No particular unfavorite
Worldbuilding: Kelvinverse
Visuals/production values: Kelvinverse
Fight choreography (ground): TNG
Fight choreography (space): Kelvinverse
Ship: Kelvinverse
Theme song: No particular unfavorite
First episode: No particular unfavorite
Last episode: ENT

 

[somebuddyX]

Okay.
--

Man I agree with pretty much everything you wrote!
(EDIT: Not sarcasm by the way, I genuinely would have written pretty much the same thing. I removed a lot of your post in the quote just for brevity)

 

[Replica Picard]

Sweet. Brannon Braga gets to be in both groups.

That's fine. But Diane Duane is definitely my lead writer on the supergroup, so Braga can make suggestions. Politely.

 

[Admiral Archer]

Writing (plot): TMP-TVH (TOS Films 1-4)
Writing (dialogue): TMP
Main characters: TMP (including Ilia and Decker for the pilot, and Saavik starting with season 6)
Secondary/recurring characters: Admiral Nogura in early seasons, Sarek, David and Admiral Cartright in later seasons
Acting (regulars): TMP
Acting (guests): TMP-TVH TOS (Films 1-4)
Worldbuilding: TMP-TVH (TOS Films 1-4)
Visuals/production values: TMP
Fight choreography (ground): TWOK-TSFS
Fight choreography (space): TWOK-TSFS
Ship: USS Enterprise NCC-1701 refit
Theme song: TMP (with TWOK style Alexander Courage fanfare and new William Shatner "Space, the final frontier..." recording)
First episode: "In Thy Image, Part I and II" (TMP)
Last episode: "The Voyage Home, Part I and II" (TVH)
Anything I forgot: 8 Seasons, starting in 1978 and ending in 1986; Wardrobe: TMP for Seasons 1-5, TWOK Seasons 6-8

Special Notes: The series basically follows Kirk's second five year mission. Captain Spock assumes command after the Season 5 finale. Season 6/7 cliffhanger is TWOK, Season 7/8 cliffhanger is TSFS, and the finale is TVH.

 

[JRoss]

Man I agree with pretty much everything you wrote!
(EDIT: Not sarcasm by the way, I genuinely would have written pretty much the same thing. I removed a lot of your post in the quote just for brevity)

Great minds, right? I remove stuff in quotes for the sake of brevity, too.

 

[Timewalker]

I had this for my desktop wallpaper for awhile. I even have a captioned version of it somewhere.

I'm including some cheats in my list:

Supergroup:

Writing (plot): Diane Duane, Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, David Mack, AC Crispin, Una McCormack, Keith RA DeCandido, Howard Weinstein, Greg Cox, Margaret Wander Bonanno

YES! Adapt the best of the novels! (none would be by Diane Carey)

They could have combined Generations and First Contact if they'd just adapted Federation into a movie. It had all the relevant characters, and Kirk didn't have a stupid death scene. The final part of that novel provides one hell of a terrific jumping off point for any new series set post-whatever the latest given date is in the Prime universe.

Writing (humour): John Ford

And lyricist. I hated How Much For Just the Planet? the first time I tried to read it. It made no sense.

But later I realized that it's really an operetta in prose form. So I imagined myself sitting in the audience in a theatre, watching everything play out on stage (also imagining costume, scenery, prop, and lighting changes, as I used to work backstage in musical theatre on several of these crews)... and that's what I needed to love this novel. I wish it had been properly adapted and performed.

My "supergroup" would include Julia Ecklar and Leslie Fish and any other well-known filk singers/writers. Both these women have written Star Trek fiction (both amateur and professional) for decades and they have a way-beyond-impressive repertoire of Star Trek and science-themed songs to their credit.