• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Too Many Commanders?

Though it should be noted the article talking about Pike and Number One leaving made no mention of Spock, though I doubt anyone's expecting him to stick around next season.

True. But he might have some type of role, even if it's only a guest appearance. Speaking hypothetically because we're talking in the dark right now.
 
Pike turned command over to Saru at the end of Brother because the mission at hand was done and Pike believed his term commanding Disco was also done. Once in contact with Starfleet, they extended his command of Disco for the foreseeable future. It was then, knowing his assignment to Disco was semi-permanent that Pike changed into a blue uniform whether than continue wearing his gold Enterprise uniform.

And it's telling that Pike talks about this "joint custody situation" after changing into the blue uniform. The Starfleet decision to give the Discovery to him didn't suffice for sorting this out, apparently; somehow, Saru's pride was an issue, and Pike continued to walk on eggshells lest he lose this valuable officer.

Though it should be noted the article talking about Pike and Number One leaving made no mention of Spock, though I doubt anyone's expecting him to stick around next season.

We know zip about Peck's contract, right? Might be he was drafted as a series semi-regular, his character level with either Sarek or Georgiou, from the get-go. Might be the decision gets overturned for S3. But Mount seems to have gotten a very definite contract, much like Isaacs, one sized for a specific story arc. It does seem significant that Spock was not packaged with Pike and Number One in this reporting, considering that packaging Pike and Number One already means tying together the fates of two very dissimilar characters - a series pseudo-lead and an almost-cameo - so excluding Spock would not be on the basis of his character again being of a different type.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Not sure about too many commanders but the tightness of the uniform pants makes me wonder if there are too many people going commando
 
TOS: Scotty
TNG: Data
DS9: Dax for seasons1-3, Worf for seasons 4-7
Voyager: Tuvok
Enterprise: Trip

Pike only took command due to emergency circumstances in the premiere. At the end of the episode Starfleet made him the official Captain of the ship due to a combination of the Red Angel investigation and the Enterprise needing to go in for repairs. That's the whole reason why Pike where's his gold Enterprise uniform for most of the episode and switches to the blue Disco outfit in the final scene.
In some eps. of TOS Sulu was second in command (TOS S1 - "Arena" and "Errand Of Mercy" <--- Sulu is in the Command Chair when Kirk and Spock are down on a Planet.)
 
Even if Scotty was second officer, his job as Chief Engineer might take precedence in some situations, and he might have the option to decline (or, more likely, Kirk has the option to pick someone else) if he is needed in engineering.

There probably is an official list of the command chain going down several links, but a Captain's prerogative has always been to allow anyone of his choosing to take acting Command for short stints.

This could be the primary function of the Goldshirt/Command Department, to show which officers are qualified to take command (...although many, like Spock and Scotty, choose not to wear the colour).

Maybe it's easier for Kirk to say "I'm beaming down to the planet. DeSalle, you're in charge," rather than contacting Scotty who might be in engineering or asleep or recovering from a massive hangover somewhere.

Chekov and Sulu are qualified to command (and are on a command track, as they eventually become an XO and captain, respectively), but might be redshirts otherwise. Like Detmer in Discovery or the random redshirt (i.e. Leslie) we see from time-to-time at navigation on the Enterprise who might not be qualified.
 
Pike is a sort of proto-Kirk in insisting on personally attending landing parties. Unlike Kirk, though, he basically never takes his XO along, so the issue of the Second Officer need not ever arise.

Lorca in turn was no proto-Kirk, so the issue of the Second Officer didn't arise there, either: even if Saru went, Lorca stayed.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Not sure about too many commanders but the tightness of the uniform pants makes me wonder if there are too many people going commando
I would say underwear isn't really necessary in the future what with printing out a new uniform every few hours, but then again we've seen the undies of Burnham, Carol Marcus and anyone who wore the TOS miniskirt (they even had patterns for them in the Technical manual)
 
Wasn't the TOS "miniskirt" actually a ballet suit of sorts, with the pants integral to it all? Or, like, a single-piece swimsuit with an attached hem?

Timo Saloniemi
 
Wasn't the TOS "miniskirt" actually a ballet suit of sorts, with the pants integral to it all? Or, like, a single-piece swimsuit with an attached hem?
Don't forget TNG:
yz4UYbq.jpg

I'll leave this at that without further comment :D
 
Wasn't the TOS "miniskirt" actually a ballet suit of sorts, with the pants integral to it all? Or, like, a single-piece swimsuit with an attached hem?

Timo Saloniemi
Yep. I think in a few shots you can see actual underwear peaking through the "shorts".
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top