There were no problems at my theater tonight. Good turnout; I had been worried I'd be able to count on one hand the number of audience members. From my cursory glances around the theater, there seemed to be a good range of demographics, though skewed of course towards young males, and, interestingly enough, late middle-aged couples. The sort of folks who probably watched TNG together way back when.
I enjoyed it. I agree with Mott the barber that the evening was structured well. I personally thought that the first documentary, focusing on the technical stuff, was interesting, though I worry that it went on longer than casual fans would be interested in. Stardate Revisited was great and I look forward to eventually seeing the rest of it. (Buying the Blu-Rays are not high on my list at the moment. Give it some time, and some later better episodes.)
Enhancing the video quality and the special FX did have the downside of putting into sharper relief all the things in the script and the interior shots that did not age so well. Not surprisingly, people laughed at the skant moment, but also at the moment not long after that where Picard tells a crewman who had been creating a fire with his thoughts to concentrate and focus on his duties. "Yes sir!" And then dramatic cut to black. I'm exaggerating, but the point remains that the scene really did not work.
Not to harp on the script, but this particular viewing situation (HD, special FX, movie screen) made it clear that both scripts really could have done with one final round of revisions. We got the fourth draft, but we would've been much better off with the fifth. "Datalore" in particular suffered for this. This episode really is a tragedy about Data. The man who cannot feel, knows next to nothing about his origins and who thinks he's alone in the universe meets his all-too-emotional brother, learns about the ambivalent situation surrounding his creation and then is betrayed by his own brother. But after the climactic scene in the cargo bay (which, imho, did age well), the episode just ends. Boom.
I mean, watch Data once he realizes that Lore has drugged him. For an unfeeling android, there is an awful lot of emotion in that look of dismay. Tragic. There could have been a really poignant scene at the end. But alas. Such was TNGS1.
What I liked most about seeing the old episodes again was how they looked just like I remember them looking when I first saw them as a kid. Back then, TV sets were crappier, so the visual defects weren't as glaring. But now, with HDTV and all that, the video of early TNG episodes just looks... old. And they didn't, way back when. So it was extremely nice to see them back the way they're supposed to be.
I really hope this was a success and something they do again.