• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek Prodigy possible new ship (spoiler)

But it’s not “implied.” If it was, they wouldn’t have put that Luna class model on display.
What I'm saying is, that for a hypothetical viewer who isn't aware of the Luna-class Titan, who won't recognize a background conference-room model, whose last exposure to the idea of "Riker became captain of the Titan" was Nemesis, dialog and situations in the show will give the impression that this is, in fact, the ship that he took command of in that movie. I don't see any other reason why this ship would be the Titan-A unless Terry Matalas wanted to finally show the Titan after twenty years, he wanted it to be Shangri-La-class, and he wanted to get around it when the studio people told him some book had already decided what the Titan looked like and they'd already used that design in a cartoon show and the fans would all have a fit about canon if they went back on it.

We'll all find out for sure in a few weeks, but that's my read on the situation. I mean, PIC is the same show that said within a few lines that the new Stargazer was a brand-new ship, and also that it was a TMP-style rebuild of Picard's Stargazer.
 
For some reason, he completely ignores the Starfleet traditions of having shuttles share the warp nacelle design with their motherships. While Voyager-A might have a different style of engine, the shuttles we saw are at least a good starting point for speculation.
Types 6 and 11 say hi :D
 
To clarify, it is inconsistent.
Ship and shuttles with matching nacelles:
Enterprise/Constitution class - Class F
Enterprise-A/Enterprise class - Type 5
Enterprise-D/Galaxy class - Type 7
Voyager/Intrepid class - Type 9
Defiant/Defiant class - Type 10
Enterprise-E/Sovereign class - Type 11
Titan/Luna class - Type 6A variant
 
The Type 11 isn’t in Picard. That’s a different design. The one in Picard is a Type 14.

IMG_6730.jpg

IMG_6733.jpg


IMG_6732.jpg

IMG_6734.jpg
 
Last edited:
Ok, so.... why would Janeway move ships? At all?

Did nobody notice there was no Captain of the Dauntless? Janeway is listed as the commanding officer of the Dauntless over on Memory Alpha as well and there is no named Captain, it jumps straight to the Andorian First Officer Tyses, and then the Tellarite Chief Medical officer Noum.

They're also to be non-federation cadets under her direct tutledge so there's little reason for them to move, especially as they went to the expense of introducing these characters. They also seem to have been set up as the proper foils for the rest of the Prodigy children.

Tyses seems very straight laced to teach the command track to the chaotic and frequently incompetent Dal.

Noum could probably teach Jankom Pogg how to be a proper Tellerite or "Federation Royalty" as Pogg would likely continue to insist to the CMO's grumbling.

Also a ship which can operate in Transwarp and thus get to the timey-wimey rift quickly seems the most sensible and the model's already made and ready to go.
 
Ok, so.... why would Janeway move ships? At all?

Did nobody notice there was no Captain of the Dauntless? Janeway is listed as the commanding officer of the Dauntless over on Memory Alpha as well and there is no named Captain, it jumps straight to the Andorian First Officer Tyses, and then the Tellarite Chief Medical officer Noum.

They're also to be non-federation cadets under her direct tutledge so there's little reason for them to move, especially as they went to the expense of introducing these characters. They also seem to have been set up as the proper foils for the rest of the Prodigy children.

Tyses seems very straight laced to teach the command track to the chaotic and frequently incompetent Dal.

Noum could probably teach Jankom Pogg how to be a proper Tellerite or "Federation Royalty" as Pogg would likely continue to insist to the CMO's grumbling.

Also a ship which can operate in Transwarp and thus get to the timey-wimey rift quickly seems the most sensible and the model's already made and ready to go.
Consider that it is possible that the Dauntless, assuming it was repaired quickly, may be the ship that will bring Gwyn to Solum. It makes some sense, considering that Solum must be very far out and thus a vessel equipped with quantum slipstream drive is a logical choice. Tysess and Noum (the latter having some experience working on a Vau N'akat in severe medical condition, which may be useful...) could interact with Gwyn (shared aquaintances include VA Janeway, Jankom and Ascencia), keep an eye on her mission/behaviour and send reports to VA Janeway. Since Ascencia is likely to turn up in or around Solum (potentially in two versions), this would offer more chances at a dramatic confrontation with the crewmates she betrayed.

Granted, it's also possible that Starfleet send Gwyn out on her lonesome on a shuttle, but then she will have to take enormous risks to even reach Solum on time (unless Starfleet has a supershuttle prototype that can also take a superduper warpdrive and is willing to just give it to Gwyn, with a large risk that it will be captured by the Vau N'akat). So I guess that sending her along on a proper explorer, to support and monitor her, would be more logical.

Anyway, VA Janeway stated she will have her choice of ship and it was quite heavily implied it will be the Voyager-A. And if not, it may be another (very) large vessel with plenty of new faces, as it will be a ship where Starfleet cadets (not just the Protogies) will be training on.

The timey-wimey rift isn't even that far out of the Federation (the site of the big S1 finale battle was relatively close to Earth/Sol) and could probably be easily reached by all the regular bigger Starfleet vessels, including the Defiant class (which may just be a smart choice for a mission to future Solum, especially if equipped with cloak).

Because she can. And she will. Because the entire reason why those shuttles were labeled NCC-74656-A is because they’re getting a new ship. This is an animated series. There are no sets or ships that need to be reused.
Agreed on the Voyager-A, but even animated series need to create their assets. Though I'm no expert by any means, I would guess that reusing the Dauntless exteriors and interiors (and associated character models if they indeed use Tysess and Noum again) would save time/money and leave them free to do something else with that money (like creating Voyager-A interiors and Solum scenery). So I wouldn't be surprised if the Dauntless does show up during S2, possibly on Gwyn's mission as mentioned, or else they may still turn up as part of Janeway's group at some point (though it likely won't be the training vessel Dal and co will be on, at least initially).

So? Neither the Dauntless nor the Protostar are good training ships. Changing ships makes sense to me.
Yes, it was implied to be larger and the extremely fast speed of the other two vessels is unlikely to be needed (though Voyager-A may have quantum slipstream anyway, I suppose).
 
Considering the care and consistency the Hageman brothers brought to Season 1 I can't personally see it.

Janeway was likely the one who pushed for the development of SF version of the Dauntless class ships (seeing how Torres was the person who oversaw that ships design and construction).

And because the original Voyager was placed/turned into a museum, she also likely pushed for development of Voyager-A.

There's also the fact that the Dauntless suffered damage during its run in with the Construct... but most (if not all) of that damage would have been well repaired by the point we saw the kids finally reach Earth.
Its possible the Dauntless was assigned to another person to command it in that case, or Tysses as promoted to a Captain.

Who knows... Janeway can easily jump ships if she deems it necessary... and its possible the Dauntless was seen as having better value elsewhere... or it will serve as a support ship for Voyager - A that will go rescue Chakotay through the wormhole.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top