• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Russell T. Davies Returns to Doctor Who as New Showrunner

There was a fair amount of acceptance that ‘this was Who now’ and the only one we were getting. The costume, the avoidance of overt continuity, the junk shop Console Room sans Roundels. It was Doctor Who that was a little bit desperate not to be too much like old Doctor Who. Which, I think some fans got behind faster than others, because we just wanted it back. As it got more confident, it sort of revealed its hand more — continuity galore, Doctors back to mostly dressing and being Doctorish again. For some reason the production team have been back tracking some of that again, and I am not sure it’s working for many fans.
 
even if the Doctor hadn't tried to strangle Peri, it really was a shockingly bad story.
Yeah, but remember, this was tacked on at the end of the Fifth Doctor's last season, as a way of introducing a new Doctor early and keep a taste of him for the next season. For a story that has him trying to strangle his companion (one who also happens to be an entirely amiable folk), on top of being written as entirely pompous and obstinate (something that's most significantly absent in most of season 23 and virtually all his audio stories), sends a pretty awful message: this new Doctor is an asshole, lets wait for a whole season of that, shall we??

To put him in that ludicrous, truly awful outfit was the icing of the cake. The show was truly and well dead, at that minute.
 
I've wondered about that myself. It was a weird time. Davidson had been popular, but of course, Tom Baker was an institution. I think a lot of people were predisposed to dislike Colin no matter what.
I just remember seeing his outfit on newsround or something like that and taking an immediate dislike to him. I don’t think I’d realised peter was leaving until then, which didn’t help; it felt like Peter only been in the role a short time (compared to Tom) and here he was being replaced by this clown. And unfortunately Colin’s performance just did nothing to win me back.
 
If it was Adric I think the fans would have been down with it. ;)

‘But Doctor! I know we can never go back and undo what happened with my father on Traken! But surely this is different, he was right there and it can’t possibly effect causality?’
‘Yeah Doctor, how hard can it be to get this bloc back there, I know you keep missing Heathrow, but hasn’t it got a reverse gear?’
‘Nyssa, Tegan, I know how deeply you must feel… and believe me if I could, I would! Now… why don’t we get some rest hmm?’
Later, as the women slept in their rooms, the Doctor eyed the Fast Retirn switch on the Tardis console, and careful cleaned the edges with a yellow duster, peering over his glasses as he did so.
‘There that should do it!’ He announced to the darkened console room.
With a wheezing groaning sound, the Tardis appeared where it been hours ago and no time at all ago.
‘Now I’ll never know if I was right!’ The boy turned from the smoking ruin of the navigational lock, the Earth looming large on the external viewscreen. ‘Doctor you came back for me!’
‘Yes. Well, that’s the thing about a Time Machine, you can always go back when you forget to do something. And well, as I said, my arms are only this long.’
With that the fair haired Time Lord lunged across the room, and with a startled yelp, Adric was prevented from accidentally affecting the evolution of life on Earth with his Alzarian biology. At least, that’s what the Doctor would tell Nyssa, if she wandered past the scanner on one of her night time trips to the Tardis food machine.
 
That's the height of hubris. Just because people aren't watching this version of DW, doesn't mean people won't come back if it "returns to form"
Sorry, but Ncuti is Ncitty as the Doctor. He may be a good actor, but between RTDs writing of him and his "acting", it drove people away.
Re Gatwa, I just don’t understand this reaction. Whatever one thinks of the writing, Gatwa as the Doctor has been terrific since the word go, and very much remains so this week.
 
Folk don't like the crying.

After all the talk of "fixing" himself via therapy, I would expect crying. And other emotional displays we're not used to getting.
In terms of the character, I very much like how much he cares about everyone who crosses his path, even the robot he has to turn off in “The Robot Revolution” (just a cleaning bot with presumably limited intelligence, yet he treats turning it off as a death, even if it gets restarted later).
 
Folk don't like the crying.

After all the talk of "fixing" himself via therapy, I would expect crying. And other emotional displays we're not used to getting.

The problem is, it makes him too human. (And this is *every week*) It makes each tear weigh less. Compare the weight for a Who Fan of those few emotional outburst’s with the ninth. In a strange way, to some people, it makes him less *british* which is in some ways a complete contradiction of that first point, but at the same time is just something built into the character. That second one is something generational, but again — it’s every week.
 
I quite like the crying. Having greater empathy than most of his previous incarnations is a welcomed one and shows necessary growth. It will becoming a defining character trait for him and a positive one at that!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top