• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Review of New DST TOS Medical Tricorder

Trekofile

Ensign
Red Shirt
DST TOS Entertainment Earth's Excl. Tricorder Review


I "was" excited when my postal carrier rang my bell and my toy had arrived. That joy, extended to seeing the outer pkging, very nice. However that feeling faded as I popped the toy out of it's tie downs and ejected it from the backing panel.
The body shell is adequate, but not not thick enough to take rough play or god forbid, be dropped.
The black texturing is fair, but it's silver accent paint ops will soon rub off with much use.
The faux-leather/pleather strap is a form of thin rubber.

The medical scanner unit is for the most part a complete let down. The sound aspect is controled by depresssing a thumb button, you hear a very low-level audible familiar sound. The spinning center action is achieved by a very lame thumb wheel you must rotate sideways to achieve motion. This cannot be accomplished in tandum w/ the sound at the same time. very dissapointing to say the least.
On to the static display screen of the Tricorder you have a depiction of the sick bay vitals readout w/ a poorly done light up effect which can only be described as a very sml. light bulb to the extreme right of the frame corner. Thus only an 1/8th of the display has any sort of illumination, and the rest is left dark. What the heck?

My toy did work on sample mode, nor play intially. After opening the faux face front memory disc panel, and playing with the on/off/Try Me switch/battery compartment, I got it to work. My toy seems to have a gliche where it will/will not work momentarly, unless I fiddle w/ this switch.
The drop down bottom drawer has a very lame node/recessed shallow hole hinge-like design that did will come apart/away and can easily be broke,unless cautious care is taken. This will drop open completely downwards to facilate access to the battery/power/disc area, and allow you to tilt the unit towards you to have the scanner drop out, unless you have smaller fingers and can pry it out. The battery well, has a micro-screw panel to cover, but I find it un-necessary and after opening it once, the screw was easily stripped. My suggestion is remove it and leave off and save yourself the grief of it's removal.
This drop down door has 2 side niches to barely keep the door in 3/4 open mode, and again, design so poor and shallow, it's guaranteed to fail or break unless you take great care.

The middle drop down door does so completely forward and down(unless bottom door closed, then it stops 1/4 way from fully down) to reveal the star moire that does move and look great, but does make a modest hum when activated but the 3 action button on the top hood section.
And now the most sadest aspect deal killer for me. The sound of Dr. McCoy(DeForest Kelly's) voice sped up to a laugh-out loud speed to make the playback a complete and utter dissapontment!
The far right button activates 5 phrases from the tv series. The middle and far left you're treated to 2 different diagnostic scanning sounds that are correct and true and at the correct playback speed! Each must be pressed & depressed to activate, and cannot be accessed by simply pressing each back and forth randomly. Each sound does sustain until disabled. If you wish to to sustain your playablility, you can relish the Tricorder's actual sounds, and sadly avoid the McCoy voice option if you want to make this toy a hit for your next con, halloween party, or showing friends & family. While unit is on, light up left/right blue remain lit, and middel/yellow light blinks untill you switch unit off.


Design: C-
Sound Phrases: 1/2-A+/1/2-C-
For $40.00, it's great batteries are incld. But, when Hallmark can make a Communicator ornament that so tiny,I t fits in the palm of my hand w/ multiple sound phrases in the correct playback speed mode for far less than 1/2 that price, somethings wrong w/ DST's R&D team and production in China. I soon will get the science version of this tricorder from New Force, but now I'm less-excited knowing the voice phrases may also have Spock sounding like an Alvin- Vulcan chipmonk. *sigh* I have to contact EE and return mine, as it mostly doesn't function and may appear to have a bad wiring/connection issue that prevents continual consistant use, and has ceased functioning before I actually finished this review!
 
My battery compartment after only carefully unscrewing it once, and threading it back only partially, the screw was forever stripped and my entry ever again was prevented for eventual battery replacement. I could have sent it back to EE, but I chose not to.
I have just used 2 thin knives and pryed the panel away from sides and bent it and twisted it permantely off and breaking it around screw hole. Did I wished I'd hadn't had to do that, yes. But, I'm fine with it, as the battery panel was superfulous and being's as it is hidden by the faux drop down memory disc panel, it's unseen. I did additionally notice the power/lights do come on when the hood is opened, when switched on. My power faliure issue seems to be with the right side battery contact spring and it's having to be tucked in better to touch the battery's bottom contact point. Your milage may vary...ahhaahahahahahahahha. The very fact you have to first drop down the bottom door completely down, open the faux disc panel every time to turn on/off the unit's power is highly annoying..but unless you want dead batteries, this is necessary.
Still not used to Chipmonk McCoy's voice..arrrrrggggg

There also seems to be an annoying intermitant contact issue w/ hood power as it flips open....I have to repeatedly open.close it until it functions, which I believe is in regards to the bad battery contact spring. Seems to be no end to production design issues w/ this toy.
 
Got mine today, and I like it a lot. The McCoy voices are absurd, but they're confined to the rightmost button on the control panel, so its pretty easy to not use it. So far, I haven't had any issues with the activation switch or the quality of construction. The toy was mastered off the HS versions of the prop used in DS9, so for the price, it's accuracy is unparalleled. Another nice touch is the total lack of visible screws; while not museum quality by any stretch of the imagination, it looks higher quality than what one thinks of as a "toy." I'd give it a B or B+.
 
I was going to buy one but I might not now. Does anyone know where I can buy a far superior version? I know it will be pricey, but I would like to have a high quality tricorder replica. PM me if you know, and thanks.

My apologies to the board and the moderator if this request violates board rules.
 
Thanks for the reviews guys, the pictures of this look FANTASTIC.

Their phaser and communicator toys are brilliant, and have so far survived my 2 year old constantly playing with them and dropping them often. :lol:

But the tricorder wouldn't survive rough play from a young kid?
 
But the tricorder wouldn't survive rough play from a young kid?

I think it would--it actually feels sturdier than the phaser and comm. The moire and sounds are higher quality than on the communicator, as well. I'd recommend it.
 
Thanks Gep :)

Looks like my son scored a Tricorder for Christmas.

Of course dad will never play with it...:shifty:
 
Master Replicas did make a couple years ago a Science Tricorder, high end prop replica for around 250.00? I own one. It does have a cool Cestus III static tactical screen backlit w/ moving target red dots. Has sound, flashing LED's, and spinning moire. Superior faux-leather strap and heavy case components. You can opt to run just the lightup screen, the moire spinning, or sound or all 3. You're best bet is ebay.
 
Master Replicas did make a couple years ago a Science Tricorder, high end prop replica for around 250.00? I own one. It does have a cool Cestus III static tactical screen backlit w/ moving target red dots. Has sound, flashing LED's, and spinning moire. Superior faux-leather strap and heavy case components. You can opt to run just the lightup screen, the moire spinning, or sound or all 3. You're best bet is ebay.

The MR tricorders have appreciated considerably in value, however.

Here's a topic over at the RPF with detailed comparisons between the AA/DST and MR tricorders. The MR is accurate to the original prop, the AA/DST is accurate to the HMS version from DS9. While one could focus on the differences, as one poster said there:
Damn... $40 for a piece that close to the MR is amazing. Can't wait to receive mine!
The only real, major letdown, IMO, is the lack of a motor in the hand scanner; however, I cracked the scanner from my unit open and it looks like adding a small motor wouldn't be too hard. The original prop had the body of the motor inside the spinning head, which is hollow on the toy, so there wouldn't be much modification of the unit required.
 
When did you order this? I ordered a regular tricorder from New Force Comics and it hasnt yet shipped.
 
^I think I read somewhere that New Force is behind the curve on shipping.

Mine came from Entertainment Earth, on preorder for the last, oh, three or four months or so.
 
I wrote New Force Friday of last week and the fellow responding was very nice. He explained that the west coast where Ent. Earth is located gets the first items. Makes sense since the toys are shipped from Asia where they are made. Then freight trucks start making their way across the country dropping shipments at distribution centers along the way. Since NewForce is in Florida, well, they are one of the last stops. So it usually takes two to three weeks from the time EE gets them to the time NF receives their stock.

Frustrating to some I'm sure, but I still like NF's prices.

BTW, looking at the sNewForce site today, they've changed the status of the med' tricoders to "in stock". Now, it may be a week or so longer before they get them. The reality may simply be that they are in transit as I type.

Hope this helps.

Sincerely,

Bill

Hmm, I wonder if Art Asylum contemplated a "wind-up" mechanism for the scanner? I could imagine either the "cap" at the bottom or the clear scanner housing at the top being wound and a rachet mechanism keeping the tension until the button is pressed. This releases the spring, letting the inner reflective cylinder to spin several dozen revolutions, enough time to "run a scan". The button would also trigger the "warbling" sound effect which would help to drown the sound of the clockwork mechanism. Even after the clockwork drive runs down, the "warble" would continue as long as the button is held.

Eh, just a crazy thought.
 
Thoughts about science tricorder

Thanks to those who've posted for the info: I find this interesting as a precursor to the science tricorder that I've ordered.

The screen looks to be a problem with its two bright LEDs on the right side. Some people have reported painting over the medical graphic with blue/gray paint (and disabling its LEDs) to better match the look of the tricorder's screen as seen in the show. I hope to achieve a middle ground with the science tricorder once it arrives in a couple of weeks...

If it's possible, I intend to bend the LEDs down, away from the screen, and place aluminum foil along the back and sides of the interior to reflect light toward the screen. Based on what I've read, the screen graphic is sandwiched between an inner and outer clear piece: I plan to place a light blue sheet of paper behind the graphic to better diffuse the reflected light and to simulate the blue/gray default screen color shown in the series. (This is presumably possibly for the medical version, but the in-episode graphic showed a black background for its readout, so that would be inaccurate - however, we never saw a science tricorder's graphic, just the plain blue/gray screen that Spock looked at).

I was initially surprised to learn that the DST science tricorder came with a hand scanner, since I didn't remember one in the show. However, upon review, its scanner seems based on the one Dr. Daystrom used in The Ultimate Computer. That one's light switched among various colors (like yellow, red, and green) without making a sound, and that's what the DST replica looks to do, so it seems pretty accurate:

daystrom.jpg


AA/DST's previous phaser and communicator replicas have pleased me with their balance of quality and affordability, so I'm looking forward to completing the "landing party trifecta."
 
If the one I received yesterday is any indication, it seems the "off pitch" playback of De Kelley's voice is a systemic issue. Yes, he sounds like a munchkin on my tricorder, too. When the communicator plays the voices so well, it does prove to be annoying. But for use as a role-playing or fan film prop, I see little reason to activate the "phrase" button.

And, like the original poster, the LEDs meant to illuminate the readout screen are mounted at the edge and create faint "hot spots". Faint "hot spots" sounds contradictory, but since the rest of the screen is effectively dark, the two barely glowing areas are hot spots only in comparison. It's embarrassing when one remembers the PLayMates toy was better illuminated.

Now I know Trekofile mentioned his hand scanner played the famous "warble" quite faintly. So does mine, even when I installed fresh button cells. (I anything the FX were less audible.) Gep? What about yours? Does it play faintly as well? If so, it play be another systemic design aspect.

Despite this "shortcomings", I still like the prop/toy so I will keep it. I've waited 35+ years for a more accurate (yet affordable) "exploration set", so I doubt we'll get anything better before I leave this mortal coil. The only problem, now I'm too d@mn old to play with the things for fear of public ridicule! :p

Sincerely,

Bill
 
Gep? What about yours? Does it play faintly as well? If so, it play be another systemic design aspect.

Yeah, it's a systemic problem. I cracked the case last week and found that the speaker is buried in the center of the scanner, under the gears that run the spinner. It's marginally louder up close, so part of the problem is poor positioning.

Of course, you can always do what this guy did and rework the scanner with an iPod battery, Playmates sound circuit, RC car motor and aluminum top and bottom plates. :p
 
By the silken breast of Mother Mogg!!! That's what I call upgrading! I can barely install a SIMM board without problems.

Anyway, thanks for the prompt feedback, Gep! :techman:

Sincerely,

Bill
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top