David Archuleta vs. David Cook
Who will be this season's winner?
Who will be this season's winner?
American Idol - Battle of the Davids
- Thread starter Gryffindorian
- Start date
Frak! How does this new poll option work? I was going to add, "Who do you want to win the American Idol title?"
Bah, I thought it was a live telecast. The judges were obviously in favor of Archuleta, although DC had a good performance in Round 1. And what was with the stupid boxing theme tonight?
Congrats to your new American Idol, David Archeleta
Yeah it's unofficial, but it seemed like Cook was mailing it in. Bad choice of songs, and while he sung them well, he didn't connect the way Archie did. That, and the Judges were playing a bit of favoritism. I know the show for me doesn't start until maybe 9:55 PM tomorrow night. That way I can miss all the stuff that comes before it and just see him get the crown.
As for the show, now I'm thinking both Randy and Paula need to be fired. Randy has gotten annoying too with the same thing mouthed week after week.
Yeah it's unofficial, but it seemed like Cook was mailing it in. Bad choice of songs, and while he sung them well, he didn't connect the way Archie did. That, and the Judges were playing a bit of favoritism. I know the show for me doesn't start until maybe 9:55 PM tomorrow night. That way I can miss all the stuff that comes before it and just see him get the crown.
As for the show, now I'm thinking both Randy and Paula need to be fired. Randy has gotten annoying too with the same thing mouthed week after week.
I think last night proves that the final is in the fix. Here's why:
David A, without the win, would fade into obscurity after his teeny bopper debut. David C, however, will sell albums whether he won or not. I think the judges obvious praise of David A. proved that. I find him so dull I sometimes have to change the channel when he's on!
Ya, David A. will win, but David C. will sell more albums...just you wait
David A, without the win, would fade into obscurity after his teeny bopper debut. David C, however, will sell albums whether he won or not. I think the judges obvious praise of David A. proved that. I find him so dull I sometimes have to change the channel when he's on!
Ya, David A. will win, but David C. will sell more albums...just you wait
I think last night proves that the final is in the fix. Here's why:
David A, without the win, would fade into obscurity after his teeny bopper debut. David C, however, will sell albums whether he won or not. I think the judges obvious praise of David A. proved that. I find him so dull I sometimes have to change the channel when he's on!
Ya, David A. will win, but David C. will sell more albums...just you wait
What she said; agreed 100%.... QFT
Q2UnME
C
Cable-X
Guest
David A....by a freakin' mile.
Cook is too generic. A is really good and will get better if he doesn't screw it up (or his Daddy does).
Cook is too generic. A is really good and will get better if he doesn't screw it up (or his Daddy does).
entfan4ever
Captain
Did anyone catch when Randy said this was the ultimate contest of 2007?
It seems he got into Paula's happy pills.
It seems he got into Paula's happy pills.
I'm 180 on this. David A, has a great voice, and when i hear him it's like god he has a great voice...but he has no 'soul'; no character in his voice for lack of a better explanation. I would never buy any of his music.
I do think David C had one of his worse nights, but he can sing anything, the night Simon select his song proved to me he could sing and make anything his own.
^^^ Geez, thanks for the lack of spoiler warning or codes. 
There are those of us on the West Coast who are quite "behind," you know.
My God! Amanda Overmyer, David Hernandez, Chikezie ... Feels like I haven't seen them in ages.
As for whichever David wins, as I've said already, it doesn't matter at this point. They're both deserving, though it would make more sense if D. Cook indeed won. Both have mass appeal to different demographics.
And when did Bryan Adams become an old man? Wow.
EDIT:
You know, this competition reminds me of the Bush-Gore presidential election of 2000. I kind of had a feeling of who was going to win and also had a feeling of who should win.
There are those of us on the West Coast who are quite "behind," you know.My God! Amanda Overmyer, David Hernandez, Chikezie ... Feels like I haven't seen them in ages.
As for whichever David wins, as I've said already, it doesn't matter at this point. They're both deserving, though it would make more sense if D. Cook indeed won. Both have mass appeal to different demographics.
And when did Bryan Adams become an old man? Wow.
EDIT:
You know, this competition reminds me of the Bush-Gore presidential election of 2000. I kind of had a feeling of who was going to win and also had a feeling of who should win.
Last edited:
Well, I'm just enjoying this season finale. The Top 12 were doing a George Michael medley. At some point, the guys were singing "Father Figure," and it was David Hernandez who sang the line "to be warm and naked by your side ..." He smirked, too. I thought that was done intentionally--a little insider joke, I see.
I liked the little Gladys Knight video featuring Ben Stiller, Jack Black, and Robert Downey, Jr. I thought that was cute.
He smirked, too. I thought that was done intentionally--a little insider joke, I see.I liked the little Gladys Knight video featuring Ben Stiller, Jack Black, and Robert Downey, Jr. I thought that was cute.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
