• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Merchantman Size?

Bry_Sinclair

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I'm wondering if there is any sort of consensus on the size of the civilian freighter we first saw in The Search For Spock.

Some sources have the ship as small as 50 meters in length whilst DITL has it down as 150 meters. Of course given how the Klingon Bird-of-Prey changes sizes every time it appears of screen, there's no easy way to try and compare the two to work out a comparison.
 
I can only cite non-canon sources.

According to The Official Starships Collection, posits that the Merchantman is 150m long.

Bernd Schneider estimates the length in excess of 100m in his analysis. In the movie, the ship briefly appears outsized by the bird of prey for dramatic effects. Link: https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/articles/merchantman.htm

According to the defunct Decipher RPGs, in the "Starships" release, the ship is as Monarch-class vessel and 237 meters long. Memory Beta link: https://memory-beta.fandom.com/wiki/Monarch_class

As for aliens using that ship class, I speculate that when the Cardassians bought the design and commissioned the Bok'Nor class, they kept the size. The Sheliak colony ship may be based on the Monarch-class or not, but is much larger either way. The Vidiian Scout-class, may be the same size as the original Alpha/Beta Quadrant spacecraft class.
 
With commercial ships today, any size is fine: shape isn't related to that much. (Alas, with today's ships, you can easily count window rows - it's in silhouette where it becomes irrelevant whether a ship is 75 meters long or 300.)

Many Trek ships are fine in this respect, too: while the Batris family of ships does have windows, it doesn't exactly have window rows, and thus the same shape could represent ships of wildly varying sizes. Nothing much establishes a scale there, after all: there's no "standard container" involved, no docking port, no bridge dome. Just windows of unknown and arbitrary size.

The Merchantman is pretty easy, too. It has a dome, which may be taken for a bridge, and allows for the ship to be kilometers long if we want (it just happens to be a really large bridge, then, but since we never see the interior...). But the dome may be a sensor atop a bridge, too, and this bridge might snugly seat but two guys. Pretty much as we see happen in ST3:TSfS.

Fifty meters is certainly an option, then - and since we see cargo stowed in the very control room, not an unlikely one, either (else wouldn't it all be in the putative holds elsewhere?). But there's little problem with a length of 25 meters, either: this would essentially be the Cardassian runabout, only with broad wings and big "rockets" but with pretty much the same size of control cabin.

Timo Saloniemi
 
I wish I had the money to make my own TNG remastered series.
Merchantman would be a sub-impulse ship and the Sheliak would have a still of the Trident Corsair from Earth*Star Voyager.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top