News RUMOR: Whittaker potentially leaving

[Asbo Zaprudder]

If the series were to end forever, heresy I know, I'd like the Doctor being a paradoxical closed time-like loop, perhaps created by the universe itself as an error correction mechanism for underlying hypercomputation in branchial space.

Closed timelike curve - Wikipedia
Hypercomputation - Wikipedia
Finally We May Have a Path to the Fundamental Theory of Physics… and It’s Beautiful—Stephen Wolfram Writings

 

[The Nth Doctor]

he just has small role in the later part of Ep1

Boooooo!

How dare they waste Sid like that!

 

[Asbo Zaprudder]

Sid was badly underused in Game of Thrones as well - not that more Sid would have prevented that series ending as a almighty clusterfuck.

 

[Australis]

Are we all forgetting Jo Martin already?

They cast a really good actor, irrelevant of ethnicity or gender. If they can do that again, I'm ok with that.

 

[Australis]

What if he thinks a black woman is the best candidate? And is it stunt casting or reflecting the diversity of the modern world and giving opportunities to people from certain groups who were historically precluded from even being considered to play the alien with two hearts whose entire body regenerates every few years...

I kinda wish we could skip forward a few regenerations to a point where it almost doesn't matter who plays the Doctor, but as others have said everyone's going to have an opinion on this.

Hire a white man and you're just defaulting to what's gone before

Hire another woman and you prompt the question "Will the Doctor ever be a bloke again?"

Hire a person of colour and its stunt casting (frankly if Jo Martin is an example of stunt casting then bring it on!)

Lydia West has been awesome in everything I've seen her in, and RTD has used her twice now in Years and Years and It's a Sin (and Moffat's used her once and is using her again, I think Edited to add, yes he is she's in his new show)

I agree with all that.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

Sid was badly underused in Game of Thrones as well - not that more Sid would have prevented that series ending as a almighty clusterfuck.

Never watched it but am very curious why people feel that way about the ending, what happened that upset people?

Also people forgetting Jo Martin is funny to me because she would have made a great Doctor and not afraid to use a gun.

 

[Asbo Zaprudder]

Never watched it but am very curious why people feel that way about the ending, what happened that upset people?

The writing became really bad. I won't go into any more detail but once the show runners went past what GRRM had committed to print, they didn't have a clue how to structure the story cohesively and consistently. It was an utter mess. In fact it was so bad I never want to watch any of it ever again.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

The writing became really bad. I won't go into any more detail but once the show runners went past what GRRM had committed to print, they didn't have a clue how to structure the story cohesively and consistently. It was an utter mess. In fact it was so bad I never want to watch any of it ever again.

OK that sounds quite dire...... I'll have to find youtubes of the ending which I have avoided looking at because of what people have said.

 

[The Nth Doctor]

I had no issues with how Game of Thrones ended (although I agree they also wasted Sid!).

But what do I know? I had no issues with how LOST ended either.

Just don't talk to me about how Battlestar Galactica ended! Ugggggghhhhhh....

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

I had no issues with how Game of Thrones ended (although I agree they also wasted Sid!).

But what do I know? I had no issues with how LOST ended either.

Just don't talk to me about how Battlestar Galactica ended! Ugggggghhhhhh....

You know the BSG ending is one that I really did not like.
It's Fiction people so why didn't they do something bold or different with the ending?

I would have preferred they found their Earth and lived with the natives and taught them basic stuff and had kept some of their technology instead of going native. Also it could have opened up potential for more stories with friendly cylons and such. The way it ended just sucked.

 

[Nerys Myk]

OK that sounds quite dire...... I'll have to find youtubes of the ending which I have avoided looking at because of what people have said.

How exactly can you judge the ending without any context?

 

[The Nth Doctor]

You know the BSG ending is one that I really did not like.
It's Fiction people so why didn't they do something bold or different with the ending?

I would have preferred they found their Earth and lived with the natives and taught them basic stuff and had kept some of their technology instead of going native. Also it could have opened up potential for more stories with friendly cylons and such. The way it ended just sucked.

The nihilist in me wanted the show to end with that long panning shot of the whole cast at the barren Earth in the midseason finale.

 

[DigificWriter]

The writing of Game of Thrones' final season and ending wasn't shit because the creators didn't have novels to draw from; it was just shit.

Also contributing to the backlash against the ending was the fact that the creators spent 7 seasons lying through their teeth about one of the series' most popular characters.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

The nihilist in me wanted the show to end with that long panning shot of the whole cast at the barren Earth in the midseason finale.

Oh actually hell that would have been good. I like that.

@The Return of Zombie Cheerleader I know what you mean. I will have a look later on. Just a lot of people I know hated it so I trust their opinions and never bothered to check it out for myself.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Oh actually hell that would have been good. I like that.

@The Return of Zombie Cheerleader I know what you mean. I will have a look later on. Just a lot of people I know hated it so I trust their opinions and never bothered to check it out for myself.

I hated it, but I've read the books and watched the show. So I knew the characters, the plot lines and the setting. I can't see coming in on the final act of a play or the last chapter of a book and saying it sucked. Makes no sense.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

I hated it, but I've read the books and watched the show. So I knew the characters, the plot lines and the setting. I can't see coming in on the final act of a play or the last chapter of a book and saying it sucked. Makes no sense.

Well not to say that, but just to see what happens.

 

[Starkers]

The writing became really bad. I won't go into any more detail but once the show runners went past what GRRM had committed to print, they didn't have a clue how to structure the story cohesively and consistently. It was an utter mess. In fact it was so bad I never want to watch any of it ever again.

But hadn't GRRM told them what was going to happen and given them the structure of the novels? All the narrative choices were GRRM's surely? Won't argue they didn't rush it because they did but I never got the impression they were heading anywhere GRRM didn't want them to go.

I had no issues with how Game of Thrones ended (although I agree they also wasted Sid!).

But what do I know? I had no issues with how LOST ended either.

Just don't talk to me about how Battlestar Galactica ended! Ugggggghhhhhh....

I was never the biggest fan of BSG and right from the start I realised there were only two possible endings (well three if they went down the BSG1980 route) They found earth and it was the distant past and they became our ancestors, or they found earth and it was the future.

The nihilist in me wanted the show to end with that long panning shot of the whole cast at the barren Earth in the midseason finale.

That's how it should have ended.

The writing of Game of Thrones' final season and ending wasn't shit because the creators didn't have novels to draw from; it was just shit.

Also contributing to the backlash against the ending was the fact that the creators spent 7 seasons lying through their teeth about one of the series' most popular characters.

Or they spent 7 years showing us exactly who the mother of dragons really was. Did they rush her final tip over the edge, probably, was that where she was always headed? Absolutely.

 

[Asbo Zaprudder]

But hadn't GRRM told them what was going to happen and given them the structure of the novels? All the narrative choices were GRRM's surely? Won't argue they didn't rush it because they did but I never got the impression they were heading anywhere GRRM didn't want them to go.

GRRM has apparently stated that he will go in a different direction. If they did use his outline, the show apparently exposed its weaknesses.

I was never the biggest fan of BSG and right from the start I realised there were only two possible endings (well three if they went down the BSG1980 route) They found earth and it was the distant past and they became our ancestors, or they found earth and it was the future.
That's how it should have ended.

There are other possible endings but none are particularly satisfying or entertaining ones. But, hey, who says life has to have meaning or be satisfying? That's unrealistic. I thought the ending made sense as I had predicted it during season one. It's the eternal return of Nietzsche, J M Barrie, and Ecclesiastes 1:9-18.

9 What has happened before will happen again. What has been done before will be done again. There is nothing new in the whole world.
10 "Look," they say, "here is something new!" But no, it has all happened before, long before we were born.
11 No one remembers what has happened in the past, and no one in days to come will remember what happens between now and then.
12 I, the Philosopher, have been king over Israel in Jerusalem.
13 I determined that I would examine and study all the things that are done in this world. God has laid a miserable fate upon us.
14 I have seen everything done in this world, and I tell you, it is all useless. It is like chasing the wind.
15 You can't straighten out what is crooked; you can't count things that aren't there.
16 I told myself, "I have become a great man, far wiser than anyone who ruled Jerusalem before me. I know what wisdom and knowledge really are."
17 I was determined to learn the difference between knowledge and foolishness, wisdom and madness. But I found out that I might as well be chasing the wind.
18 The wiser you are, the more worries you have; the more you know, the more it hurts.

God has laid a miserable fate upon us. There you go. Suck it up, my creation.

Or they spent 7 years showing us exactly who the mother of dragons really was. Did they rush her final tip over the edge, probably, was that where she was always headed? Absolutely.

Yes! For example, Daenerys Targaryen crucified 163 Great Masters of Meereen to prove a point. She wasn't averse to violence to get her way. The problem was I don't think the directors conveyed to Emilia Clarke that she needed to portray an abused woman who had a simmering, underlying ruthlessness and sense of entitlement. I don't think Daenerys's behaviour was the result of her experiences; I think it was in her genes - it was nature, not nurture all along.

What we discussing again?

Any thoughts on how many of the audience for JW's final season are going to have to turn on the subtitles for John Bishop? My ear is attuned to the Scouse accent thankfully.

 

[Lonemagpie]

What a brilliant idea for relaunching the series, binging in new viewers and bringing back lapsed ones that would be.

Big Finish will no doubt pump out as much Jo Martin as people want once they get the rights to 13-era material next year.

Undoubtedly. It's their way.

 

[Lonemagpie]

If the series were to end forever, heresy I know, I'd like the Doctor being a paradoxical closed time-like loop, perhaps created by the universe itself as an error correction mechanism for underlying hypercomputation in branchial space.

Closed timelike curve - Wikipedia
Hypercomputation - Wikipedia
Finally We May Have a Path to the Fundamental Theory of Physics… and It’s Beautiful—Stephen Wolfram Writings

Which is pretty much what the Timeless Child sets up, IMO. They just need the Quantum Leap bar to sign off on it.