• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Looking back - Voyager, season 2

donners22

Commodore
Commodore
Sorry, it's been a while since the first season, but I'm slowly getting through the Borg Cube box set. Here is a look back at Season 2.


There are three notable features of Voyager's second season – stand-out guests, bizarre plots and running plot threads.

The season certainly begins oddly. A truck floating in space, the Doctor "realising" he is real and the rest of the crew are holograms, aliens trying to mate with the ship, Kim back on Earth having never joined Voyager's crew... Their scientific basis rarely stands up to close scrutiny, but taken in the right spirit, they are fun. These episodes would provide a stark contrast to the machinations and intrigue that surrounded the ongoing plot of a traitor on Voyager. The show's co-creator, the late Michael Piller, says the writers were taking "creative risks" and aimed for "distinctive television", and there are certainly several unusual plots.

Of the more regular episodes, "Initiations" gave us our first real insight into Kazon culture. Though the young Kazon is too recognisable as Aaron Eisenberg, with Nog's voice and mannerisms, it fleshes out the season's main villains well. There is a belated and underwhelming follow-up to "Caretaker" with "Cold Fire", "Tattoo" offers some insight into Chakotay and Neelix's jealousy over Kes is finally resolved in "Parturition" - though not before much damage has been done to the character.

Voyager's first big-name guest is Academy Award winner Joel Grey, who plays an aged rebel. His heartbreaking performance lifts the otherwise standard "Resistance" into one of the best episodes to date. Horror star Brad Dourif appears as the murdering Betazoid Lon Suder in "Meld", though he is upstaged by a deranged Tuvok, played brilliantly by Tim Russ. Michael McKean rounds out the star guests, playing the embodiment of Fear in "The Thaw". He holds captive Harry Kim (who is also killed for the second time and sent to an alternate timeline this season) and dominates the scenes in his bizarre realm. Unsurprisingly, this episode is written by Joe Menosky, known for several of TNG's odd episodes.

"Death Wish" is perhaps the best Voyager episode to this point, featuring Q's first appearance in Voyager and the introduction of a suicidal Q. Though Q is not truly at his menacing best, the episode is thought-provoking and well executed. "Tuvix" with Tuvok and Neelix merged into a single distinct person is also a talking point thanks to Janeway’s controversial solution – effectively, a murder.
Less impressive is "Threshold", regularly voted one of the show's worst episodes and described by writer Brannon Braga in an Easter egg interview as a "royal, steaming stinker".

It is the Maquis plots that provide the "meat" of the season. Voyager has transporter technology stolen and a crewman turns traitor, leading to a subtle plot in which Paris gradually seems to abandon his role on board. This baffled and annoyed many reviewers at the time, with the true purpose of the actions – using Paris to expose the traitor – was revealed. Watching Janeway compromise her ideals to try and ally first with the Kazon, then their enemies, results in the terrific episode "Alliances". This all builds to Voyager's first cliffhanger, "Basics", which leaves the crew stranded on a volatile planet, with a cave monster and primitive tribe, Tom's fate unknown after he flees in a shuttle and only the Doctor and Suder left on the ship which has been taken over by the Kazon. The episode left plenty of threads dangling, as a good cliffhanger should do. Piller notes that the title is a message that the series is taking a "back to basics" approach, and notes the fast pace is influenced by shows like "ER".

Extras are fairly limited and unremarkable. "The 37s" features text commentary, curiously in large blue boxes rather than the usual subtitles. Perhaps the best extra, aside from Braga’s aforementioned blunt comments, is a music clip of Tim Russ performing "Kushangaza", the eponymous track from his 2001 album. Russ, like several of his Voyager castmates (Jeri Ryan and Robert Picardo) is a terrific singer. Imagine Star Trek: The Musical, with those three, Brent Spiner and Avery Brooks…
 
When season two originally aired back in 1995-1996 I wasn't too impressed with it. I thought it was quite middling with no consistency. I was hoping for the same kind of entertaining stories from TNG--high concept sci-fi mysteries, character dramas, morality plays but that didn't happen.

I had problems with the rather silly plots and uninteresting stories, the lack of developing any real interesting alien races, and the characters not connecting with me. Episodes like Initiations or Tattoo had good ideas but were executed in a rather dull way.

Elogium, Twisted, Parturition, Innocence, Non Sequitir, The Thaw, Resolutions, Dreadnought, Prototype, Cold Fire were quite underwhelming.

One bright spot was Seska-a truly compelling antagonist for the crew. I enjoyed the subplot with Jonas and traitor Paris. I enjoyed episodes like Persistence of Vision, Alliances, Deadlock, Manuevers. Basics was a great season finale and a nice culmination of the season's various arcs.

Looking back now I still don't see it as a great or solid season but it did in hindsight come closer to what I watch Trek for. There was an attempt to focus on the characters and I do experience nostalgia looking back when there were still mentions of bioneural gelpacks, Kes, Janeway's bun, Kazon, Vidiians, the Doctor confined to sickbay, talk of establishing holo projectors, Janeway's holonovel, Seska, Maje Culluh etc. I still think season four was the show's best season.
 
He holds captive Harry Kim (who is also killed for the second time and sent to an alternate timeline this season) and dominates the scenes in his bizarre realm.
Wait, Harry was killed once prior to Deadlock? :confused:

Edit: Oh, right! He did in Emanations... duh me, LOL. :scream:
 
yeah the Paris/Seska plot was great I was genuinyl worriewd that Tom was leaving the show! As i was watching my boyfriends dvds at the time, and he didn't tell me any spoilers, i really did think he would go!!!!!
 
Season 2 is one of my favourite seasons of the show, particularly because of the Kazon/Seska arc which was a good way of reminding the audience that this crew really is two crews combined and didn't initially start out as one unified crew. In between these arc episodes there are standout episodes like Deadlock, Cold fire, Resistance, Death Wish, Lifesigns, Tuvix and The Thaw.
 
donners22 said:
offers some insight into Chakotay and Neelix's jealousy over Kes is finally resolved in "Parturition"

Wasn't the jealousy between Paris and Neelix? :p Just thought I'd point it out.

I enjoyed reading your look-back to season 2. :) I actually didn't start getting into the show until around season 4, but whenever I catch earlier seasons on television, I become rather nostalgic. Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

Agreed that there were a lot of underwhelming episodes and I tend to think season 2 wasn't the strongest in comparison to the other seasons but it did have a few interesting storylines - the traitor, Seska etc - but otherwise the season didn't leave a huge impression in my books. I actually had a hard time remembering which episodes were which. :lol:

^^^ By the way, I think a musical would have made the season much better. :p
 
^ You missed part of a sentence there. I said the episode "Tattoo" offered an insight into Chakotay, THEN that another episode resolved the jealousy of Neelix regarding Kes.

Probably my fault - my punctuation perhaps could have made it clearer rather than running two different points together. :)
 
Honestly, I liked S2. Although there were some stinker eps...Emanations, Threshold, Partuition. This is the season where all the crap happened..Seska and the Kazon take over the ship, there is a spy aboard who has to be taken care of(Neelix to the rescue!), and Neelix's jealousy over Kes(even though I didn't like the ep overall).
Good eps: Basics, Alliances, Resistance, Maneuvers, Resolutions
 
Voyager's first big-name guest is Academy Award winner Joel Grey, who plays an aged rebel. His heartbreaking performance lifts the otherwise standard "Resistance" into one of the best episodes to date.

I actually think Resistance is one of the weaker episodes of the season. It just doesn't do anything for me. I do find Grey's performance to be heartbreaking at times, but also find it to be a bit overdone at times, too. YMMV.

I found it interesting that Piller rates this season as one of the better ones he was involved with. It's good, but it's too uneven to hold up against TNG Seasons three through six, DS9's second season, and VOY's first season. Still, it does have the Kazon/Seska storyline going for it, which results in several top notch episodes IMO. I wish VOY had continued with that type of storytelling, but alas, it was not to be.
 
I liked Season 2. The Kazon arc was interesting, leading up to Basics which I really enjoyed as a finale, and there were many other entertaining episodes like: Projections, Resistance, Deadlock, Persistence of Vision, and the episode with the honor of being my personal "Masks" episode of the year (Meaning an episode I loved because of it's quarkieness even though it seemed like everyone hated it) was The Thaw. That clown was weird.
 
^ Actually, I think The Thaw is generally fairly well regarded. Most reviews I've seen have been positive, and it's one of my favourites.
 
"The Thaw" is one of those episodes that fans tend to have strong opinions about one way or the other. I'm on the "hate it" side.
 
Some of my favorite VOY episodes come from this very season, such as Death Wish, Life Signs, and Tuvix.

Personally, VOY should have kept the arcs in the later seasons, but obviously UPN forbade the producers and writers from doing that.
 
I remember having a negative impression of The Thaw when I first watched it several years ago, and I didn't see it again until I was watching the S2 DVD set recently. This time around I was pretty impressed with it. The ending was very interesting, I thought. I think the episode really tries to be more than just fluff, which is what a lot of latter day Voyager seemed to me. Maybe that's why I appreciate it more now.
 
I hate The Thaw. It came off too campy for my tastes and fear/clowns/the sadistic carnival aspect never really unsettled me just made me roll my eyes.
 
I think it's interesting to note that the first four episodes of S2 were originally filmed as part of S1.

The 37s
in particular works better as a season-ender than it does as a premiere. :)
 
"The Thaw" is one of those episodes that fans tend to have strong opinions about one way or the other. I'm on the "hate it" side.

Just like Masks, even though more people are on the hated side than the liked side. It's nice to be in a minority. :D
 
I thought "The Thaw" was a really interesting episode and I enjoyed it. It's one of the few episodes of Voyager that I really remember well. Most Voyager episodes just blend and blur together for me.
 
I didn't like 'The Thaw' at first (it seemed to be FAR from what Voyager usually had been) but I have to say that I enjoyed it. It felt kind of like a sadistic Barney episode for a while but the themes were pretty relevant.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top