• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Grade: Roger Moore's James Bond movies

Dream

Admiral
Admiral
What grade would you give each of Moore's Bond movies?

Live And Let Die
The Man With The Golden Gun
The Spy Who Loved Me
Moonraker
For Your Eyes Only
Octopussy
A View To Kill


I recently bought a bunch for Bond movies for cheap on dvd. I suddenly realized that I've only seen and own one of Moore's bond movies The Spy Who Loved Me. I've never really made the effort to check out the rest of his movies since I dislike camp. Are his other movies worth owning?
 
While his movies are not cinematic masterpieces, they are a lot of fun.

Personally, I really enjoy Octopussy. The Spy Who Loved Me and For Your Eyes Only are generally well-received. A View to a Kill and Moonraker are generally disliked (though the latter is usually praised for it's special effects).

All that being said, your mileage may vary.
 
Here's how I would grade them:

Live And Let Die - B
The Man With The Golden Gun - C
The Spy Who Loved Me - B
Moonraker - D+
For Your Eyes Only - A+
Octopussy - A-
A View To Kill - F
 
Live and Let Die: C

Bond does blaxploitation. Not a whole lot to like here, very lackluster action (boat chase towards the end brings the movie to a screeching halt) feels very low budget overall, but it's got a lively score and some of the villains are fairly entertaining (Tee-Hee, Baron Samedi).

The Man With the Golden Gun: B

Many people don't like this one, I however do. Very campy, but in a somewhat good way. Christopher Lee as Scaramanga makes for a great villain, Far more exotic locales than the previous two films, pretty entertaining overall.

The Spy Who Loved Me: A-

After a decade, Bond feels big budget blockbuster again! Lots of classic stuff here. A bit rough around the edges though and very formulaic.

Moonraker: C+

Maintains the big budget feel of the previous film and even seems a bit more polished production-wise, but the plot is both a rehash of the previous film's and also downright absurd. Still, it occasionally has it's moments.

For Your Eyes Only: A

The grittiest, most down to earth, and best of the Moore outings IMO. Decent, believable action, hardly any gadgets, campiness kept to a minimum, and what had been my favorite Bond girl til Vesper came along!

Octopussy: B

Kind of a bipolar film here. The India parts are VERY campy, but the Germany parts are pretty decent. Fairly good overall, but nothing about it truly stands out.

A View to a Kill: F

My least favorite of the entire Bond series. Only good thing here is the fantastic Duran Duran theme. Everything else is downright lackluster and uninspired. Post-plastic surgery Moore looks terrible here, worst Bond girl ever, Christopher Walken's laughably bad, bleh, yuck, ptooey, I hate it.
 
I've only seen three of those so far. "The Spy Who Loved Me" is actually one of my favorite of all of the Bond movies. I don't remember much about "For Your Eyes Only" since it's been so long since I've seen it. "Moonraker" was pretty good and it was cool to see "Jaws" help Bond at the end.
 
A View to Kill is pretty bad, i don't think I ever even finished. The same was true about Moonraker until a few weeks ago, wow that movie is horrible too!

Three words... Space Shuttle Laser....

The rest i can't remember off hand.
 
A View to Kill is pretty bad, i don't think I ever even finished. The same was true about Moonraker until a few weeks ago, wow that movie is horrible too!

Three words... Space Shuttle Laser....

The rest i can't remember off hand.

In fairness, Moonraker did give us an awesome weapon for GoldenEye 64.
 
A View to Kill is pretty bad, i don't think I ever even finished. The same was true about Moonraker until a few weeks ago, wow that movie is horrible too!

Three words... Space Shuttle Laser....

The rest i can't remember off hand.

In fairness, Moonraker did give us an awesome weapon for GoldenEye 64.

Moonraker also got Jaws laid, which makes it a strong B, B+ in my book.
 
Live And Let Die B-
The Man With The Golden Gun C+
The Spy Who Loved Me B
Moonraker C-
For Your Eyes Only B
Octopussy C+
A View To Kill D+
 
I didn't know Moore had plastic surgery between Octopussy and A View to a Kill. :eek:
You be the judge. :lol:

moore1.jpg
moore2.jpg


His eyes are just downright creepy looking in AVTAK.
 
In order of preference:

The Spy Who Loved Me
For Your Eyes Only
Live And Let Die
Moonraker
A View To A Kill
Octopussy
The Man With The Golden Gun

Why that order in the lower half? Moonraker's ludicrous, but it's so campy and goofy and OTT that it has a certain charm. View is tired (both with the age of its star and its recycling of old material) but for me it has a fun nostalgia factor, plus Christopher Walken hamming it up as a bad guy who truly enjoys his evil deeds and flies around in an airship. Octopussy has a genuinely good action sequence (the train), while not even Christopher Lee can save poor old Golden Gun.
 
Here's how they roll for me:

Live And Let Die - A
The Man With The Golden Gun - A
The Spy Who Loved Me - D
Moonraker - D
For Your Eyes Only - D
Octopussy - B
A View To Kill - D

Live And Let Die is my favorite Bond film; it's the first one I ever saw in the theater, way back when I was in Junior High. Man With The Golden Gun was almost as good, but there was an unfortunate crash in quality right after that and, despite a brief resurgence in Octopussy, the Moore films are overall pretty bad.
 
Live & Let Die is a lot of fun. Roger Moore seems to have a strong handle on the role right out of the gate (as opposed to Pierce Brosnan, who took a whole movie to warm up). Jane Seymour is very sexy as Solitaire. And Yaphet Kotto is always awesome.

The Spy Who Loved Me has a lot of great action scenes in it. It's kind of a prototypical James Bond movie. To some degree, I think most of the movies that followed it owe a lot to its structure & vibe. Plus, we have this movie to thank for Pinewood's massive 007 stage, which has since housed such other big budget films as Alien & Superman.

Moonraker isn't quite as bad as many make it out to be but they still shouldn't have gone there.

For Your Eyes Only doesn't really do anything for me. It's got some good stuff but it doesn't gel.

Octopussy is where it becomes very clear that Roger Moore is too old for the role.

I've not yet seen The Man with the Golden Gun or A View to a Kill.
 
Live And Let Die - a fairly solid start for Moore. I've always thought that you could see Connery in this movie, just as you could see Moore in Diamonds Are Forever. 7/10

The Man With the Golden Gun - Did we need to see that silly sherrif again? And why did they spoil the best stunt in the movie - the loop-the-loop car - with a silly sound effect? Some decent enough scenes but a disappointing sophamore effort. 5/10

The Spy Who Loved Me. In some ways, this has become as definitive a template for Bond movies as Goldfinger was. Great settings, scenes, gadgets (the submarine car), Jaws is fairly menacing and some of the most memorable Bond girls. 8/10

Moonraker. Oh dear. After the success of Star Wars, this is basically TSWLM in Space but to lesser effect. The opening scene is brilliant but nothing thereafter comes anywhere near. 4/10

For Your Eyes Only. I like this one a lot. As has been said, more grit, fewer gadgets and, of course, great locations etc. Not to mention many great action sequences, including a genuinely exciting climax, with Bond climbing the cliff-face as the villains remove his pegs. 8/10. Had Rog ended his run then, he'd have had a fairly good innings. But no ...

Octopussy. Actually, it's been so long since I've seen this that I'm not sure it's fair for me to grade it. I remember enjoying the scenes with the mini-plane flying through the building at the start. But I also remember hating the 'SIT!' scene and Bond dressed as a clown getting laughed at by a bunch of students. I just remember thinking that Connery's Bond would never have tolerated this shit.

A View to A Kill. Embarrassing. Did they bring Patrick Macnee in just to make Rog look less old? If so, it didn't work. No memorable action scenes, a forgettable Bond girl, a crap theme tune. Even Christopher Walken can't save this one. 3/10.
 
Live And Let Die B+ Great debut for Roger, and the closest we’ll ever get to a 007 horror film. Tad dated now but Yaphet Koto is always good value, Jane Seymour is lovely, and the soundtrack rocks! Also features one of my favourite Moore scenes. Where Rosie says he wouldn’t kill her after what they just did. “I certainly wouldn’t have killed you before.” :lol: fantastic

The Man With The Golden Gun B There’s nothing really bad about this, it’s just a bit average. As someone said, they ruined the car stunt with a silly sound effect (and I wish someone would reissue the damn thing and take that out). Christopher Lee is great though, Scaramanga is a wonderful villain and he and Bond have some nice scenes together.

The Spy Who Loved Me: AThe best Moore and probably in the top five of Bonds, which is slightly odd given it is a retread of You Only Live Twice. Very epic and cinematic, the final battle inside the tanker is fantastic (something modern Bond’s have missed if you ask me, the big battle) Barbara Bach is a great foil and it features some of my favourite Moore moments. For someone who people joke can’t act, the flicker of pain that flashes across his face when XXX makes reference to him having been married is great. Similarly his offhand murder of Mr Fekesh (I think) with the flick of his tie. Connery was a thug, you wouldn’t ever be surprised when he acted cold blooded. Moore’s so damn amiable it quite shocks. All this plus the best pre-title sequence ever!

Moonraker: B+ So easy to be a snob about and hate, and I sure as hell wouldn’t want every Bond film to be remotely this ridiculous, but as a one off this is a hugely enjoyable, fun film. Astronauts, with lasers, fighting in orbit! I watched this again just a few weeks ago and I really wish they’d reissue it because I’d love to see it on a big screen. The effects are wonderful. There is a lot of subtlety to the film, and a few scenes that are outright creepy. Corrine’s death at the hands of Dobermans for example feels like a scene from an Omen film, and similarly Manuela being threatened by Jaws in a giant Rio outfit in the alleyway is decidedly creepy. Roger Moore is the only Bond who could get away with going into space!

For Your Eyes Only: D+ I want to like this, want to admire it’s back to basics spy thriller roots, but unfortunately I just find it terminally dull.

Octopussy: B Very underrated Bond film this. The villains are interesting, the settings original (only Bond film set in India? How many have we had in the bloody Caribbean!) the nefarious plot manages to be fantastical yet believable, and they pair Moore with a Bond girl old enough to be his daughter rather than his grand daughter which is a plus.

A View To Kill C Ok, it’s bad, very bad, but frankly it is at least more fun to watch than FYEO. The Paris scenes are fun, and the airship ending quite well done. It’s so badly realised though, surrounding Bond with really young vital villains just makes Moore look even older than he actually is, and partnering him with (the wonderful) Patrick Macnee just adds to this. Tanya Robert’s audition for worst Bond girl ever doesn’t help matters.
 
Live And Let Die - D
The Man With The Golden Gun - E
The Spy Who Loved Me - A
Moonraker - B
For Your Eyes Only - A
Octopussy - C
A View To Kill - F
 
The Man With the Golden Gun - Did we need to see that silly sherrif again?

Yes. He must be in all of Richard Lester's movies. See also: Superman II.

Actually, Guy Hamilton directed TMWTGG (and LALD, I think). Lester hasn't directed any Bond movies, as far as I know. But Tom Mankiewicz wrote or co-wrote all three movies - perhaps that's who you're thinking of. Yes, the inclusion of an identical sheriff in Superman II was definitely not required either!

But to be fair to him, without Mankiewicz, we would have gotten the silly script in the vein of the 1960s Batman which Mario Puzo turned in for Superman The Movie.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top