DC's New 52: Reviews and Discussion (Spoilers welcolme and likely)

[Mr Light]

Yeah, there's basically five really good books... after that it was hard to come up with five more

 

[Admiral_Young]

Oh damn. I guess I have to add "Batman Incorporated" to my list. It'd be number two under Action Comics So its a top six list.

 

[Saga]

Yeah, there's basically five really good books... after that it was hard to come up with five more

well, i enjoy books like Batgirl and all the Legion stuff too. but then there are books like Justice League and Firestorm that i keep wanting to drop.

 

[Trekker4747]

1. Batman - The last couple issues have been meh, but it's a pretty good book. My favorite Batman book.
2. Superman - A book I more or less like it has its flaws though.
3. Action Comics - Enjoyable the last few issues have really improved.
4. Supergirl: A good book but I think the story need to pick up some pace.
5. Batgirl - A fun book with a fun character.
6. Aquaman - It's impressive to me how good this book is considering I've never been an Aquaman fan.
7. Catwoman - I've mostly enjoyed this, last couple issues are meh, though.
8. Flash - Hit and miss but mostly interesting.
9. Detective - I go either way on this book but it's shown signs of improvement the last couple issues.
10. The Dark Knight - I'm surprised how long I've stuck with this one, actually but the last couple of issues seem to be leading to something interesing.
11. Wonder Woman - This book really needs to pick up and I find the art to be hit and miss.
12. Batman and Robin - Dropped. Just wasn't doing anything for me.

 

[Captain Craig]

Yeah, there's basically five really good books... after that it was hard to come up with five more

Yeah, same here. At least as far as 'really good' is concerned.

1. Aquaman
2. All-Star Western
3. Frankenstein: Agent of Shade
4. Resurrection Man
5. Swamp Thing

 

[Hound of UIster]

Yeah, there's basically five really good books... after that it was hard to come up with five more

You are just not reading the good titles. WonderWoman/Batwoman/Swamp Thing/Animal Man/I Vampire/All Star Western/Frankenstein are worlds better than the entire second half of your list. And Green Lantern? Really that titles belongs at #50 with shit like TDK.

 

[Admiral_Young]

Has anyone posted this? Earth 2 Superman design. It reflects Earth 2 Supergirl's pretty well.

http://www.newsarama.com/comics/dc-comics-earth-2-designs-120227.html

 

[Mr Light]

I am reading Wonder Woman and Batwoman, and I do not get the praise for them. Aside from the interesting art design, nothing really stands out about Batwoman. I'm all for having gay/lesbian characters of course, it's just not an interesting book. And WW I've always struggled to care about. I don't like magic/gods in comic books. So combine that with the incredibly average art... meh.

 

[Guy Gardener]

The only thing I'm really really digging is Aquaman, and if you squint JLI, even with Jurgens, is basically the same book it was 24 years ago.

i read the first 6 issues of Superman the other night.

horrible.

But I needed that under my belt before Giffen set up shop.

 

[OdoWanKenobi]

Batman and Aquaman are the standouts for me. The Lantern books I'm reading mostly out of loyalty to the characters. They've been a bit less impressive than usual ever since Blackest Night, really. I'm enjoying the Flash, too, come to think of it.

 

[Mr Light]

The GL franchise definitely peaked with Blackest Night, but I did enjoy "War of the Green Lanterns". The main book has always been good. I absolutely loved GLC in the early days with the Patrick Gleason art (he draws the best aliens and planets period).

 

[Mike Farley]

I'd say the GL franchise peaked with the Sinestro Corps War and gradually fell off after that, with a big slip after Blackest Night. I dropped all the relaunched books after the first issues.

 

[Mr Light]

Sinestro Corps was better than Blackest Night, but BN was the natural climax of the story.

 

[Derishton]

Top ten titles: All Star Western, Demon Knights, Batwing, Justice League Dark, I, Vampire (who knew?), Wonder Woman, Frankenstein, Action, Justice League. Er ... I don;t seem to have come up with ten. I do love Batwoman, but I'm not reading it until the trade because it isn't served well by the Comixology format.

 

[Admiral_Young]

The new Shazam (er Captain Marvel).


http://www.bleedingcool.com/2012/03/05/shazam-the-new-cloaked-look-of-captain-marvel/

Not sure I like this...Johns quote made me laugh. A lot of people think Captain Marvel's name was Shazam? Who did they think the Wizard was then? The Wizard?

 

[Enterprise is Great]

Sadly over the years I've heard plenty of people who thought that Captain Marvel was named Shazam. It's not nearly as common as people who call Spock "Doctor Spock" though.

 

[ncc71877]

I'm a tad suprised they didn't go with Captain Thunder.

http://www.newsarama.com/comics/james-robinson-describes-earth-2.html

James Robinson talks about Earth 2 and the first look at the new Jay/Flash on the cover to issue 2.
I wonder if he gets his speed from the helmet?

ncc71877

 

[Mike Farley]

NuEarth 2 Flash is perfectly hideous. I'm ascared to see NuEarth 2 Green Lantern.

 

[Professor Zoom]

NuEarth 2 Flash is perfectly hideous. I'm ascared to see NuEarth 2 Green Lantern.

I looks like a bastardization of the Evil Flash from Earth 3 or 2 from continuities ago. Johnny Quick of the Crime Syndicate.

And it looks fucking awful.

 

[Derishton]

Yeah, I've been excited for Earth-2 but each announcement/interview cuts into my enthusiasm a little bit. I don't really want to see an Elseworlds Trinity. I don't really want the connection with WWII severed. I wouldn't mind seeing something like Robinson's JLA on Earth-2, actually. But it's clear as day we're just getting an angrier Justice League.

The Robinson interview at least gives me a little hope that they're planning something with some of the original Titans.