• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers TOS: Lost to Eternity by Greg Cox Review Thread

Rate Lost To Eternity

  • Outstanding

    Votes: 19 52.8%
  • Above Average

    Votes: 13 36.1%
  • Average

    Votes: 4 11.1%
  • Below Average

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Poor

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    36
Star Trek is not historical fiction. It's an attempt to approximate the future in a way that's accessible to its contemporary audience. That meant that in the '60s, it was written with the vocabulary used by '60s writers and viewers, but now it's the 2020s and it would be pointless to present a 2020s audience with 23rd-century characters who sound like they're from the 1960s.

Gene Roddenberry himself saw ST as a dramatic recreation of the "actual" events in Kirk's logs, and he was the first to say that any change in a new version (like giving the Klingons ridges in TMP) was just a refinement in how the events were dramatized for the audience, rather than an actual in-universe change. He believed that later versions of ST should be updated for their contemporary audience's taste and understanding, because he was trying to evoke the future, not the past.

Incidentally, I can find no reason to believe that "good call" is a term of recent vintage. The term originally comes from sports, referring to the call made by a referee or umpire, and an Ngram search shows its use in writing peaking in the 1920s with a lesser peak in the late 1950s, though declining by the later '60s. Older documents seem to use the phrase in a different sense, but I found one document from 1970 that used the phrase to convey approval of someone's decision.
i suppose agree to disagree. i really like trek novels that hew to how the dialog was written in each era of show / movie. to me that provides an extra level of immersion when reading fiction based on existing media properties. when reading a TOS novel feels like watching the show.

still, there's no excuse for The Mission District. :lol:
 
Wow, that blurb for the 2024 portion of the book is both the coolest and cleverest idea for a Trek story I've heard of in a long time! I've been out of the TrekLit loop for way too long plus I'm usually not a TOS novel guy...but I think I'll grab this one. I've always enjoyed Greg's work in the past. Looking forward to seeing how all the plots converge.
Well I'm a little late to the party, but I finally had time to pick this up and I loved it!

As I was expecting, the 2024 story was probably my favorite. It's just such a fun idea to see a years-later investigation into the absurdity of a comedy movie's plot through a believable "real" person's eyes. The planet-based adventure in 2268 was terrific too. The TOS Klingons were pitch-perfect, the locals were fun ("O Captain!" :lol:,) the monster battles were cool, it was just generally a good time. I would have loved to see it on screen in an imaginary world where TOS was given Marvel movie budgets for an episode. I also liked how it all converged in the end, but I did miss the fun momentum of the every-third-chapter-A-B-C storytelling when we stopped visiting 2292 as often in the second half of the book. To be fair though, plot-wise that made sense since the story kind of had to resolve in the "future" so the narrative stepped back from that timeline for a bit while the other 2 stories took the lead. Great use of Saavik too.

Overall this was an awesome way to get back into TrekLit after way too much time away. I grew up on TNG with a dash of the 80s movies, so I've never been super attached to TOS. That said, I'm inspired to pick up some of @Greg Cox's other TOS books after this one - when the classic characters are written so authentically I find myself getting into TOS prose way more than the show. Plenty to choose from I know. Thanks for a great read!
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top