As a viewer, I always prefer to have the next episode available immediately, so that I can go on to it right away if time allows. The unfortunate truth is, though, that I don’t usually have a lot of time available for TV. Even though
Fallout was released all at once, it took me a little over three weeks to get through the season… and it was only eight episodes. Being a very spoiler-adverse person, trying to avoid spoilers on “drop all at once” seasons becomes difficult.
I have come to appreciate the weekly release model, though. I’m actually glad that Star Trek generally follows that model, since it allows me to keep up with everyone else. I can follow along in the episode discussion threads and see how everyone else reacted to the episode, and where our views matched or differed, which is part of the fun. If Trek seasons were released all at once, the conversation would have well moved on by the time I was ready to jump in.
Not to mention, I see how it’s better for P+, since a 10 week release schedule will typically require 3 months of subscription. I only stay subscribed while new Trek is airing, and based on my
Fallout example, I could probably get through 10 episodes in about one month.
For
Prodigy, I think my ideal release schedule would be weekly, but with two episodes per week. The shorter run time of the animated shows means that a single episode is over before you know it. Releasing two at a time would give you roughly the same amount of content per week as the live-action shows.
Vox had an interesting article a couple days ago about this very topic:
https://www.vox.com/culture/353427/why-does-tv-feel-so-underwhelming-yet-so-overwhelming