That year, Shaq was once again the most "valuable" player in the league even if AI had the more flashy year. That being the case, the sportswriters voted for AI as MVP. These same writers also voted Larry Brown Coach of the year, Mutumbo Def Player of the year, and that other 6er guard 6th Man of the Year. This apparently "super-talented" team led by a wunderkind coach, managed only one fluke win in the Finals against the real MVP that year.Iverson certainly earned that one if you go either by best player or most valuable player to a team.
That team had two NBA 50 Greats on it, the coach who currently has the most championships, and some of the best supporting players in Fisher and Horry. The Sixers had a heavily injured Iverson, an injured Aaron McKey (sixth man), the starting small forward out with a foot injury, and the starting point guard having returned from an injury a month before the regular season ended.
That Laker team was great. They lost one game in the playoffs. But they lost that game because the Sixers played amazingly and Iverson carried the team on his back. It wasn't a fluke win (the next two games were arguably fluke wins, since they were very close as well. One of them Shaq made a basket right after the buzzer for halftime that was counted. Before late game fouls, the Lakers were only up by two, so that could have changed the game entirely).
AI was horribly overrated. I don't know it for a fact, but I'de be willing to bet that he is is a career under 45% shooter. Its just that he took so many shots, that's why he won all those scoring titles. He was a defensive sieve, and how many assists can you hand out if you're constantly jacking 'em up from all over the court?
Iverson took that many shots because he had Eric Snow to pass to (a point guard who could not hit a 3 point shot if his life depended on it). Still, there was a year where he led the team in assists (I believe seven per game or so). He wasn't a great defensive player because of his height (he'd usually guard point guards for that reason), but he did lead the league in steals several years.