• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

‘TREK vs. TRANSFORMERS’ Crossover Comic

Oh God.

Well, I’ve been wondering if IDW would keep making good Star Trek comics after the departure of Gaydos & Ryall. I guess I have my answer right here.
 
This is weird to me. Since I was in the audience of TAS's original run in the '70s, I think of Transformers as being from a different era of animation altogether. I mean, one was from when I was in kindergarten and first grade, the other from late high school, so naturally they feel ages apart to me.

But more than that, there actually were several massive changes in American animation between the time when TAS was made and the time when Transformers was made. One, limited animation produced domestically was almost entirely replaced by somewhat less limited but messier animation outsourced to Japan, Korea, and the Philippines, with Filmation being the last holdout. Two, kids' animation was almost completely taken over by shows created to sell toys (and in this case Filmation actually pioneered the change with He-Man). Three, first-run syndication took off and animation came to be dominated by shows that aired every weekday afternoon and had 65-episode seasons rather than just Saturday-morning shows with seasons of 13 episodes or less (another change He-Man pioneered). And four, the broadcast standards that had restricted violence in '70s kids' shows were relaxed, so that '80s shows were heavily dominated by guns, swords, and fighting. So they really were two radically different eras in American animation, and TAS and Transformers were very much products of those respective eras. So it's strange to me to see them paired off.
 
Hunh. Well, I suppose this was inevitable, given IDW's mission to cross over and pair up every thing with every other thing that's ever existed throughout human history...
 
Last edited:
When I learned about this project about three weeks ago and I saw the artwork for one of the retailer incentive covers (the Enterprise crew running forward with Optimus Prime behind them), I spent about an hour sitting in my office grinning like a little kid.

I don't know what I want out of the story -- I expect we'll see Starscream plot opportunistically against Megatron with the Klingons, because that would be a very Starscream thing to do, I hope we'll see Dinobots, and I want appearances from Unicron and Galvatron due to the Star Trek connections (Nimoy, of course, voiced Galvatron, while Orson Welles did the voiceover for the Star Trek: The Motion Picture trailer) -- and while I'm a little disappointed that the story seems to be using the classic Season 1/2 Transformers rather than reflecting where the Transformers would be in the 23rd-century (in the Marvel UK comics, we've seen as far ahead as the 24th-century in "Aspects of Evil"), that hardly matters; readers would much rather see Kirk and Optimus Prime fighting Megatron and Starscream than Kirk and Rodimus Prime fighting Galvatron and Scourge.

I think this will be fun. :)
 
On the one hand, I don't think of Transformers as a franchise that really goes together with Trek in any meaningful way, actor castings aside.

On the other hand, "Freedom is the right of all sentient beings" is definitely something Kirk or Picard would say.


Nimoy, of course, voiced Galvatron

And Frank Welker, who played Megatron and Galvatron in the TV show, did the "Spock cries" in ST III. So Nimoy and Welker share two characters in common.
 
On the one hand, I don't think of Transformers as a franchise that really goes together with Trek in any meaningful way, actor castings aside.

You're right, it doesn't. They make very different assumptions about what the universe is like and what kind of life inhabits it. (One thing I noticed with Transformers is that carbon-based life like Earth is very rare. Most life in the universe appears to be Transformers-like.) Plus, you'd need a Eugenics Wars scale retcon to explain away the Transformers' effects on Earth civilization in the 20th-century if you wanted to treat them as the same universe. Still, it doesn't matter to me whether or not the two universes fit together. I know I'm going to enjoy the heck out of this. :)
 
Hunh. Well, I suppose this was inevitable, given IDW's mission to cross over and pair up every thing with every other thing that's ever existed throughout human history...
This is going to sound like I'm joking, but I'm being 100% serious when I say that I'm hoping we get Star Trek/Ghostbusters, Star Trek/X-Files, and Star Trek/Godzilla crossovers.
 
This is going to sound like I'm joking, but I'm being 100% serious when I say that I'm hoping we get Star Trek/Ghostbusters, Star Trek/X-Files, and Star Trek/Godzilla crossovers.

All of those have possibilities! :)

Among IDW's licenses, I'd also be interested in Star Trek/Judge Dredd and Star Trek/Mars Attacks! (though I think IDW may have let the Mars Attacks! license lapse). Heck, I wouldn't even be opposed to Star Trek/My Little Pony.

(There were a couple of pitches for Mars Attacks! My Little Pony -- I even made one that was centered on Dr. Whooves, Derpy, and DJ Pon-3 when the Martians captured the Mane Six -- but I suspect Hasbro went, "Uhhh....")

If you go beyond IDW, I'd be really interested in IDW working with Dynamite for a Star Trek/John Carter, Warlord of Mars crossover. I can even think of two ways of doing it. :)
 
I think the crossovers have become really overdone by this point. They aren't special or surprising if they become a matter of routine.
 
But more than that, there actually were several massive changes in American animation between the time when TAS was made and the time when Transformers was made. One, limited animation produced domestically was almost entirely replaced by somewhat less limited but messier animation outsourced to Japan, Korea, and the Philippines, with Filmation being the last holdout. Two, kids' animation was almost completely taken over by shows created to sell toys (and in this case Filmation actually pioneered the change with He-Man). Three, first-run syndication took off and animation came to be dominated by shows that aired every weekday afternoon and had 65-episode seasons rather than just Saturday-morning shows with seasons of 13 episodes or less (another change He-Man pioneered). And four, the broadcast standards that had restricted violence in '70s kids' shows were relaxed, so that '80s shows were heavily dominated by guns, swords, and fighting. So they really were two radically different eras in American animation, and TAS and Transformers were very much products of those respective eras. So it's strange to me to see them paired off.
But they're both not very good cartoons, so they've got that in common.
When I learned about this project about three weeks ago and I saw the artwork for one of the retailer incentive covers (the Enterprise crew running forward with Optimus Prime behind them), I spent about an hour sitting in my office grinning like a little kid.
I see Windblade is on one of the covers. I wonder if she'll be in the story, retconned into the original line-up, or if that's just a promotional thing, like how these IDW crossover covers often are.

I'm a little disappointed that the story seems to be using the classic Season 1/2 Transformers rather than reflecting where the Transformers would be in the 23rd-century (in the Marvel UK comics, we've seen as far ahead as the 24th-century in "Aspects of Evil"), that hardly matters; readers would much rather see Kirk and Optimus Prime fighting Megatron and Starscream than Kirk and Rodimus Prime fighting Galvatron and Scourge.
The Beast Wars Transformers hail from the 24th century if I've done my sums right. I'd like to see Rhinox, Rattrap, et al. on Deep Space 9.
After what happened with Star Trek/Aliens, I'll only believe this is real when it comes out.
I forgot all about that. What did happen to it?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top