• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"Wink of an Eye" question

Terra Pryme

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
Even though Spock and McCoy developed a remedy to the Scalosian hyperspeed, they wait until after they leave the Enterprise before Spock gives it to Kirk to cure him, and eventually himself after he repairs the ship. So why didn't they offer the cure to the Scalosians themselves? Kirk worried they would be a threat to any other ships that would approach the planet. But if they were cured, they would have been no threat at all if they were returned to normal speed. Am I missing something? Would this have been some sort of violation of the Prime Directive? The Scalosians seemed to be a pretty advanced race even though they had no starship travel. It seemed uncharacteristic that Kirk would allow a civilization to die out like that. What are your opinions of this episode?
 
Even though Spock and McCoy developed a remedy to the Scalosian hyperspeed, they wait until after they leave the Enterprise before Spock gives it to Kirk to cure him, and eventually himself after he repairs the ship. So why didn't they offer the cure to the Scalosians themselves? Kirk worried they would be a threat to any other ships that would approach the planet. But if they were cured, they would have been no threat at all if they were returned to normal speed. Am I missing something? Would this have been some sort of violation of the Prime Directive? The Scalosians seemed to be a pretty advanced race even though they had no starship travel. It seemed uncharacteristic that Kirk would allow a civilization to die out like that. What are your opinions of this episode?

Maybe the cure only worked on Human anatomy?
 
Probably the Scalosians had been living with the condition for so long that it was incurable in them. Kirk and Spock only had a limited exposure, so it was still reversible.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top