• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The MOST Disliked Episode of VOYAGER - Season Seven...

Farscape One

Admiral
Admiral
This is a twist on a game that is played here, which I thoroughly enjoyed. I am very curious to see the results.

Here's the game. The basic idea is your standard elimination game. I'll provide a list of the episodes for each season and you need to eliminate your most favorite or the one you deem the 'best.' Please provide an EXPLANATION for why you are eliminating your choice and be sure to copy and paste the list with your choice removed. Finally, wait six hours and leave at least 2 eliminations by other posters before you eliminate another episode.

No tactical voting! You cannot remove an episode because you feel they would threaten your preferred episode's chance to win. Pretty simple. Enjoy!

Hall of Champions (or Failures?)
2011 - "THE FIGHT"
2018 - "FAVORITE SON"

Season Seven -

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
DRIVE
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
SHATTERED
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
THE VOID
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
HOMESTEAD
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
Last edited:
My first save for the last season will be "THE VOID". The kernel for this episode, I think, is season two's "ALLIANCES"... another great episode.

Here, we see the concept taken and made even better. It was really nice seeing Janeway create a mini-Federation, and the spirit of STAR TREK alive inside such a dark place.

Always a rewatch for me when it airs.


UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
DRIVE
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
SHATTERED
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
HOMESTEAD
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
I deleted Drive for redoing the pod race from The Phantom Menace.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
SHATTERED
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
HOMESTEAD
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
I am saving SHATTERED: This was a really fun episode and the return of Seska, likely the best villain of the whole series.


UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
DRIVE
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
HOMESTEAD
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
Someone posted an instant before I did so I am reposting the shortened list and without Shattered, so everything is A-OK now.:hugegrin:

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
SHATTERED
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
HOMESTEAD
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME.
 
Homestead. Looking back at it, Season 7 was on the whole pretty forgettable and really didn't take too many risks story-wise, but this one at least felt like the series was starting to come to a conclusion.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
CRITICAL CARE
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
Removing Critical Care. One of the few Voyager episodes that makes legitimately relevant social commentary, satirizing health care systems that prioritize those deemed more worthy.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
BODY AND SOUL
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
"Body And Soul." Any of the jokes about how flustered the Doctor-in-Sevens-body gets when men hit on him are distastefully juvenile and NOT aging well (why would the Doctor even be programmed with a sexuality?) Everything around that is delightful! And what an excellent job Jeri Ryan does channeling Picardo's performance. My mind really remembers this as a great Doctor episode, even though it's Ryan on screen the whole time.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
LINEAGE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
"Lineage" is a trifle melodramatic, but generally a decent piece of character exploration that tells an important part of B'Elanna's backstory. I could really feel for her, and for Tom.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
AUTHOR, AUTHOR: Is Voyager's response to TNG's "The Measure Of A Man" and it's really good. I like the Caricatures of the regulars and also the doctor's caricature by Tom Paris.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
Q2
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
“Q2”. It’s too bad that we didn’t get another Q episode after this, however John deLancie always stole the show.


UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
Eliminating Workforce, Part I. I think this is one of Voyager's better premises (Even if it requires suspension of disbelief that they would go to that kind of trouble just to brainwash people into performing middle income factory jobs), and I think the setup was better than the resolution.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
IMPERFECTION
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
I've always found "Imperfection" very moving. Really gets to some core Trek values.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
AUTHOR, AUTHOR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
"Author, Author" snuck back onto the list, despite @Discofan having removed it. Got your back, Discofan! And quit playing for attention, Doctor!

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
FLESH AND BLOOD
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
I am saving "FLESH AND BLOOD". It was a great two-parter, and I always loved the Hirogen. They were also the only villains the ship can legitimately come across year after year because of their nonadic nature, other than the Borg. Also, nice to see some of the consequences of Janeway's actions for a change.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
ENDGAME
 
My favorites for this season are gone already so I'll save the finale... it had a bigger scale feel and, yes, a few things fans didn't care for I suppose, but it also had some high points like the birth of Miral and we see they will finally get home. Plus it is the most watched Star Trek ep per that Netflix stat. ;)

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
WORKFORCE, PART II
HUMAN ERROR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
 
Workforce Part II. It's the weaker half of the two-parter, but still an enjoyable enough episode.

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
INSIDE MAN
NIGHTINGALE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
HUMAN ERROR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
 
I have to save INSIDE MAN: Episodes with Dwight Schultz are all the better for it and the comical interactions between his character and Picardo's are something to see. Plus it doesn't hurt that Marina Sirtis was there too. The weakest point is the story itself but who cares as long as we're having fun!


UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
NIGHTINGALE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
HUMAN ERROR
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
 
I'll save "Human Error" for the sake of Seven's attempts at character development, which were pretty touching; Jeri Ryan may have been brought on as cheesecake, but IMO episodes like this proved she was one of the better actors in the cast. The metaphor of the metronome was apt, and holo-Chakotay was a really good guy, thoughtful and understanding.

Screw that cowardly b.s. ending, though. "Hey, have some character development! Oh no wait, let's not!"

UNIMATRIX ZERO PART II
REPRESSION
NIGHTINGALE
REPENTANCE
PROPHECY
FRIENDSHIP ONE
NATURAL LAW
RENAISSANCE MAN
 
I'll save "Human Error" for the sake of Seven's attempts at character development, which were pretty touching; Jeri Ryan may have been brought on as cheesecake, but IMO episodes like this proved she was one of the better actors in the cast. The metaphor of the metronome was apt, and holo-Chakotay was a really good guy, thoughtful and understanding.
Agreed (and regarding the ending as well). That was my next save, so thanks... :techman:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top