• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Supergirl - Season 5

This. Absolutely this. I didn't know I want it, but I want it so bad.
Sounds like what the Xena folks did when LL broke her pelvis in season 2. Her character switched bodies with Callisto in one ep and once the actress became disabled they kept her character in Callisto's body for an extra ep.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Of course, if body switching is out, there's always the tried and true "make the actress wear a smock" like they did with Crusher in TNG or Torres in VOY. I think Roxann must have loved "The Killing Game" when she sported a "holographic" pregnancy and didn't have to hide her "condition".

https://www.vulture.com/2016/03/pregnancy-on-tv-hiding-the-baby-bump.html

I think the new Supergirl costume might work in her favor for hiding the baby bump.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Oh, I just remembered another instance of body switching in Star Trek, but this time it wasn't a switch of the characters, it was the switch of the pregnancies from Keiko into Kira.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

For nontrek fans, "Kira's" pregnancy really was Doctor Bashir's fault, or rather the actor who portrays him was the actress' signficant other at the time.
 
Hiding the baby is much harder when the actress is a superhero. It's hard to have a show called Supergirl without the title character being important. If she's not flying around doing Supergirl things, it could be a very dull season.

Plus, it's not like she will give birth and be ok instantly. It takes time to heal and get back into shape. I still think a hiatus is the best thing, though I guess that would hurt momentum. The audience is small enough.
 
Sounds like what the Xena folks did when LL broke her pelvis in season 2. Her character switched bodies with Callisto in one ep and once the actress became disabled they kept her character in Callisto's body for an extra ep.

Just an FYI, I never watched Xena.
 
Sounds like what the Xena folks did when LL broke her pelvis in season 2. Her character switched bodies with Callisto in one ep and once the actress became disabled they kept her character in Callisto's body for an extra ep.

Yes, and Hudson Leick and Lucy Lawless both did amazingly accurate impressions of each other's characters. It was one of the best examples of body-switch acting I've ever seen. So though I regret Lawless had to be injured to make it happen, I'm glad we got more than one episode of the switch.

But man, how lucky did they get that they did the body-swap episode close enough to the right time to take advantage of it that way?
 
Maybe they recast Supergirl for a short while.

Jason

Why would they do that? TV has a long history of women continuing to act on their series while pregnant and after delivery.

The strength of a series (provided there's strength there) is that the show can work around the pregnancy and not miss a beat.
 
One thing they have is that spacesuit thing Supergirl was in when the air was poisoned. Just have her in the suit during action scenes. Maybe do the Iron Man thing for some reaction shots with the actress.


Jason
 
Seriously, Lena being deeply hurt by Kara & Cie's lies/general behaviour, alright, but they pushed to far her reaction to excess of zeal, which borders on the Luthor's madness/resentment. I mean, that she feels humiliated and she decides to teach her supposed friends a lesson (the type of regardless I forgive you, my trust and confidence will be no longer blind and total), it would be understandable and maybe even shared by a majority of viewers but at one point, it is therefore necessary to know how and when to whistle the end of the game. Alas, again, Supergirl's writers showed how much they were unable to show moderation. Result: they completly ruin Lena's character they have made 4 years to build (though she is a brilliant and endearing individual, she remains someone very sensitive who tends to let herself be deceived by her emotions too, in particular in her will to do too well). Instead, since the beginning of s5, we had a Lena cold/calculating who does not hesitate to use others to get what she wants and worst, who has the spiteful grudge, even for those
who like me, like her since s2 and believe me, It hurts my little heart to write that! It is like Lex Luthor, who was fascinating in the 4B but now, in 5B, it's indigestion :shrug:

Frankly, to correct the mess writers created (and proudly supported by producers) since the beginning of s5 with their "battle for Lena's soul" (that being said, I don't really have the feeling that so far, Kara and her Superfriends really took this cause to heart and work hard to reach this goal so much they were busy to self-flogging aka Kara and/or to continue their business as if nothing had happened, turning completly their backs on one of their friends who seems upset and emotionally lost aka the other Superfriends -> Brainy would have been the 1st to understand Lena's position, especially after his little speech about the difficulty to trust again and use of boxes to lock up emotions in S4) they will need to be very imaginative to correct the badly creative Lena's storyline to make her become likeable again (I don't think their intention was to make Lena unbearable to fans but they managed to do it and I don't think either their intention is to copy Superman vs Lex's tense relationship and besides, we already know that Lena won't turn villian so...), maybe in letting J'onn finally erases her short term memory or a sudden amnesia due to a head injury or whatever, will allow to correct the situation... .. I know it is stupid scenario and why do it now when they could have done it after Crisis events. I'd answer to that,in saying they try to dismiss the ease of the loss of memory, which was an easy scebario to develop their storyline of betrayal and its consequences, but they ended up getting in a complete muddle and making the plotline last unnecessarily and going to far in Lena's loss of sense of reality. In the same time. I fear that keeping letting Lena pursue her project until she realizes that she is falling on the wrong side of the barrier and that she decides afterwards to recover in changing her stand, finishes to be awkward and worst, this total change in attitude will not erase what she has done since the 5x01 to 5x100 (even if it is clear that Kara's caution in 5x100, will serve as a wake up for Lena ... even if we will have to wait a little longer to really see a change in her). And now, 7 episodes remain to try to correct the situation. Even if for CW, ratings are satisfactory, they are nontheless declining and I won't be surprised that this decline was facilitated by Lena's messy storyline. That being said - but maybe I'm wrong - I still don't think that killing-off Lena Luthor will be solution, as an eventual sacrifice for a good cause, in 5x20, the last episode of the current season. It would be too simple ... and sad, especially after 5 sesons. But I know, some of you will say that Arrowverse producers/writers already killed popular characters in the past, often becasue they thought their stories were over.... Anyway, a quick redemption on 1 or 2 epsiodes, as seeing as they intend to pursue Lena's mental crisis as late as possible, followed by a potential death of the young Luthor would be strange and maybe too much (even if in DC comics, she dies after being seriously injured by her brother). Arrowverse series already demonstrated that they don't necessarily follow comics so, everything is possible.
 
As for s6 for which, the shooting is supposed to begin in April to end in June to accomodate Benoist maternity leave (then, the actors would resume the shooting in Nov), we already know that the renewal of the contracts of 7 regulars has been confirmed. The last being Staz Nair, last month while the production had to already know their lead actress's pregnancy so, I guess that the writers already have some ideas in head, including the continuing Kara/William's romance alas**). IF a cliffhanger must be, I guess it will be in the last episode shooted in June before Benoist's maternity leave but I bet that even afterwards, there will be less Kara/Superfirl scenes or a shorten season again, Benoist probably wanting to spend as much time as possible with their newborn, even on set.

* And IF Kara is less present in s6, maybe producers,have an interest in keeping Lena Luthor around and reintegrate her into the circle of Superfriends to help them to be more effective, in the absence of Supergirl.
** As for Kara/William, I guess that the romance will begin in a few episodes. But again, I'm pretty sure that they won't be endgame (sorry but William has not the potential to be a self-imposed and permanent companion in Kara's life, while Mon-El is - I wasn't fond of him in S2 but he has become bearable in s3 - and I really think that producers will end Supergirl with these 2 reunited, like Oliver/Felicity in Arrow's finale, though they were dead. As for the actor, Staz Nair, he has the charisma of a piece of wood - and still a piece of wood has some vertue. Just ask to a wood worker => yes, he fully reminds me Robert Beltran/Chakotay from ST: Voyager! Weak acting and flavorless character).

Possible scenarios
:
To accomodate Benoist's need of rest, writers will choose
- to make Supergirl loosing her powers for awhile and Kara, obliged to rest, will take advantage of this unepxected interlude to focus on her career as a journalist and try in the same time to give herself a real chance with Williamn following Winn's advice but of course, after awhile, the romance will fail to leave place for an unexpected return of Mon-El, maybe accompanied by Winn, in her universe, even for a short stay.
My question is: knowing that she refused to reveal her true identity to Lena to supposedly protect this latter, with the consequences that we know, will she feel compelled to tell William not to repeat the same mistake with the risk of really putting him in danger, Lex having clearly threatened to attack the English reporter if the latter pursued his investigations into him and this in front of Kara, especially if she lost temporarely her powers).
- to send Kara being lost in another universe, like she has been when she met Brainiac for the very fist time - further to fight which would have turned badly for her and get her out of there after but for awhile, she won't be the same and would need a time of adaptation in order to resume the course of her life ad Kara and Supergirl.

To end, I wonder if Benoist being a new Mom in a 4 or 5 months, won't decide to end Supergirl at the end of s6 or at best, Kara/Supergirl will make her "swan song" in a very short s7 (which will be even shorter than s6), if her contract is of 7 years instead of 6, as we thought.... .
 
Yes, and Hudson Leick and Lucy Lawless both did amazingly accurate impressions of each other's characters. It was one of the best examples of body-switch acting I've ever seen. So though I regret Lawless had to be injured to make it happen, I'm glad we got more than one episode of the switch.

But man, how lucky did they get that they did the body-swap episode close enough to the right time to take advantage of it that way?

That reminds me of one of the best flashback episodes ever of Hercules--Sorbo had a surgery or something--and the show was set in the writers room as they were trying to come up with a new story.
 
Just an FYI, I never watched Xena.

I wasn't accusing you of plagiarism, I was just pointing out "that" particular scenario has been done.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

If you haven't seen Xena, I suggest you check it out.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

It runs the gamut from high drama to extreme "camp" and everything NOT in between. ;)

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I would love it if Supergirl/Kara ever met Xena WP.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I think Kara would find it enlightening.


To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Apropos of very little, this is my favorite "Supergirl credits in the style of another show":
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Seriously, Lena being deeply hurt by Kara & Cie's lies/general behaviour, alright, but they pushed to far her reaction to excess of zeal, which borders on the Luthor's madness/resentment.

Eugenics--through trying to "improve" humans is one of history's worst beliefs/practices. She's no better than her brother.

Instead, since the beginning of s5, we had a Lena cold/calculating who does not hesitate to use others to get what she wants

What show were you watching? She's been corrupt for several seasons. She experimented on and killed Adam/Subject 0331 in the seventh episode of season 4, so she's been a villainess for years, and all that was building up to Adam's death started long before that season.

they will need to be very imaginative to correct the badly creative Lena's storyline to make her become likeable again (I don't think their intention was to make Lena unbearable to fans but they managed to do it and I don't think either their intention is to copy Superman vs Lex's tense relationship and besides, we already know that Lena won't turn villian so...)

Wrong. She's experimenting on humans. She has been and remains a villainess of the worst kind.

Even if for CW, ratings are satisfactory, they are nontheless declining and I won't be surprised that this decline was facilitated by Lena's messy storyline

The ratings have been dropping for years. .
 
Apropos of very little, this is my favorite "Supergirl credits in the style of another show":
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I'll see your charmed response and raise you a prequel. :hugegrin:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I'll see your charmed response and raise you a prequel. :hugegrin:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
OMG, that is amazing. :luvlove: I cannot express my love for "Midvale"; it's one of my favorite episodes of the entire series. As I've noted before, I sometimes consciously call Vidovic and Nikkanen's performances to mind when watching Benoist and Leigh's scenes together. I find it actually enhances my sense of them as characters with a shared history and a profound bond.
Ooh, that could work -- have Kara get magically de-aged and have Izabela Vidovic take over the role for a while.
And Christopher drops the fucking mic. Best. Solution. Imaginable. :beer:
 
They have nearly finished the season. I doubt it will play much of a factor her pregnancy in the show.
 
I doubt it will play much of a factor her pregnancy in the show.
hC3AE2E25.jpeg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top