• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 1x04 - "Memento Mori"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    219
Well they've got to think of something that can top this:

giphy.gif


They can't let Discovery outdo them on the spectacle! Maybe turbolift buggies...
 
Very obsolete. The limited functioning of the computers, the very slow processing speed, and the limited storage of data all spring immediately to mind. Just watch Spock fake orders and audio to the Enterprise in the "Menagerie." Then look at Deep Fake audio tech today.

Now, excuse me, I need to go back up my laptop to a floppy disk.

In the episode where Kirk was accused of letting his buddy die it was shown that the video was altered. No deep fake at all. It was totally altered where it was impossible to distinguish from the real video.
 
Ok what looks dated? We are nowhere near as advanced as TOS even today
We already have better mobile devices and computers than they had in TOS, for starters.

Just one example: Watch "Court Martial" and tell me the computer's voice listing Kirk's carreer achievements doesn't sound extremely dated.
 
My view is on SNW's design is still that as long as the show stops before TOS starts, there's always room for another refit. Or not. That way fans can imagine any kind of TOS they want! Maybe the Original Series adventures look just like those old VHS tapes, or maybe they look like SNW's reimagining, it's up to you! Everyone's happy... except for the people who really want that Kirk series.

I mean the Enterprise doesn't even look like it did in Discovery. The corridors and crew quarters are radically different. They could easily be changed again.
I take the more pragmatic view: that they changed stuff in the real world and we're not supposed to agonise about whether the continuity fits precisely all the time.
 
We already have better mobile devices and computers than they had in TOS, for starters.

Just one example: Watch "Court Martial" and tell me the computer's voice listing Kirk's carreer achievements doesn't sound extremely dated.


It actually sounded cool. Also the had a had pad on the chair that could tell if a person was lying. How are our computers better? In TOS they had spocks reader that gave him a huge amount of information on what was in space. They could ask ask computers any question. They also had tech that could repair a person instantly if they were mentally ill. Mobile devices that cannot scan for lifeforms or chemicals, or ships, or scan for medical issues and instantaneously tell a doctor what is wrong with us.
 
Last edited:
Well they've got to think of something that can top this:
giphy.gif


They can't let Discovery outdo them on the spectacle! Maybe turbolift buggies...

Well, Discovery as of Season Three has an excuse: it’s the 32nd century, there may actually be some TARDIS-like space warping going on there, since there’ve been time pods from an earlier period that definitely had it. The 23rd century had no such excuse.
 
Well, Discovery as of Season Three has an excuse: it’s the 32nd century, there may actually be some TARDIS-like space warping going on there, since there’ve been time pods from an earlier period that definitely had it. The 23rd century had no such excuse.


Wasn't that in season 2 before they got to the 32nd century or their ship reconfigured?
 
Very obsolete. The limited functioning of the computers, the very slow processing speed, and the limited storage of data all spring immediately to mind. Just watch Spock fake orders and audio to the Enterprise in the "Menagerie." Then look at Deep Fake audio tech today.

Now, excuse me, I need to go back up my laptop dumb terminal data to a 8" floppy disk.
FTFY ;)
 
It actually sounded cool.
Are you joking? You think the mechanistic, stilted, shrill computer voice sounded cool, when our computers today have speech almost indistinguishable from real people's?

Also the had pad could tell if a person was lying. How are our computers better?
Please don't play obtuse. That they have better tech in one field doesn't change the fact that they have worse ones in others, and you're talking about having better sensors and a better understanding of lie detection, which has nothing to do with computer technology -- you know this.

Mobile devices that cannot scan for lifeforms or chemicals, or ships, or scan for medical issues and instantaneously tell a doctor what is wrong with us.
You're talking about having better sensors and a better understanding of science, which has nothing to do with mobile devices -- you know this.
 
They also had tech that could repair a person instantly if they were mentally ill
Terribly sometimes. I don't see that as a perk when it erased the personality in "Dagger of the Mind."
I take the more pragmatic view: that they changed stuff in the real world and we're not supposed to agonise about whether the continuity fits precisely all the time.
Exactly. I treat it as a dramatic presentation of events in that time, not literal historic recreation of that time. Just like Rameses probably didn't look like Yul Brunner, much to my disappointment.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top