Okay, so I watched "That's What Ships Are For" this past weekend and found myself very impressed even if I had a few quibbles. So, I've decided to watch this entire series.
I watched the first episode earlier (the one with Apollo) and found it to be decent but sort of weak for a "premiere" episode (even if we're to take this series as a "Season 4" and not a fresh start it's a weak season opener, but maybe not in a 1960's sense. Either way to get people pulled into a fan production, for me, it was weak but still decent.), this one I just got done watching about 20 minutes ago and was very impressed. I didn't recognize Ferrigno at first and was having trouble understanding this guy who sounded like he had a swollen tongue, but when Ferrigno finally clicked in my head it all made sense and even got into the notion of this being an alien speaking English/Basic or whatever. It began to work.
Maybe I'm too much of a fan of TNG but the counselor woman doesn't bother me even if she messes up the 3-way dynamic of Kirk, Spock and McCoy, I think it's interesting to have someone there willing to challenge Kirk a bit and keep him on his toes. She works for me, but can understand why she wouldn't be overly well received/welcomed as an addition.
The actors on this show really do a great job and the production values of it are really good. I am damn impressed, the lighting, look and overall feel of this show just feels very much like TOS. They've done a remarkable job.