Sovereign Class Starship Vs Imperial 1 Class Star Destroyer

[Rayleo02]

Contests
Power Output +2
Speed/Maneuverability +2
Crew Complement +1
Weapon Power +2
Crew Competence +2
Shielding +2
Armor +1
Crew Comforts +1
Sidearms +1
Troops +1
Computing Power+2
Targeting Systems +2
Crew Morale+1
NO Favoritism
Must Be Impartial
Facts only
Out of 20
Canon Only

 

[Tenacity]

If it's a Star Trek production (movie/TV) then the Sovereign class wins.

If it's a Star Wars production (movie/cartoon) then the Star Destroyer wins.

 

[jaime]

I am sure it’s been said a thousand times, but warp drive is more useful than hyperspace, canonically to both, and a transported photon torpedo ends things quick. And Star Wars ships have rubbish shields and no hull breach shielding. The sov wouldn’t even break a sweat.

 

[Tenacity]

Right off, Starfleet would join forces with the rebel alliance,

 

[Leviathan]

Right off, Starfleet would join forces with the rebel alliance,

Doubtful.... Starfleet Admirals *are* mostly evil.