• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Several FanFic Questions

Counterpoint: There is nothing in the realm of the science of this or last century that says an amoeba can be the size of a solar system (TOS:"The Immunity Syndrome"), A spaceship can have a baby (TNG: "A Fistful of Datas"), explosive devices can reproduce like cells (DS9's "self-replicating mines"), or two human beings can travel so fast they mutate into horny pink monitor lizards (VOY: "Threshold.") All that nonsense is canon, and if professional writers got paid to write it, there's no way we should hold a fanfic writer to that standard. It's a matter of taste. Grounded sci-fi may be to your taste, and most of the time it's to my taste, but we always have to keep two things in mind: One, none of these stories work without some level of bullshit inserted into them, and Two, there's an audience for everything.

So, Bynar, what I'd say to you is that there's no way to know for sure how readers will react to what you make up until you actually make it up and present it to them. I can tell you that acceptance of made-up stuff is inversely proportional to the quality of the overall story. The more compelling your narrative, the less anyone will notice anything silly that it contains.

And now I'll say what I always say: Just write the story.
Late joiner to this but I remember asking my chemistry teacher in high school all kinds of scientific questions, much to the chagrin and horror of my classmates. He had a piece of advice that has stuck with me for 20+ years now; whatever you write be consistent. Those who know won't mind if you craft a coherent story with engaging characters that draw them in to the world. Those who mind those details are going to mind no matter what. The rest are just jumping in for the ride.

My other piece of advice comes from another author (can't remember the name; no doubt someone will): the secret to writing is to write. Write often, write a lot, and write about different topics.
 
Has anyone ever tweaked a major canon character history to make it work with your fanatic?
 
Last edited:
Has anyone ever tweaked a major canon character history to make it work with your fanatic?
Personally, I'm staying far, far away from canon characters. The exception being in my story TIMELINES (link below), most of the characters are canon. While I didn't specifically call them out by name, it should be obvious who that are.
 
I like Bible and poetry quotes, myself. Puns and idioms (Trekified) work, too.

My two TOS episode fics, "The Best Robe" and "Image Of The Invisible", get their titles from Bible quotes. The former is a retelling of the parable of the prodigal son (therefore a reference to the robe the father wished to dress his returning son in), while the latter is about
the previously invisible characters and world of a writer's mind coming to life.

When using Bible quotes, use the King James version. It sounds more sci-fi-y.
 
Several episodes of STH started with the episode title - and then I figured out what it would be about and started writing it.

In some cases, I had only the episode title for several months with no clue what the episode would be about.

Thanks!! rbs
 
Easiest answer: write the story and use a line of dialogue or narrative for the title. That's how Tom Clancy named most of his books. (Example: in his final showdown with Ramius, Captain Tupolev is said to be "fully caught up in the hunt for Red October.)

What I personally like to do is emulate the way episodes of TOS are titled. Most (but not all) of the episodes seem only marginally related - or completely unrelated - to the story until you've seen the episode and can think about it. Example: "Tomorrow is Yesterday" - one day Enterprise is on routine patrol, the next she's hurled back in time, so... "What Are Little Girls Made Of?" - the story is about the nature and potential of self-aware robots, so the question the title's asking is really about all sentient life, not just little girls. "The Naked Time" - not about bodies but the crew's innermost desires and torments bared "naked" by an alien infection. I find that method strangely compelling, one that canon creators pretty much gave up on by season two of TNG, so I try to incorporate it in my own writing to varying degrees of success. Mind you, if you decide to go that route it would be best if you at least have an idea how your story is going to go, and even better if you write it first.
 
Last edited:
I somehow settled on using Foo Fighters song titles (not necessarily the content of the lyrics) that are thematically linked to the story I'm telling in each episode of my fic.
 
I chose one of the many maps available from Memory Beta and stuck with it. There are lots and lots of Trek star-maps, many of which don't agree with one another and a stunning number of which are strictly 2 dimensional. Considering that the galactic disc, where we are located, is, on average, 1,000 lightyears deep, 2 dimensional thinking is a serious oversight.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top