• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Klingons: Different appearances, artificial cranial deformation/head binding

INACTIVERedDwarf

Commander
Red Shirt
For those who like to reconcile the different appearances of the Klingons in Star Trek, there are a few problems, and potential explanations. One explanation was that there were different species that made up the Klingon Empire; this was used in old novels prior to DS9's "Trials and Tribble-ations". An alternative explanation was that Klingons cross married with other subject species across generations. Another was that the Klingons had undergone change due to genetic engineering, or a state eugenics program, or a genetic disease, and this was the solution made official canon in ENT's "Divergence".

7xMPpij.png


The current idea is that this retroviral vector was not 100% endemic to all Klingons, and the latest novels posit that these Klingons are exiled to patrolling borders, explaining why they came into frequent contact with Kirk. But one problem remains; they don't appear side by side, which is statistically unlikely. Some of the changes between "ridged" Klingons however, could be due to two remaining factors 1). Klingons being cross related with subject peoples (as is common in human history's empires), and 2). Klingon physical body modification (hair depilation, skull binding, etc).

klingons.jpg

  • 1). (1966-1969) Star Trek: The Original Series
  • 2). (1979) Star Trek I
  • 3). (1984-1991) Star Trek III, IV, V and VI
  • 4). (1987-2005) Star Trek: The Next Generation, Star Trek Deep: Space Nine, Star Trek: Voyager and Star Trek Enterprise
  • 5). (2011) Star Trek Into Darkness
  • 6). (2017-Present) Star Trek: Discovery
There is little difference between 3 and 4 (head appliances seem smoother in the films). There are strong links between 5 and 6 (such as holes distal to the nostrils, on the cheek), but the 6th type of Klingons sometimes have very elongated skulls.

QFVfuI0.jpg


The hair accounts for a lot of the differences between Klingons, as in Star Trek I: The Motion Picture, they were given a Samurai's bald hairstyle, and in later Star Treks, they were given almost Elizabethan hairstyles inspired by Shakespeare, followed by long flowing hair similar to many ancient cultures. It is possible that the more pronounced features of Klingons 5 and 6 represent a more relict population with aboriginal features, where the most frequently seen Klingons of TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT were more cosmopolitan in their heritage. Finally, several ancient peoples of Earth performed head binding to shape skulls into a more conical shape, sometimes to differentiate social rank; the Huns, ancient South American cultures, etc. So it is possible that the Klingons seen in DSC practice this, or that it is a social trend at this time.
 
Since the changing appearance of Klingons is a Trek constant, I embrace any rationalization that makes it explicit, commonplace and inherent to the Klingon way of life.

Voluntary body modification makes eminent sense. After all, this is what "Affliction"/"Divergence" was all about: Klingons volunteering to alter their bodies, with nary a line about this somehow insulting the spirit of Kahless or diluting the essence of Klin.

That we nevertheless only see one or two body types at any given time, rather than a broad spectrum, could boil down to a single word. If looks matter, then naturally Klingons would be doing Fashion. And being out of Fashion would be one of 'em deadly sins, requiring the offender to remain off camera.

Since we furthermore see specific Klingon individuals change their appearance by various means, there's an obvious alternative to simply staying off camera or being "banished". Any Klingon of means could undergo a procedure to restore his adherence to Fashion as required. And any Klingon spotted in DSC would be one of means, surely, as we mostly see their top brass and the crews of ships belonging to said.

There is plenty of opportunity and time for the Fashion to change between DSC and TOS again, given how it so swiftly changed between TOS and TMP. Perhaps the rise to prominence of L'Rell also brings to prominence her lover whose features are those of a TOS Klingon?

Timo Saloniemi
 
I consider 2, 3, and 4 of your list to be the same type of Klingon, with variations that are normal within any species. I'll call them TNG Klingons, just to make it easy.

I think TNG Klingons look exactly half-way between TOS Klingons and DSC Klingons. I think the Augment Virus from ENT is silly but we'll go with it. What if the Klingons, in trying to counter-act the virus went too far and they ended up with DSC Klingons?

DSC Klingons physically have everything the TOS Klingons don't have and vice versa. Only the TNG Klingons have both, save for four nostrils (what the Hell is that?)
 
But what about Kang, Koloth and Kor? They looked human in TOS, then more movie-era/TNG style for their appearance in DS9.
 
They were affected or their ancestors were, then in 2270-something, they had their infection undone.

There we are. ;)
 
Nice thread - the Huns and other tribal empires used to mix without much hesitation with other ethnic/national groups, since modern 19th century style racism didn't exist in classical antiquity, so I think maybe the ENT/TNG Klingons are intermixed with other humanoid species seeded by the First Humanoids. It still does not quite explain how the DSC Klingons all suddenly look different, unless, as others say, this was a reaction against the augment virus. I would like to see a few other types of Klingon alongside the current ones, or just some hair on the current ones.

g4EMbr2.jpg


In fact, there is a way to resurrect one of my old favorite pieces of lore - see the screenshot above. There was once an idea in beta canon sources that the Klingons had engaged in eugenics. Maybe the stronger facial features of Klingons in the era of DSC points to a widespread eugenics program, thus making the Klingon state a bit more dangerous again, rather than the ignorant victim of the silly augment virus.

But what about Kang, Koloth and Kor? They looked human in TOS, then more movie-era/TNG style for their appearance in DS9.

Most people guess they had surgery or otherwise were genetically cured.
 
The appearance of Klingons was already a mess. Discovery just made it an even bigger clusterfuck. Enterprise tried to fix the mess that existed since TMP and somewhat succeeded with mixed results. It was an explanation for those that needed one. Not perfect by any means but an explanation as good as any was ever going to be.

Then along comes Discovery to throw another wrench into an already convoluted and ridiculous mess. There was no need to reinvent Klingons again. It was change for the sake of change. The TNG era ones still look fine. In all honesty there was no need to go over old ground with the Klingons once again whether they looked like TOS or TNG era. Been there, done that. And frankly the iteration of Klingons in Discovery were boring as hell. They certainly didn't justify the reinvention.

And now, for those who care, the Klingons start off looking like TNG era on Enterprise, get afflicted with a virus that makes them look like TOS era, end up looking like Mutant Coneheads on Discovery, back to TOS era look and finally TNG era Klingons.

A clusterfuck.

And unnecessary. We survived for almost 40 years without a good explanation for the discrepancies between TOS and TNG Klingons. We could reconcile them in our minds or accept the Augment explanation. Either was fine with me. Why the hell did we need another iteration to add to the confusion?

Of course it could all be reconciled in one episode if all iterations of the Klingons were featured side by side...
 
Since the changing appearance of Klingons is a Trek constant, I embrace any rationalization that makes it explicit, commonplace and inherent to the Klingon way of life.

Voluntary body modification makes eminent sense. After all, this is what "Affliction"/"Divergence" was all about: Klingons volunteering to alter their bodies, with nary a line about this somehow insulting the spirit of Kahless or diluting the essence of Klin.

I like your idea; the Klingons being into extreme body modification would not surprise me at all - they are already compared to vikings and biker gangs - they already have a violent culture like the Huns - they consider their dead disposable shells - maybe they just don't give a shit about appearance.

EiSReB0.png


Of course it could all be reconciled in one episode if all iterations of the Klingons were featured side by side...

Yep, that is something I think a lot of people would like to see, in a non-fanwanky way. Maybe we should take this opportunity to also again raise the issue of how different Klingon ships are in DSC from virtually every other era - maybe the ones were see are privately owned by great noble houses, and all the D7s belong to the standing military?

xJnHgEZ.jpg


rEILBgN.jpg
 
Last edited:
Kelvinverse Klingons are not the same sort of radical departure from the movies/Berman era as Discovery. The "feature Klingon" was bald and clean-shaven, but we see also Klingons who keep their helmets on with long hair, along with bearded ones.

bRjVbG3.jpg


Really, the only major difference is the redesign of the ridges, and that could be thought to be just a different "race" of Klingons.
 
Genetic engineering is my personal favorite, as well as inbreeding among the Great Houses to preserve bloodlines.
 
Imaybe the ones were see are privately owned by great noble houses, and all the D7s belong to the standing military?

IIRC, even the regular vessels of the Klingon Defense Force are owned (and presumably crewed) by specific Klingon houses.

It's from that one DS9 ep when Kurn was talking about his discommendation, he said that the House of Mogh was dissolved, all their land taken, and all their ships seized.

What if the Klingons, in trying to counter-act the virus went too far and they ended up with DSC Klingons?

I'm OK with that. :)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top