• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll How silly is Star Trek?

How silly is Star Trek, out of 5?


  • Total voters
    79

F. King Daniel

Fleet Admiral
Admiral
I love Trek and always have. That being said fans take it very seriously and get bent out of shape over magic supernovae, travel times between planets, how big the classic Enterprise is or whether the future is really utopian enough when...

90% of aliens are humans with bumpy heads which make zero evolutionary sense. And they can all interbreed with humans, even when they have green blood or similar. Alien women can even knock up human men after something that was so weird it wasn't recognisable as sex until it was too late.

The Enterprise is a really silly and impractical shape. And if there is some practicality to it in-universe, why do most aliens prefer to shape their vessels like birds instead?

Space is presented in a completely ficticious way where there is sound, FTL spaceships swoosh past each other at distances of mere meters and things explode as if in an oxygen-rich atmosphere. Up is universal and time is constant throughout the galaxy unless you're from the "Blink of an Eye" planet.

While I enjoy the debates on this site, sometimes I think we need to remember what it is we're arguing about. How silly is Star Trek?
 
ops...
sealy.jpg
 
Unfortunately there are no wizards in Star Trek to wave away plot holes, a la Xena.

However we do have this qizard

1yxvma.jpg


With this airtight deus ex machina in place, not silly at all.
At ALL.
 
4 and that's alright. You can still tell good and emotionally resonating stories even with a silly premise/world.

And every trek show has its serious and silly elements, characters and episodes.

My thoughts (and vote) exactly.

Also, speaking as someone who names the "weird" episodes of TNG as his favorites... I'm SO here for the silly stuff. (But I do have my limits. lol)
 
Silly compared to reality and what the actual future will probably look like. But still much more well thought out than most scifi. So, 3?
 
A bit silly - yes - but, it IS fiction after all.

Classic Trek tried to be serious when it made sense to do so. They did (deliberately) go off the rails from time to time - and that's fine with me!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top