• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Duncan Jones' "Rogue Trooper" Movie

Rogue doesn't meet a whole lot of women to be fair. There are three main women he comes across, two are GIs themselves (Venus Bluegenes and Azure) and while you could say both are somewhat belligerent at times it's more complex than they merely betray Rogue and both tend to be considered allies much of the time.

the third is Sister Sledge, a Souther nurse who tags along with Rogue and who is
actually a Nort 'Filth columist" who tries to kill Rogue.

The comic as originally conceived in the 80s has an old fashioned attitude towards women (female GIs are called Dolls and are mainly slated for administrative. nursing or R&R duties) but that has evolved over time and I sincerely doubt any of that is going to permeate the film. If for no other reason than none of it is integral to understanding the character. I do wonder if Atwell will play Venus. There have been plenty of women in the Rogue universe the last few years, including Atalia Jaegir whose spin off series is perhaps the best thing outside of the core Rogue Trooper concept.

It's no more violent than any other war comic TBH, much of the nastiness tends to come from people being killed by poison clouds rather than Rogue, and he is very much aware of his nature. The whole point of the series is that while he was created as an obedient soldier he went 'rogue' after the Quartz Massacre to avenge the deaths of his comrades. He's hunted by both sides. To the Norts he's an enemy, to the Southers a deserter.

I'm not sure that's an accurate understanding of Dredd. He's softened over the years but even now he believes in the law above all else and hasn't remotely become any kind of left wing hippy! He's hard but fair...but mostly hard.
 
I haven't read the comic, but I've heard that Rogue Trooper gets betrayed by every woman he encounters. That's going to appeal to a certain demographic, I expect. If that theme is continued into this adaptation, it's going to attract a lot of criticism. I've read about the basic premise of the character and I doubt it's for me because of the violence. Judge Dredd eventually comes to realise that he's a product and tool of his society. I don't know if Rogue Trooper has a similar character arc, but is this just a thematic repetition when one boils it down to its essence?
I read a handful of stories and I don't even remember female characters who had some meaningful relationship with him. I don't believe it happens so often. And times change.
 
I'm not sure that's an accurate understanding of Dredd. He's softened over the years but even now he believes in the law above all else and hasn't remotely become any kind of left wing hippy! He's hard but fair...but mostly hard.
He isn't a mere automaton, but Dredd ultimately doesn't kick against the system. It's so much bigger than him that such action would be useless. He's basically locked into his role like Sisyphus?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top