• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 5x12 - "Violations"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
Violations.jpg


The Enterprise is serving as host to three members of a telepathic race, the Ullians, in need of travel between star-systems. The aliens' telepathic abilities allow them to help a subject to recall half-remembered or forgotten memories and recall them vividly.

Keiko O'Brien allows herself to be a subject of one of their probes to better recall a faint memory from her childhood as she aided her grandmother in ink paintings.

The one performing the memory probe, an older male member named Tarmin, is eager to perform his abilities on someone else but everyone declines to be probed, he tries again during a formal dinner with the bridge crew causing his son, Jev, to leave the dinner in frustration over his father's eagerness to use his telepathic abilities on others. Troi follows and has a pleasant conversation with Jev in the turbolift enroute to her quarters. Once there and readying herself for bed Troi begins to experience a memory, presumably from her own past, where after a poker-game her and Riker had a near-romantic encounter. Soon in the memory Riker is replaced by Jev who forces himself on Troi, in the real world Troi lapses into a coma.

An investigation is begun as no explanation can be found for Troi's lapse into a coma as she has no physical condition that would have caused one, investigations by Geordi reveal no agent or technological component on the ship that'd cause her coma and Crusher's own medical tests and and analysis reveal nothing but a slight resemblance to known condition but the diagnoses don't line-up 100%.

The only "unknown" in everything are the Ullians, though they aren't carrying anything missed by the transporter's biofilter and Keiko -the only one to undergo a memory probe- is fine. As Riker pursues the issue with the Ullians he falls into a coma while recalling a memory of an impending disaster on the ship, and Crusher too falls into a coma while recalling a memory of her identifying her late husband's body in a Starfleet morgue.

Picard is forced to confine the Ullians to quarters, prompting tensions between him and the Ulllian leader, soon after Troi regains consciousness but cannot remember what happened much past after entering her quarters.

With her consent, Jev offers to help Troi recall that evening where Troi remembers remembering the time after a poker game only this time it's Tarmin who forces himself on Troi, prompting Picard to begin to take the necessary action against him.

During much of this Geordi and Data have continued investigating what's happening and are focusing on cases of unexplained comas on planets the aliens have recently visited.

Before they're set to leave the ship, Jev visits Troi in her quarters one last time to say goodbye and apologize for his father. But Troi's kindness and beauty overwhelms Jev and he begins trying to telepathically force himself on her again. Troi realizes what's going on and takes aggressive action just as Worf arrives with a security detail to apprehend Jev.

During their investigation, Geordi and Data reveal one member of the Ullians was present for all of the instances of unexplained Coma, Jev. Jev had "framed" his father for the crimes he committed -telepathic rape- on the ship.

Tarmin and the Ullian homeword offer their assistance in helping Riker, Troi and Crusher recover from their comas and to heal from the violations the Ullians thought they had grown past as a species. Picard laments that humans, too, have grown past their more aggressive natures from hundreds of years ago but sometimes there are still those seeds that lie in everyone that cannot be weeded out, no matter how much a species might evolve.

Not too terrible an episode, really, the flashback/rape scenes are nicely done with a sort of soft-focus and an almost "fish eye lens" type look to it (Not sure how to describe that type of filming technique) to give it a real eerie feel.

The story isn't too bad but feels padded in a couple of places, most notably a treknobabble scene between Geordi and the computer trying to determine if there's anything on the ship causing the problems. And the aliens are given a bit more than the "bumpy forehead/odd nose" look common to the AOTW and actually have an interesting look.\

There's a really nice, sweet, scene as Riker talks with a comatose Troi in sickbay.

The episode's subject matter is harder to dive into without probably bringing up uncomfortable discussions but it should be clear that calling what Jev was doing to the crew as "rape" isn't being hyperbolic even if there was no real physical violation taking place.

The episode also seems to want to touch a bit on the "evolved humans" idea that's so common in TNG by sort of backing up on it a bit and saying that humans aren't perfect and that sometimes human nature still comes out and bad things happen. No matter how advanced a society is, there's always someone to make you realize how far a society still may have to go.

Pushing up my glasses (obviously held together by tape on the bridge) I'll point out a nice scene with the turbolift where we see Troi and Jev enter it on deck 3 (where the formal dining room would likely be in the bridge island) as they approach the doors to the lift. When the car arrives at it's destination the doors close again on the camera as the scene ends and the doors correctly say, "deck 8", the deck Troi asked for and correctly where her quarters are.

On another hand, this episode must have been filmed not too long after, or the same time as, scenes from Star Trek VI were filmed, or the stage crew for either the movie, the show, or both hadn't gotten around to redressing the sets for TNG.

We see the replicator alcove in Troi's quarters and in Riker's quarters when falls into his coma (and in the flashback to his quarters) and the replicator alcove's control panel has the 23rd century style Okudagram/LCARS display rather than the 24th century one.

Oops.

Along with all of that, maybe we can also discuss in this thread fond memories we have or half-remembered ones we'd like to get more of with the help of the Ullians.
 
I've always liked this one, and loved when Worf knocks out Jev at the end.
 
Hell, I love how much Troi manages to hold her own against Jev! She actually gives him a decent wallop; no clay pots this time around for her!
 
I like this one as well. Good call on the replicator alcoves - I had not noticed that.

It's obvious that there's something creepy about Jev from the start, and I like the pacing of this one. LaForge and Data slowly and steadily putting it together works for me. And yeah, this is another one that shows how far Troi had come from the early days of the show.
 
Last edited:
A few months after the episode, I saw Eve Brenner, who played the Ullian woman, in a play in LA. Didn't talk to her after the show though, probably should have, but likely would have sounded like just another Star Trek fan. Some actors probably eat that stuff up though, especially if they're not big stars. One of the other actors in the play was in an episode of the George Reeves Superman series I had.
 
Hell, I love how much Troi manages to hold her own against Jev! She actually gives him a decent wallop; no clay pots this time around for her!

I agree. Troi was often depicted as one of the most girly girls of Trek, so it was great here to see her give Jev a wallop. One of my favourite TNG eps.
 
This episode was creepy and I remember my Parents wouldn't let me watch it when it came out. I think the first time I saw this episode was when the DVDs came out.
 
This episode was creepy and I remember my Parents wouldn't let me watch it when it came out. I think the first time I saw this episode was when the DVDs came out.

I dunno, depending on the age you were I suspect there may have been other reasons your parents didn't let you watch this as a child, given some of the outfits Troi wears in this episode.

:drool:
 
This episode was creepy and I remember my Parents wouldn't let me watch it when it came out. I think the first time I saw this episode was when the DVDs came out.

I dunno, depending on the age you were I suspect there may have been other reasons your parents didn't let you watch this as a child, given some of the outfits Troi wears in this episode.

:drool:

This came out in 91, so I was 6 at the time.
 
This episode was creepy and I remember my Parents wouldn't let me watch it when it came out. I think the first time I saw this episode was when the DVDs came out.

I dunno, depending on the age you were I suspect there may have been other reasons your parents didn't let you watch this as a child, given some of the outfits Troi wears in this episode.

:drool:

I can only think of her peach nightdress and that didn't seem too revealing. What else s there? :confused:
 
This episode was creepy and I remember my Parents wouldn't let me watch it when it came out. I think the first time I saw this episode was when the DVDs came out.

I dunno, depending on the age you were I suspect there may have been other reasons your parents didn't let you watch this as a child, given some of the outfits Troi wears in this episode.

:drool:

I can only think of her peach nightdress and that didn't seem too revealing. What else s there? :confused:

The peach night-dress had a very low cut back and, ahem, her "girls" were pretty free and wild and it was apparently cold on the set.

Then there's the sheer dress she wore into Ten-Forward and just the overall hyper-sexualized demeanor she had after "bonding" with what's-his-name and seduced the ensign in the turbolift. Which led to a pretty funny reaction from Riker later on when he runs into him in her quarters.

ETA: Crap, I'm thinking of "Man of the People" from season 6, which I'm ALSO watching on Blu-Ray and got my episodes mixed up.
 
I really enjoyed this one on the rewatch. It breaks up a run of what can only be described as dull & boring season five episodes.
 
ETA: Crap, I'm thinking of "Man of the People" from season 6, which I'm ALSO watching on Blu-Ray and got my episodes mixed up.

I wondered if you were getting your nightgowns confused. I can see how that could certainly happen. Thanks for all the episode write-ups, by the way. I enjoy reading them. :)
 
I never quite got if the mind-rape scenes were based on actual memories, or something that was perhaps a daydream or a nightmare, or a complete fabrication from Jev.

If so, then did Riker rape Deanna? That seems really strange. When did the 'memory' end and Jev's rape take over?

The ones for Riker and Crusher seem like memories that might have haunted them - the responsibility of letting a crewman die, and Crusher visiting her husband's dead body.

It's been said that Picard wearing a toupee was less about showing Picard as a younger man, but to look more like Jev, along with that weird thing on the side of his head. So maybe not a memory at all.
 
I always thought the mind rape scenes were implanted by Jev, which would constitute as rape. If they were actual memories, that puts on a darker light for these characters.
 
I always thought the mind rape scenes were implanted by Jev, which would constitute as rape. If they were actual memories, that puts on a darker light for these characters.

Combine the mind rape scene from this episode with the testimony given about Riker's behavior in "A Matter of Perspective" and one might have to re-evaluate the behavior of our Imzadi. This seems especially true when you consider how quickly Ricker was able to incapacitate Data in "The Measure of a Man". If it were not for the fact the hearing was in session at the time, after Ricker had flicked Data's snooze button, he may have awoken to the sensation of Riker's dipstick verifying our Chief of Operation's full functionality.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top