• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch 4x18: "Identity Crisis."

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
IdentCrisis.jpg


A colleague, Lt. Cmdr. Leijten, from his previous assignment is on board to hunt down two other fellow crew-members from the ship who suddenly hijacked shuttles from their current assignments and fled to the same planet, a planet LaForge and the other crew-members were all on an away mission on some five years earlier.

A third missing person dies during re-entry of the shuttle as the Enterprise approaches the planet where an away team investigates the landing site of a shuttle, the same place where the away mission was years earlier. There are no signs of the missing Starfleet officers other than shredded and discarded uniforms.

Upon return to the ship Leijten grows increasingly agitated as the investigation goes on ship-side and continues to show desires to return to he planet which go unfulfilled. Soon she begins showing physical changes to her body, sensitivity to light, among other changes causing a medical investigation to unfold by Crusher in sickbay.

Geordi continues to go over the records, including a video recording, of the original away mission leading him to a recreation on the holodeck (That's our LaForge!) where an unidentified shadow is seen in the recording, it cannot be linked to anything in the recording device's field of view.

LaForge too then begins to show signs of changes, similar to what Leijten underwent and presumably the others.

After doing a very intense microbial analysis of Leijten Crusher discovers her DNA is being re-written by a previously unseen parasite. She's able to remove the parasite and use Leijten's remaining original DNA to restore her to normal. Suspecting LaForge will need to be treated as well she requests him to sickbay but it's then discovered he has managed to escape the ship to the planet. They're now on a time crunch to find LaForge before his genetic code is too far gone to be recovered, the search is further harmed that the creature is turning into is invisible to light and the ship's sensors. Data, however, is able to rig-up a light the emits UV rays, making the creatures visible.

The away team, including Leijten, finds LaForge on the planet and Leijten is able to convince alien-Geordi to come back to the ship where Crusher is able to restore him to normal. It's determined that this process is how this alien species reproduces, rather than being a parasite or other malevolent organism. The original missing officers are too far gone, genetically, to be treated.

This is an episode I can go either way on. It's got some good and interesting moments but it's also got some cheesier and harder to really take moments. One in particular is near the end as LaForge's former colleague tries to convince him to go with her back to the ship.

The episode is also a different take on the "planet side dangers" of space-travel and showing us how it can create a story but this episode never makes it clear on how the original away team (and further the occupants of the outpost there in the original investigation) became infected with this reproductive process. Are all of the away team members in this episode going to need to be treated as well?

It's also a question on how such an organism developed in the first place since its entire way of reproduction seems to be dependent on alien visitors to be "infected." It's a question of whether or not interstellar space-travel his existed in the galaxy long enough for such an organism to evolve.

One thing I really like about this episode is that it shows us something that, really, we should have been seeing all of the time. The original investigation had an officer wearing a recording device (we'll call it LCARS Glass) to document the investigation. Geordi is able to use this recording during his investigation of what happened and it's apparent the data from the device is able to record things beyond simple audio and video as Geordi is able to get information from the recording including subspace data. So... Why isn't someone wearing these devices on EVERY away mission? Hell, why does it even need to be a device you wear on your head? Couldn't a tricorder record everything around it (even if it can't visually see it) while being active but still holstered?

Obviously there's plenty of "TV reasons" why this is the case but it seems that in "reality" the LCARS Glass device would be used on every away mission to document things on a new planet.

At the same time the device causes a bit of a mistake in the events of the episode. Geordi begins to suspect there was someone else there in the area of the away mission when he discovers and unidentified shadow on a wall, it doesn't match up to any person or object in the camera's point of view. He's able to conclude that it's the shadow of an invisible creature that was in the area at the time. How does something invisible (is transparent to light) leave a shadow?

Data's able to modify a flashlight to emit UV light to make the creatures visible on the surface. Yet ship's sensors aren't able to detect the creatures (which leaves the question on how the transporter transports something that it doesn't know is there) can't the ship emit UV light on the planet's surface to find Geordi and the others?

Overall, for me, this is a "meh" episode. It has some good moments in it with Geordi and his former colleague and watching Geordi's investigation of the recording is fairly interesting but at the same time it's hard to really get to wrapped up in the mystery of what was going on. Which is sort of a function of putting a main character in peril.

The remastering of the episode looks really good and I'd have to go back and check the DVD but it seems something was "added" to the effects of the eyes on Geordi's colleague as she lays on the biobed in sickbay mid-transformation. I'm sure some video effect or contacts were used in the original version of the episode but here they seem to have a more vivid "glowing" effect, sort of like a cat's eyes at night.

Some nice character moments with Data as his "concerns" over Geordi's wellbeing seem to motivate him more during the investigation. Not much is given to Picard or Riker to do here, which gives Geordi that much more time to shine in the episode.

Good, but not great.

Next week, however.... Oy.
 
Last edited:
Ugh. I found this one to be just plain bad. I guess one of the advantages of TOS not getting more seasons is the fact they didn't have to do much in the way of episodes that focused on secondary characters.

Any time you got a Geordi episode, it was like getting a Lisa episode of The Simpsons. You knew the odds of it being watchable were not good.
 
Ugh. I found this one to be just plain bad. I guess one of the advantages of TOS not getting more seasons is the fact they didn't have to do much in the way of episodes that focused on secondary characters.

Yeah, I can certainly see that. It's not an episode I over enjoy or watch often. I've warmed to it the more more I watch it but it's not an overly fantastic episode.
 
This episode probably features the best use of a holodeck in Star Trek. That entire scene was well done. As for the rest of the episode, it was just ok. Did like the effects of the alien species though.
 
This episode probably features the best use of a holodeck in Star Trek. That entire scene was well done. As for the rest of the episode, it was just ok. Did like the effects of the alien species though.

Yeah, it was great use of the holodeck, More reason why LCARS Glass should be more common.

If I'm not mistaken popular (well, at the time) Disc Jockeys/radio show hosts Mark and Brian played the other two alien creatures.
 
Surprised at the reaction to this episode, it's one of my all time favorites. The holodeck scene is probably the creepiest moment in the show. Where he sees a shadow and all of sudden he's in pain and his hands have changed. It's a good episode to watch on Halloween.

The fact that Geordie can be saved at the end is very far fetched though, much like that episode with Worf's spine injury, but I'll suspend my disbelief.
 
I liked this episode because of the creepy vibes too. Also because of that 25th Anniversary Special VHS, this episode sticks in my memory more than most. It's funny that Geordi can seemingly have such a close relationship with Leijten, yet he always strikes out with ladies romantically.

He had a credit on Reunion with 3 others a few months prior, but this fully kicks off Brannon Braga's interesting 14 year career with Star Trek. Thus begins the familiar Braga storylines involving alien parasites, space/time distortions, mindscrews, bad science, creepy romances, copious amounts of technobabble, and the occasional 'f#%& you' to the audience (Fury, A Night in Sickbay, Zero Hour teaser, TATV).

Did Star Trek change once Michael Piller joined? Yup. Did Star Trek change again once Brannon Braga joined? Big time.

Wait a minute .... Braga script, stolen shuttlecraft landed on an alien planet and then abandoned, human bodies being modified into animals (also Genesis), this is just a prototype for Threshold. You got it right the first time, Braga.

Braga's first evolution and/or parasite episode - Identity Crisis, good. Braga's first space/time distortion episode - Cause and Effect, good. Braga's first mindscrew episode - Schisms, good. His regular themes popped up in his scripts often, but they were never quite as good as his first try.

Next week, however.... Oy.

Wait, what? I thought everyone liked The Nth Degree.
 
Last edited:
The Nth Degree is one of Season 4's most underrated episodes, so I'm looking forward to that thread. You talk about seeking out new life and a Star Trek vibe to it, The Nth Degree delivered that.
 
The Nth Degree is one of Season 4's most underrated episodes, so I'm looking forward to that thread. You talk about seeking out new life and a Star Trek vibe to it, The Nth Degree delivered that.

The Nth Degree is one of my favorite episodes from all of Star Trek.
 
I guess it's an okay episode I just have some issues with it, I like Barclay as a character but the episode for me just really didn't work. But that's a discussion for next week.
 
I'm curious why you guys don't like Geordie that much. IMO the fact that he strikes out with women makes him more interesting than typical playboys Riker/Kirk. Realistically though I would think he'd be getting a lot more dates having the prestige of chief engineer. He has an interesting sort of jerky attitude at times.

He seems to get a lot of great holodeck scenes up to this point in the series. Sherlock with Data, Leah Brahms, now this investigation.

Infact I sort of wished they focused on him a little more. I wish they never got rid of the Visor in the movies though, it's so iconic to the character.
 
One of my favorite episodes of season 4 and a favorite of those centering on Geordi. I always his friendship with Leijten presented here, the investigation and creepy nature of the transformation. Plus, the creepy notion of those other team members completely lost to the change, now living on that planet. Great stuff!
 
it was like getting a Lisa episode of The Simpsons. You knew the odds of it being watchable were not good.

Lisa episodes are some of the best in the show. Mr. Bergstrom, Lisa becomes a vegetarian, Kidz News, Lisa Lionheart, when she gets the pony, Lisa's wedding, the one where she gives Ralph a Valentine's Day card. Back when the show was still good, so were the Lisa episodes.
 
"We're trying to impress people here, Lisa. You don't win friends with salad. ...... You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad." :lol:
 
"We're trying to impress people here, Lisa. You don't win friends with salad. ...... You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad. You don't win friends with salad." :lol:

:lol:

That was classic.
 
Are all of the away team members in this episode going to need to be treated as well?
It seems reasonable that they would be.

Plus, the creepy notion of those other team members completely lost to the change, now living on that planet. Great stuff!
This struck me as wrong, even if your colleagues can't be be treated and would be permanently changed, you don't simply abandon them on the planet for the rest of their lives. You take them with you and care for them, if they're "infectious" you take that in to account.

It kind of like the way Chakotay abandoned Janeway and Paris's salamander children. They're not like us, so leave them in a swamp to be eaten.

:)
 
Plus, the creepy notion of those other team members completely lost to the change, now living on that planet. Great stuff!
This struck me as wrong, even if your colleagues can't be be treated and would be permanently changed, you don't simply abandon them on the planet for the rest of their lives. You take them with you and care for them, if they're "infectious" you take that in to account.

The idea seemed to be that these creatures weren't "intelligent", perhaps only driven on instinct and very primitive. I'm not sure what benefit taking them would serve especially given the creatures are invisible and seem to be hostilely driven to the planet.
 
A bit of rationalizing and in-universe musing:

Are all of the away team members in this episode going to need to be treated as well?
A good question. And we don't know if anything preemptive can be done about the transformation, or if treating of the symptoms (as with Leijten and LaForge) is the only possible course of action.

It's also a question on how such an organism developed in the first place since its entire way of reproduction seems to be dependent on alien visitors to be "infected."
Not necessarily. Surely any host from the planet itself would also suffice? It's just that the "reproduction disease" doesn't differentiate: it hits local and foreign life equally easily, which means that space travelers can fall victim to it, too.

Sapient victims are probably very rare, but there could be a less intelligent type of biped on the planet that is the usual victim. Just as possibly, though, the "disease" can take over any type of lifeform and then turn that into a roughly corresponding "blacklight only" lifeform - the ones made of humans are tall and apelike, but there are also ones made of local tortoises or ostriches. Those won't be "incompatible" with each other, because the lifeform is the fancy blacklight network on the body, and the actual body is sort of incidental to this all...

So... Why isn't someone wearing these devices on EVERY away mission? Hell, why does it even need to be a device you wear on your head? Couldn't a tricorder record everything around it (even if it can't visually see it) while being active but still holstered?
Probably a tricorder can do it, and does do it on a regular basis, which is why nobody bothers with the headsets. It's just that this is the only episode where somebody wants to inspect the 3D visuals afterwards. (Spock made use of apparent 2D visual recordings way back in "City on the Edge of Forever", but for all we know, he could have played them back in 3D as well, if not for having to work with stone knives and bearskins.)

I guess the real question here is, was there a period of time when 3D visuals required the use of a clumsy recording headset, and technology then moved forward? Or did the guy from the Victory wear a non-Starfleet headset in addition to donning a more regular recording device, possibly because capturing imagery was his hobby? We see those headsets, or things very similar to them, being used by reporters in ST:GEN. Perhaps a news agency had asked for the officer to wear the set for them?

Note that the imagery LaForge goes through doesn't come solely from the headset: there are many viewing angles that would not be available from visuals made by the headset at all (chiefly, top-down ones), and would be pure "extrapolation" rather than "interpolation". For all we know, LaForge used multiple sources such as Starfleet-issue tricorder recordings, but relied heavily on the civilian headset because of its (unnecessarily) good recording quality.

He's able to conclude that it's the shadow of an invisible creature that was in the area at the time. How does something invisible (is transparent to light) leave a shadow?
We know those things reflect/block ultraviolet light. So the total intensity of radiation going through a creature is indeed decreased. In certain circumstances, there'd be a shadow from that, but not that dark in the visible band.

Then again, remember that this is LaForge going through the material. He'd spot a decrease in UV intensity just as surely as a decrease in visual light, even if he didn't quite realize what he was seeing. But given the nature of the imagery, he could not see the creatures themselves unless they happened to bathe in light that contained a respectable quantity of ultraviolet. Apparently, the only light down on the planet that did this was the one casting that particular shadow! (Not the headset light, mind you...)

So there would be a recording that shows reflected/absorbed UV only in certain viewing angles, and if LaForge turned around in the holosimulation and looked at a lifeform that had stood there, out of the UV light, he would not see anything.

Data's able to modify a flashlight to emit UV light to make the creatures visible on the surface. Yet ship's sensors aren't able to detect the creatures (which leaves the question on how the transporter transports something that it doesn't know is there) can't the ship emit UV light on the planet's surface to find Geordi and the others?
We have seen Kirk achieve that with a couple of hundred satellites. But that was pretty risky to the people down below, and only done because the alternative was even worse. Giving the entire planet a solarium treatment might be doable, but doing it locally, with handsets, would be just about as effective. Although they really should have done it from a shuttle or a hovering drone...

As regards the transporter, it often moves items it doesn't recognize, or items that aren't part of the "manifest" - people jumping into the beam at the last moment, say. Apparently, it's not a careful process of scanning everything and then sending it forward, but more like launching an "effect" that propagates along the targeted people or items until it has encompassed them and "phased" them, following laws of physics rather than any instructions sent from the control console. That is, just like a phaser beam propagates along the victim's body until the entire body is vaporized, but not the air around it: this takes no "scanning", just "injecting" the deadly effect and letting it spread.

Enough technobabble for now... I guess I like this one partially for its technological merits, but not the ones mentioned above. I'm more fond of the effort that went into the props: the outpost structures, the "landed" shuttlepod, the use of the darkness/ultraviolet effects.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top