• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Uncanny Valley...

TedShatner10

Commodore
Commodore
When I was a toddler I watched Thunderbirds and for some reason it subconciously distrubed me in a profound way, making me cry violently. I found the fairly lifelike but not human puppets unsettling, and they gave me vivid nightmares, in the disconcertain way they moved and talked. That must've been the Uncanny Valley effect: the more realistic a puppet/animated character/robot gets, the more overtly eerie and ghoulish it is. That is why CGI movies with less realistic characters in them (such as Antz and Finding Nemo) are generally well received, while CGI movies featuring more human like characters are generally panned (like The Polar Express which might as well been renamed The Haunted Dummy Express).

A Japanese animatronics artist, Masahiro Mori, was the first person to coin the term, "Uncanny Valley", after a robot copy of her daughter invoked a negative reaction in her. In science fiction, the Uncanny Valley effect is occasionally used in the depiction of androids and cyborgs - Mr. Data's attempt at laughter in this video at 0:55 is more scary than the alien brainbugs that came on later in that episode. The Borg drones are also somewhere in the Valley, especially when they are "sleeping" in their alcoves.

Of course the Uncanny Valley predominantly features in The Terminator, especially when the T-800s passing as humans are seriously damaged and revealing their mechanical innards. Also when Skynet first attempted to make its android soldiers pass off as human, they had rubber skin as their disguise, which was a dismal failure. Some people theorise why there is a subconscious Uncanny Valley and it is some kind of alarm mechanism to catch out people who are seriously ill or injured and (perhaps controversially) also pick out people who are mentally disabled. I personally think very drunk people belong in the Valley as well.
 
I always wondered why I dislike all these new mega-CGI movies. Now I know. :) Gimme a good old-fashioned actor with rubber bumps on his nose any day. :)
 
it is a fascinating phenomena- it also explains why people find mannaquins & those victorian dolls with glass eyes creepy, but not the Muppets(the human characters specifically) or kewpie dolls.

also this = :eek:

and this = :wtf:
 
What about this?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tevmq_op-qQ

Not quite as scary, but interesting.

I find robots more intimidating, in that their physical presence intrude into my world. There's also the fact that their responses are just programmed. Silvia is more interesting in that she independently tailors her responses to each question.
 
When I was a kid and even now the thing that distrubed me about Thunderbirds was not the puppets but their environment. Those endless landscapes, roads and citites that appear completely empty of life really freak me out. OTOH, when I was a small child Rupert the Bear really, frightened me and I can remember being reduced to tears by it.
 
What about this?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tevmq_op-qQ

Not quite as scary, but interesting.

I find robots more intimidating, in that their physical presence intrude into my world. There's also the fact that their responses are just programmed. Silvia is more interesting in that she independently tailors her responses to each question.

wow, now imagine that inside one of those robots I linked to above! :eek:

btw she says she likes Van Goh, but how does she "see"(as in see a painting)? or is that just b/c her creator programmed her to like Van Goh?
 
I liked Thunderbirds and Captain Scarlet, so I think I'm mostly immune to Uncanny Valley Syndrome. But I do think that the closer computer animation (and robots) get to complete realism, the more small flaws stand out and cause distraction. As far as CGI goes, I think it won't be long before films can be made entirely by computer that are indistinguishable from films made in the real world; in fact, I think it could be done now if they put their minds to it.
 
Although still quite spooky Milo is a good example of CGI getting better.

The "Uncanny Valley" occurs because we see something that looks and acts somewhat like a living person, but we know it is not a living person, and it is like watching an animated corpse.

The Uncanny Valley effect was played for laughs in Men In Black and Galaxy Quest; in Men In Black an insect alien wears a dead person's skin to blend in and in Galaxy Quest we have non-humanoid aliens similar in mentality to the Pakleds who make a brave attempt at passing off as human, but failing badly, and acting like characters from The Sims.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top