Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Bale)
- Thread starter Dream
- Start date
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
I have one of those free movie ticket codes you get from DVDs/Blu-rays for Ice Age. Since it comes out the same day as Public Enemies, I'm going to try to find a theater that accepts the ticket and is showing both movies at about the same time and sneak into that one.
I have one of those free movie ticket codes you get from DVDs/Blu-rays for Ice Age. Since it comes out the same day as Public Enemies, I'm going to try to find a theater that accepts the ticket and is showing both movies at about the same time and sneak into that one.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
Dillinger- This town deserves a better class of criminal, and i'm going to give it to them.........
Sorry but the similarities to "The Dark Knight" posters are funny.
Dillinger- This town deserves a better class of criminal, and i'm going to give it to them.........
Sorry but the similarities to "The Dark Knight" posters are funny.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
Should be pretty awesome. All of the right elements are certainly there.
Should be pretty awesome. All of the right elements are certainly there.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
I'm planning on seeing it tomorrow afternoon...Canada Day and all...so I'm hoping everyone will be going to take their families to either Revenge of the Fallen or Ice Age 3. I've been looking forward to it since I first saw the trailers...it looks awesome.
I'm planning on seeing it tomorrow afternoon...Canada Day and all...so I'm hoping everyone will be going to take their families to either Revenge of the Fallen or Ice Age 3. I've been looking forward to it since I first saw the trailers...it looks awesome.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
Roger Ebert gives it *** 1/2.
Roger Ebert gives it *** 1/2.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
It does look cool. I may give it a check.
It does look cool. I may give it a check.
Thespeckledkiwi
Vice Admiral
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
I might see this movie but it feels weird. My family was apart of that gang
I might see this movie but it feels weird. My family was apart of that gang
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
Bank robbery: a game the whole family can play!
I might see this movie but it feels weird. My family was apart of that gang
Bank robbery: a game the whole family can play!
Thespeckledkiwi
Vice Admiral
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
Yeah...technically my aunt didn't rob banks but she -uh- was associated with Homer.
I might see this movie but it feels weird. My family was apart of that gang
Bank robbery: a game the whole family can play!
Yeah...technically my aunt didn't rob banks but she -uh- was associated with Homer.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
I'm looking forward to seeing this, but I've been disappointed to find that many of the reviews have been surprisingly mixed. Even Ebert hesitates to call it a "great movie." Still: Michael Mann, Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, and Marion Cottilard. It doesn't seem like that could go wrong.
I'm looking forward to seeing this, but I've been disappointed to find that many of the reviews have been surprisingly mixed. Even Ebert hesitates to call it a "great movie." Still: Michael Mann, Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, and Marion Cottilard. It doesn't seem like that could go wrong.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
It seems that the general consensus is that this is less one of Mann's great story films, like Heat and Collateral, and more one of his "Okay, this is what happened, now I'm going to make it look really, really cool, okay, bye," films, like Ali and The Insider. So I'm pretty sure I'll still dig it.
It seems that the general consensus is that this is less one of Mann's great story films, like Heat and Collateral, and more one of his "Okay, this is what happened, now I'm going to make it look really, really cool, okay, bye," films, like Ali and The Insider. So I'm pretty sure I'll still dig it.
Re: Public Enemies - Grading and Discussion (Johnny Depp, Christian Ba
^Now that I've seen it, I think that analysis is right on the money.
Public Enemies is a good movie. A really good movie, in fact. But, like Ebert, I thought it lacked that little extra something that would have made it a great movie.
In my case, I think that little extra something was characterization. Dillinger is probably the only fully-realized character in the film. And that's very unfortunate, because Mann drops all sorts of intriguing hints about his law-enforcement characters.
The impression I got was that Purvis was out of his depth in the manhunt for Dillinger--that he had been promoted too quickly by the power- and headline-hungry Hoover. He made poor decisions, under pressure, and then acted recklessly, trying to compensate for those poor decisions--and in the process, he came into conflict with one of his subordinates, Agent Winstead. This, the movie seemed to hint, made Purvis almost as much a 'public enemy' as Dillinger.
But, frustratingly, the law-enforcement side of the story wasn't fully developed, and all we got were hints. Bale was as watchable as ever, but his Purvis remained something of a cipher, compared to Depp's Dillinger.
On the positive side--this was a very well-made and authentic-seeming historical crime drama. The gunfights were particularly well-staged, and as with Heat I was particularly impressed by the sound of what was happening. The acting was quite good, as was the direction and pacing: it seemed a lot shorter than 2 hours and 20 minutes.
But without a fully-developed antagonist for Dillinger in the form of Purvis, the film couldn't quite reach the heights of Heat or Collateral. So it wound up being just "above average" instead of "excellent," in my opinion.
^Now that I've seen it, I think that analysis is right on the money.
Public Enemies is a good movie. A really good movie, in fact. But, like Ebert, I thought it lacked that little extra something that would have made it a great movie.
In my case, I think that little extra something was characterization. Dillinger is probably the only fully-realized character in the film. And that's very unfortunate, because Mann drops all sorts of intriguing hints about his law-enforcement characters.
The impression I got was that Purvis was out of his depth in the manhunt for Dillinger--that he had been promoted too quickly by the power- and headline-hungry Hoover. He made poor decisions, under pressure, and then acted recklessly, trying to compensate for those poor decisions--and in the process, he came into conflict with one of his subordinates, Agent Winstead. This, the movie seemed to hint, made Purvis almost as much a 'public enemy' as Dillinger.
But, frustratingly, the law-enforcement side of the story wasn't fully developed, and all we got were hints. Bale was as watchable as ever, but his Purvis remained something of a cipher, compared to Depp's Dillinger.
On the positive side--this was a very well-made and authentic-seeming historical crime drama. The gunfights were particularly well-staged, and as with Heat I was particularly impressed by the sound of what was happening. The acting was quite good, as was the direction and pacing: it seemed a lot shorter than 2 hours and 20 minutes.
But without a fully-developed antagonist for Dillinger in the form of Purvis, the film couldn't quite reach the heights of Heat or Collateral. So it wound up being just "above average" instead of "excellent," in my opinion.
Last edited: