• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Movies that play very differently when you switch the genders?

The Borgified Corpse

Admiral
Admiral
Sometimes you can tell what gender double standards still exist when you think about how certain movies would play out with reversed genders.

The Proposal is a perfect example. A verbally abusive boss bribes, blackmails, & bullies an employee into getting engaged to avoid deportation. When the boss is a woman, it makes for highly profitable romantic comedy hijinks. If the boss were a man, it would be a horrific, over-the-top Lifetime drama.

Chicago is another movie that plays very differently switching the genders around. I think it could still work but it would play as a much, much darker comedy than it already is. Amidst all of the music & glamour, it's easy to forget that the main character is a petty murderer when that murderer is a tiny waif like Renee Zelwegger. But if it were about a bunch of men who murdered their girlfriends for petty reasons then tried to parlay that infamy into a showbiz career, it would just have an extra, unseemly layer of nihilistic ick to it.

On the other hand, frankly, I'm curious to see what The Rocky Horror Picture Show would be like if you switched both Dr. Frank Furter & Rocky to women.

What are some other movies that would either be improved or turned offensive by switching the genders around?
 
12 Angry Men. :vulcan:

I'd actually really like to see that. They've done stage versions that use a mixture of men & women but I don't think that would work. So much of the play is about men and how these assorted male archetypes interact in an all male environment. Adding women creates a completely different, more guarded, more "civilized" situation. But I would be interested in seeing the flip side of that emotional cauldron, where it's all women.
 
more "civilized" situation.

:lol: A room full of angry women...civilized?!

To quote several of my female friends: "Girls are bitches." That jury room would be a fucking nightmare.

At that point, I was referring to a mixed gender room. My point is that I think we both tend to behave ourselves more (or at least misbehave in a very different way) when we're surrounded by both men & women.
 
Species: beautiful female alien has sex with men, then kills them horribly . . . . a fun guilty-pleasure movie.

Species 2: a male alien has sex with women, then kills then horribly . . . much more unpleasant.
 
Eyes Wide Shut: Having Nicole Kidman as the alienated one who goes out on a journey of sexual discovery would make the film far more interesting.

Brokeback Mountain: If you switched one of the leads' gender, the movie would be about heterosexual adultery and therefore contain no controversy and suck.

Titanic: Kate Winslet playing the shabby artist and Leonardo DiCaprio as the young socialite who she falls in love with. Could be interesting, but then again a woman playing a travelling artist in an early 20th century drama?

Black Swan: Male Ballet dancer with split personality disorder... Billy Elliot meets Fight Club (just no!)

Alien: If Ripley was male (as it was originally planned) the movie wouldn't have been as interesting as it was. It would be unoriginal (tough male lead fights off hostile alien) and not as accesible to women. Let's face it, Ripley inspired so many heroines in sci-fi.
 
Brokeback Mountain: If you switched one of the leads' gender, the movie would be about heterosexual adultery and therefore contain no controversy and suck.

Ah, but if you switched both leads gender than you'd have a movie about lesbian cowgirls. Score!
 
was originally planned) the movie wouldn't have been as interesting as it was. It would be unoriginal (tough male lead fights off hostile alien) and not as accesible to women. Let's face it, Ripley inspired so many heroines in sci-fi.
But a male Ripley, with a female Captain, first officer, android, both engineers. The only other guy on the crew is the (somewhat) cowardly navigator.

The girl Captain dies in the air vent, the girl first officer is the chest "bursted,", the girl engineer "kills" the girl android.

And in the end the boy is the only survivor.


"Pretty Man" about a rich woman falling in love with a callboy?
This could work.
------
Fight Club, with a gender reversal, would be either better or just a modern cliche.

When I first heard rumors of Star Trek Eleven, I thought of the possibility of gender reversals, like what Ron Moore did with some of the characters in BSG. If all the characters in Star Trek Eleven were flipped ... interesting.

:)
 
Wedding Crashers - Switch Vince Vaughn's character to female, have the male "Isla Fisher" character scare the shit out of her, tie her down to the bed against her will, rape her, then have her learn to like it to the point where she falls in love with him. A little different than that whimsical way it's actually portrayed in the movie.

40 Days and 40 Nights - Have the main character's ex-boyfriend have sex with her against her will while she's chained to a bed. Then have her apologize to her current boyfriend because it was all her fault while the ex-boyfriend gets away scot-free.
 
12 Angry Men. :vulcan:

I'd actually really like to see that. They've done stage versions that use a mixture of men & women but I don't think that would work. So much of the play is about men and how these assorted male archetypes interact in an all male environment. Adding women creates a completely different, more guarded, more "civilized" situation. But I would be interested in seeing the flip side of that emotional cauldron, where it's all women.

I've seen the Stewart role be done by a woman. Does change the whole nature of Cobb's character's anger towards the Stewart role a bit more darker in that respect.
 
Sleepless in Seattle

When you look at the basics, it's pretty much a stalker film. Annie Reed uses company resources to send a private investigator to follow Sam Baldwin, a man she started obsessing over after hearing him on the radio. She later flies to Seattle and watches him through binoculars, and then goes to confront him when he's with his son and sister.

A woman does that, and it's romantic.

A man does that, and it's jail time.
 
Kill Bill: The Bride becomes The Groom and goes on a revenge spree against his former assassin crew. Wouldn't really make much difference I suppose, but the protagonist being female gave it that edge.

Die Hard: John McClane becomes Jane McClane a rogue police officer who fights off a terrorist threat in her husband's office building. Meg Ryan plays Jane, imagine the totally bizarre elements of the movie as a petite blonde fights off German terrorists in hand to hand combat and celebrating with cigarettes and one liners like "Yippe Ky Yay Motherfucker"?!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top