• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How do/did you feel about the return of the Enterprise-D?

TroiFan4ever

Commander
Red Shirt
I seriously wish I could go back and relive it. In the episode "Võx" when the doors to Hangar Bay 12 opened with the lights turning on one by one to reveal the Enterprise-D, I was absolutely awestruck. I had my hands covering my mouth that night I watched it.

Seeing the main crew of TNG back on that bridge again was quite an experience. It was like watching a new episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation but in widescreen format. I also love the dynamic to it that there's an urgent situation that is the Borg having assimilated every other Starfleet vessel and everyone below the age of 24, then the threat of Earth's destruction if not stopped. But they allow themselves a moment to admire the beauty of the recreated D bridge.

The whole experience of that scene at the end of "Võx" and all of "The Last Generation" and seeing the Enterprise-D takes me back to my childhood, back to the 1990s watching Star Trek: The Next Generation on my old CTR television on UPN 57 (WPSG out of Philadelphia, Pa). I really miss those days and these two episodes gave me a real glimpse of that experience but I guess a more modern version of it since this was Star Trek: Picard watching on Paramount+.

Ironically, the very first scene of the show was Picard having a dream of him and Data playing poker in Enterprise-D's Ten Forward but since then I always imagined what it would be like to see the much-older cast on her bridge, thinking it was never going to happen! But it did!

I also love the very beginning of "The Last Generation" how it started with a piece of the S3-S7 opening of TNG and seeing Picard in the captain's seat. I like everyone being in their usual positions on TNG but I especially enjoyed Picard in the captain's chair, especially with Troi to his left and Riker to his right. Too bad he wasn't in it a lot in "The Last Generation". My other favorite part was the way Data flew the ship into the Borg cube with that dramatic music playing with a lot of laser bolts shooting at it.

That was the Star Trek surprise of the century! I'll leave it there for now. :):D:hugegrin:
 
Many immediate reaction from when it came out are here:
https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/the-thing-in-bay-12.313808/

When the D crashed, I was just a kid and really sad. It felt a little like I lost a friend. The E was great, and quickly grabbed the empty spot, but it took a while to get over never seeing the D again, and her lying on a random planet like a pile of trash, rotting away. Now little me is alright again :techman:

Ramping it up and up stepwise was brilliant. First the hints of where we're going. :)
Then the doors open and we see a shadowy silhouette of what seems to be the D. :drool:
Then closeup of the hull markings confirming it! Data getting choked up! :biggrin:
Then onto the bridge, which gradually lights up, closeups of consoles initializing!! :eek:
Picard petting the plaque, Crusher (?) stroking the tactical console, Data greeting his chair!!! :weep:
And then MAJEL says hi and Picard takes his old chair and does his thing...

...the drop becomes the ocean. :wah:
 
Not something I was specifically looking for, but I welcomed it. And I can see Geordi as the type who would spend 20 years restoring it. I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy seeing the Enterprise-D being able to move in ways that wouldn't have been possible to pull off on TNG. If you're going to have the TNG crew back together again, it had to be the D.

And I say this as someone whose favorite Enterprise is the A. I also like the G, even though I think the back of it is over-designed. The only one I don't like is the F.
 
Last edited:
I'm not made of stone. As mixed as my opinion is on that season of television, I'll admit to my eyes getting a little misty when we first saw her. Which is saying something as the D is definitely not my favourite Enterprise.

That said, that feeling was pretty much eradicated when Data decided he needed to fly the Millennium Falcon Enterprise into the Death Star Borg Cube and destroyed its Reactor Beacon.

That was dumb.
 
That said, that feeling was pretty much eradicated when Data decided he needed to fly the Millennium Falcon Enterprise into the Death Star Borg Cube and destroyed its Reactor Beacon.

That was dumb.
That whole sequence is going to be immortalized in Ships of the Line calendars for years to come. It's going to get to the point where we'll be begging for a new Enterprise and fighter jet from Tomorrow is Yesterday.
 
Definitely something I never knew I wanted, but was appreciated when it happened (the score really helps here as well!). GEN is such a mixed bag that the destruction of E-D was relatively glossed over, unlike the original Enterprise in TSFS. Yeah they wanted a new ship with new sets for the following movies.

And I'm sure some quips will be made about ROTJ... but for all we know this was the PS3 team implementing a note from above asking for something Star Wars-y. ROTJ is far more welcome than TLJ!
 
I was slightly spoiled, but still chocked up and had to blink a few tears away.

Meaning I was an emotional wreck about it and I felt like we were re-introduced to a long lost character of the show.
 
I loved it. I only don't understand why they didn't upgrade the ship and bring it back in the fleet because of all the ships the fleet lost

Can you imagine the nuclear explosion in fandom of at the end of the finale, it wasn't the Titan-A rechristened as the Enterprise-G but it was the D, now retrofitted into that three nacelle monstrosity from All Good Things?
Dear Lord that would have been funny as fuck.
 
Can you imagine the nuclear explosion in fandom of at the end of the finale, it wasn't the Titan-A rechristened as the Enterprise-G but it was the D, now retrofitted into that three nacelle monstrosity from All Good Things?
Dear Lord that would have been funny as fuck.

I would pay to see that :D
Or just rename it USS Picard or USS Firefly ;)
 
To me, the return of the Enterprise-D was kind of silly. I understand it was nostalgia and a way to send the TNG cast off with the ship they began with, but in-universe it made no sense. The saucer section of the Enterprise-D should have been scrapped for parts a long time ago, IMO. I think the resources used to restore the ship could have been better used for other ships intended for active service, not one destined to sit in a museum.

USS ENTERPRISE NCC-1701-D
Commissioned: 2363
First Deployment: 2364
Destroyed In Action: 2371
Restored: 2401
Decommissioned: 2401
 
The YouTube clip of the TNG cast returning to the Enterprise-D bridge has almost 2 million views and over 7 thousand comments, and what struck me was how effusive and emotional some of those comments are.

There are people that are thankful and love that they went through the trouble of recreating it, but there's also comments about how the moment hit an emotional center with a lot of people. There are comments where people talk about watching TNG with parents that are now gone, and how seeing the Enterprise-D with all the cast in their places again brought them to tears.
 
The YouTube clip of the TNG cast returning to the Enterprise-D bridge has almost 2 million views and over 7 thousand comments, and what struck me was how effusive and emotional some of those comments are.

There are people that are thankful and love that they went through the trouble of recreating it, but there's also comments about how the moment hit an emotional center with a lot of people. There are comments where people talk about watching TNG with parents that are now gone, and how seeing the Enterprise-D with all the cast in their places again brought them to tears.
Oh no, this will give the nihilists in our midst another reason to clutch their pearls:D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top