• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

COMICS: Difference between layout, inks, finished and colors

Tino

Captain
Captain
Hi there,

I just finished "Spock Reflections" and found David Messinas artwork excellent - as usual.
But I wonder how much of the graphic is really his. So I checked the imprint and came to
wonder about the differences between layout, inks, finishes and colors.

Can anyone explain those differences to me?
 
I'm thinking they correspond, in that order, to the roles of penciller, inker, letterer, and colorist.
 
A penciller works from the script, drawing the entire story one artboard 1.5x larger than the printed comic book. All the details are there to be seen, allowing room for captions, word balloons, and sound effects. The different between pencils and layouts is the amount of detail, especially when it comes to spotting where the black areas go that gives a panel weight.

An inker uses pens or brushes, working with india ink, to complete the artwork and ready it for reprodiction. Since the inker has a style of his/her own, you're hoping the comibination of talents brings a pleasing result. An inker can be said to finish or embellish layouts, adding lots of background details, texture, and "spotting" the black areas.

A colorist works from a scan of the finished art and, using PhotoShop, adds color which can make or break a story since it should be helping the overall storytelling.

Does this help?
 
My understanding was that you could have a penciller doing rather detailed drawings that were then gone over by an inker, or you could have a layout artist doing rougher drawings that were then given more detail in ink by a finisher. So that the division of work was different in a penciller/inker team than in a layout/finisher team. So I'm a little unclear on how one book can have credits for layout, inker, and finisher all at once.
 
Just tapdancing here till Bob comes back, Christopher, but sometimes diferent parts of a book are done by different creative combinations--especially when that issue is nudging up against (or well past) a deadline.
 
A penciller works from the script, drawing the entire story one artboard 1.5x larger than the printed comic book. All the details are there to be seen, allowing room for captions, word balloons, and sound effects. The different between pencils and layouts is the amount of detail, especially when it comes to spotting where the black areas go that gives a panel weight.

An inker uses pens or brushes, working with india ink, to complete the artwork and ready it for reprodiction. Since the inker has a style of his/her own, you're hoping the comibination of talents brings a pleasing result. An inker can be said to finish or embellish layouts, adding lots of background details, texture, and "spotting" the black areas.

A colorist works from a scan of the finished art and, using PhotoShop, adds color which can make or break a story since it should be helping the overall storytelling.

Does this help?
What would you know about it? ;)
 
Some of the artists for Spock Reflections have another relationship. David Messina is also an art teacher. I believe some of the artists who worked on Reflections were his students. I would expect them to work well together, however the work is divided up.
 
layouts- very rough minimal drawings depicting the character action and panel positions. NOT full art.

pencils - literally the penciled art, fully realized, that makes a comic book a comic book. Full detail but not inked.

inks- same as above with one distinction. inkers do not "trace" the pencilled art. They are artists in their own right, adding nuance and tone to the pencilled art, in theory enhancing it.

Finished art - this can mean either art that has been pencilled and inked or it can mean art that has been pencilled, inked and colored. It does not include lettering.
 
Last edited:
And then there are "breakdowns" which if I remember correctly are somewhere in between layouts and full pencils.
 
And then there are "breakdowns" which if I remember correctly are somewhere in between layouts and full pencils.

Breakdowns and layouts are essentially the same thing, or are so close as to not really make much of a difference, though some artists can be very particular about what constitutes what. At that point, though, it's pretty much just splitting hairs, if there even are any hairs to split.

To answer the original question, though: "finishes" is simply a term used when you're also using the term/s breakdowns or layouts. You really wouldn't see credits that include a penciller and a finisher at the same time.

To understand the difference between layouts and pencils, remember that pre-ink comic book art really occurs in two main phases: the layouts, where the artist chooses the camera angles, positions the figures (who at this point are just blank bodies), anticipates where the word balloons might go, etc.

The finishing phase is where the artist goes back and fills in the specifics--turning ovals into faces, geometric blocks into computer consoles, detailing the uniforms, etc.

Keep in mind that these are distinctly different skills. A good breakdown artist has to really know sequential visual storytelling, how to create pacing and tension in the shots, how to move the reader's eye around the page, etc. The finishing artist is where what most people think of as the "style" comes in--in other words, why Frank Miller's art looks like Frank Miller's or Jim Lee's looks like Jim Lee's.

Some artists have a great visual style, but are desperately lacking in sequential storytelling skills--and that's when you see comics that look like a series of poses and page pinups when they handle all the pencils themselves.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top