I agree with this, I never liked Vic. The bar was a useless location because it was inside Quark's which was already a bar the crew could hang out in and Vic as a character was so weird. He knew he was a hologram for example, what's the point of the 50s setting then when Vic knows he's not living in the 50s. And I hated the songs, I always fast forward through them.
As someone who watched Time Tunnel, I loved the addition of James Darren to DS9. Tony was my favorite Time Tunnel character.
I don't see a problem with a hologram knowing he's a hologram. There were several holodeck characters on TNG who knew they were holograms, and ditto for Voyager.
Why shouldn't Vic live in the 1950s if he wants? The world would be a boring place if nobody embraced cultural elements of the past.
As for Vic having a bar that some of the crew liked to visit, so what? Did Quark have a monopoly on entertainment/food/drink venues on the station? No. At least with Vic running a bar, it's not like he was being paid in real latinum. Quark still got paid for the use of the holodeck even if Vic was doing the actual work.
I'll admit I'm not into that kind of music. But at least James Darren can sing. Singers who can really
sing are in short supply these days.
I'm not sure why they felt like they needed this character at all and so late in the run of the series. Don't get it. I was never a Vic fan. I don't think the character adds anything to the show. Season seven would have been just fine without him
It would have been boring without him. He broke up the godawful relentless Klingon/Bajoran/war soap opera that the show had fallen into.
Here’s some future ideas for threads that seem to be all-time favorites:
- “Jadzia is a dull character. Discuss.”
- “The Mirror Universe episodes suck. Discuss.”
- “Keiko is a bitch and treats Miles horribly. Discuss.”
- “Bajoran politics were booooring. Discuss.”
- “Avery Brooks was a horrible actor. Discuss”
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Sorta; he was actually more annoying than horrible.
I don't wonder. I know. Killing off Jadzia was a deplorable act in itself. Just replacing her right away was worse. Talk about trivializing a character's death!
I never liked Jadzia. Her best contribution was giving Worf an excuse to say "Nice hat."
Considering that one of the concerns that led to Ezri's appearance was that if Jadzia wasn't replaced then there'd be only one woman in the primary cast, I'm a little leery of discussing the idea of keeping Jadzia but in a reduced role if we're all just a bunch of men (which may or may not be the case). Which is to say, I think a female perspective on this could be valuable to the conversation.
In any case, I liked some of the refresh elements that came with Ezri's introduction, and I maintain that Jadzia never would have given Worf the reality check that Ezri did, so keeping her, or at least not introducing Ezri, would have robbed us of a great moment in late S7.
Okay, another female perspective: It's less important how many main female characters are than how
interesting they are.
Here's an example: I've taken a deep dive into BBC Merlin fandom. There are two main female characters: Gwen and Morgana. After the third season Morgana is irredeemably evil, doing absolutely awful things and her default facial expression is a smirk. Gwen was interesting at first - imagine a Guinevere who was a blacksmith's daughter instead of the usual Arthurian ice queen we see in so many depictions. But later on she became chaotic - sometimes icy, sometimes so annoyingly self-righteous, and she had more guest characters executed than Uther Pendragon did.
Where this is going is that neither of these female characters appealed to me. I don't find either of them interesting enough to want to rewatch the episodes that are primarily about them, and I'm not interested in the fanfic about them, nor am I interested in writing about them myself. The female character in that show who does interest me was a guest character in two episodes, and that's Queen Annis. She's interesting and worth reading and writing about.
I always found Jadzia alternately boring, self-righteous, unbelievably ludicrous in how she managed to out-Klingon the Klingons, and I wasn't in the least bit unhappy when she was killed off.
Ezri? The premise was interesting - a joined Trill who didn't want to be joined. That's something they should have explored more, instead of playing it for laughs when Ezri gets all these emotional moments and feels she has to apologize for them. But ultimately Ezri failed to be interesting because she was just there to be Jadzia 2.0.
This female thinks 1) Terry got screwed over; 2) Ezri was a good character anyway; 3) NONE of 90s Trek had more than 2 women in the main cast. VOY had a female captain, but arguably she and Belanna were the main women until Seven showed up - I didn't watch a lot of VOY, but Kes always seemed a secondary character to me. DS9 *could* have used Kassidy or even Keiko more. TNG just had Troi and Crusher.
Ohgoodgrief. No. Kassidy wasn't interesting enough for me to care what happened to her, and Keiko was annoying in most of her episodes. The only time I liked her was when she faced off against Wynn over the school.
The number of women in a cast doesn't matter if they're not interesting, dynamic characters.